A certificate says one thing: a prop firm met six requirements, checked against evidence, and a named person at Responsible Trading decided it and recorded the reasons. It is not a score and not a ranking, it covers named programs for twelve months, and it can be suspended.
01
Principles
Evidence over claims
A requirement is met only by evidence we have checked. A firm’s statement starts a check; it never finishes one.
We start the review
Firms do not apply. We choose which firms to review and start from public evidence. Where it cannot settle a requirement, we ask the firm for what would; a firm that does not answer within 30 days is judged on public evidence alone.
People decide, scores don’t
The six scores on a passport are our assessment. They never grant or deny a certificate.
Proportionate
Each requirement asks for what a well-run firm of any size can already show, not for audits the industry doesn’t do yet. Where a small firm has too few people for an independent appeal, an outside reviewer counts. Methods for catching abuse can stay confidential; the outcomes for traders can’t.
Independent of money
Reviews carry no fee, and affiliate income has no bearing on a decision. Everyone who reviews or decides declares any conflict of interest and steps aside from that firm if they have one.
A right of reply
Before a decision, the firm sees our findings and has 14 days to correct a fact or add evidence. Its reply is recorded with the decision.
02
The six requirements
Each requirement is met, conditional or not met, on the evidence listed under it. A level is a reviewer’s finding, never a sum.
01
Who you are dealing with
Can a trader tell which company they contract with, and who owns and runs it?
Met
The terms name the contracting company, and every company that sells to, funds or pays traders is named, registered and active. Owners of 25% or more and the directors are confirmed against registers or documents the firm shares with us, and the people in control are named publicly.
Conditional
A registered company is named, but which one contracts with traders, or which one funds or pays them, is unclear; or the owners are disclosed to us but not yet named publicly; or the firm has not answered our request for them.
Not met
No identifiable, active company stands behind the brand, or the firm refuses to disclose its owners to us.
Checked against
Company registers
The terms traders accept
Ownership documents shared with us in confidence
Housekeeping A company number or registered address missing from the firm’s own pages, where a register already shows it.
02
Payouts are paid
Are payouts actually paid, as and when the firm says, by a company that can afford them?
Met
A random sample of payouts requested in the last 90 days (30, or 1% of them if that is more, up to 300; all of them if there were fewer than 30) matches bank, payment-provider or blockchain records, and at least 90% were paid within the time the firm states for that payment method, counted from the trader’s request until the money reaches an account the trader controls (a stated approval window plus a stated sending time make one time); money held in a wallet the firm runs is not yet paid. The contracting company’s latest accounts, or a statement of reserves shared with us, show it can cover the payouts it owes.
Conditional
The sample was paid, but often later than the stated time; the firm states no time for a payment method, or times that contradict each other; part of the sample cannot be matched to records; the company’s ability to pay cannot be shown; or the firm has not shared the records we asked for, so only public evidence speaks for it.
Not met
Payouts that were due were not paid, the firm refuses to evidence them, or the contracting company is insolvent or in insolvency proceedings.
Checked against
Payment-provider and bank statements
Blockchain records
The firm’s payout ledger
Confirmation from sampled traders
The contracting company’s filed accounts, or a statement of reserves shared with us
Housekeeping Payout pages that disagree with each other on fees or methods.
03
Rules a trader can rely on
Can a trader find every rule that decides a pass, a breach or a payout, and trust it not to move?
Met
Each program’s rules, and every document that binds a trader, are published before purchase. Over the last 12 months, every change that affects what a trader may do was dated, and none applied to accounts already bought unless it favoured the trader.
Conditional
A document that binds traders, such as the agreement for a funded account, is not public before purchase; a rule that can cost a payout or an account was added without a date, or without saying which accounts it covers; or a change was applied to accounts already bought without refusing a payout.
Not met
A rule that decides payouts is unpublished, or in the last 12 months rules were changed after purchase to refuse a payout.
Checked against
Program pages, terms and help centre
The firm’s change log
Archived copies of its pages
Housekeeping Official pages that contradict each other on a rule, an undated change to wording that does not alter what a trader may do, and terms that reserve a right to change rules for accounts already bought, until the firm commits in its terms not to use it.
04
Fair enforcement, and a way to appeal
When a firm closes an account, refuses a payout or cuts a trader’s share, does the trader learn why, and can they contest it?
Met
Every refusal, termination or cut share names, in writing, the rule and what the trader did, not only a category of breach; the evidence is kept for twelve months and summarised for the trader on request; a written appeal is decided within 15 business days by someone not involved in the original decision (an outside reviewer counts); and no term lets the firm refuse a payout or close an account because a trader criticised it.
Conditional
Reasons are given, but only as a category of breach; a decision can be looked at again only informally or at the firm’s discretion, such as by asking support or through a review the terms say the firm may give, with no formal appeal, even if the outcome is then called final; or the appeal has no deadline, takes longer than 15 business days, or is decided by the people who made the original decision; or a term lets the firm refuse a payout or close an account for public criticism, though we found no case of it being used.
