Skip to content
QuestionGeneral

Can a prop firm ban two traders for using the same IP address?

@caleb_trading

This is an interesting issue, especially for friends, couples or family members who both trade with prop firms.

Imagine two traders living in the same apartment. They use the same internet connection, but each has their own account, trading strategy and risk management.

One day, both accounts get flagged for suspicious activity or suspected copy trading.

Can sharing an IP address really be enough evidence of a trading rule violation?

I'd like to discuss:

Can prop firms reliably distinguish between copy trading and independent trading?

Should firms investigate individual trading behaviour before terminating accounts?

What evidence should be required before accusing someone of copy trading?

Have you or someone you know experienced an issue like this?

Helpful2

1 reply

  1. @kenjifx#1

    Good question, Caleb. I think sharing an IP address alone should never be enough reason to ban two traders.

    Think about couples, family members or even roommates who both trade. Sharing the same internet connection is completely normal and doesn't mean they are copying each other's trades.

    Of course, prop firms have a responsibility to detect account sharing and coordinated trading, but there should be more to the investigation than just looking at IP addresses.

    Trade history, execution timing, lot sizes and actual trading behaviour should all be considered before making a decision.

    I think the biggest issue here is making sure legitimate traders aren't punished for something they have no control over. There needs to be a clear difference between a suspicious connection and actual evidence of rule violations.