Not met
Payouts are refused or shares cut without a stated rule; the firm offers no way at all to have a decision looked at again: its terms or help pages declare decisions final and name no review, and nothing shows it reviewing one on request (court or arbitration does not count, since it is open against any firm); or a trader lost a payout or an account for criticising the firm.
Checked against
A sample of refusal and termination notices
The appeal procedure
The terms traders accept
A sample of complaints and their outcomes
Housekeeping An appeal process that exists but is not named in the terms or the help centre.
05
Honest claims
Do the firm’s public claims match the evidence?
Met
Everything the firm publishes, in its terms, website, help centre and advertising, says plainly whether its accounts are simulated or live, and makes no material claim the evidence does not support: that it is regulated or licensed (checked against the regulator’s own record, wherever the claim is made), a broker or a fund, that traders trade real capital, or that payouts are never refused or are guaranteed without saying, where the guarantee is made, what it covers. No review platform has withheld its rating or warned the public because of fake or manipulated reviews.
Conditional
A claim like those is published while the evidence says otherwise, and the firm corrects it within 30 days of our raising it; or, in the last 12 months, a review platform has withheld the firm’s rating or warned the public because of fake or manipulated reviews (a rating withheld for other reasons, such as a pattern of complaints, belongs under standing).
Not met
Materially misleading claims stay up after we raise them, including a claim to a licence that the regulator’s own record contradicts.
Checked against
The firm’s website, terms, help centre, releases and advertising
Regulators’ own registers
Review platforms’ notices on the firm’s profile
The records reviewed for the other requirements
Housekeeping Figures that are undated or disagree with each other, such as payout totals, trader counts, support hours or processing times.
06
Regulatory standing and complaints
Is the firm free of unresolved regulatory action where it sells, and does it answer complaints?
Met
No enforcement action or regulator warning names the firm in a market where it sells (one where it does not sell is noted, not counted); traders have a published way to complain, and most complaints made through it get an answer.
Conditional
A regulator’s warning names the firm in a market where it sells, and the firm is challenging it, has explained it, or has not yet answered our request to explain it; there is no published way to complain; or fewer than half the complaints in a sample get an answer. An unanswered public review is not by itself an unanswered complaint: a firm may answer privately.
Not met
An active ban or enforcement action in a market where the firm sells, or complaints go unanswered.
Checked against
Regulator registers and warning lists, including IOSCO’s alerts database
The firm’s complaint records
A recent sample of public complaints and the firm’s replies
Housekeeping No stated time to answer a complaint.
03
How the outcome is decided
One rule, applied the same way to every firm. No score enters it: the six scores on a passport cannot move it.
Certified
All six requirements are met, a grade of 6 of 6. The certificate is issued once every housekeeping fix is made.
Certified with conditions
None is not met, and at most 5 are conditional, so at least one is met; housekeeping never counts toward that limit. The certificate is issued once every housekeeping fix is made and the firm agrees a dated plan to close each condition within 90 days; the conditions and the grade are shown on the certificate, and it is suspended if a deadline passes.
Not certified
Any requirement is not met, or more than 5 are conditional. We review the firm again once it shows the gaps are fixed, or after six months.
How findings are counted
One fact, one condition
A single fact can bear on two requirements, such as a funded account run by a company the terms do not name. It is counted once, under the requirement it most affects for traders, and noted under the other.
A grade out of six
Every certificate shows a grade: each requirement met counts 1 and each conditional counts ½, out of six. A firm with every requirement met has 6 of 6; one with three met and three conditional has 4.5 of 6. The grade is worked out from the levels, never set by hand, and it is not a score: the six scores on a passport are separate.
The last 12 months, not the day we look
Each requirement looks at what the firm did over the last 12 months, from archived pages and its own change log, so rewriting the terms before a review changes nothing that already happened.
Housekeeping is what a firm can put right in days without changing how it treats traders: its own pages contradicting each other, figures that are undated or disagree, details missing from its own documents. It never counts toward the limit on conditions, so a firm is judged on how it treats traders, not on how tidy its website is. But every housekeeping fix is made, and checked, before a certificate is issued. A new rule that can cost a payout is never housekeeping, dated or not.
Try the rule
Set a level for each requirement to see the outcome the rule gives. Housekeeping is left out, as in the rule. It shows how the rule works; it assesses no firm.
Outcome under this method
Certified
Grade 6 of 6
Every requirement is met.
04
From review to decision
01
Selection
We choose which firms to review; firms do not apply.
02
Review
One reviewer, Reigo Tooming, checks the evidence for each requirement and records a level, with the evidence behind it.
03
Questions to the firm
Where public evidence cannot settle a requirement, we write to the firm for what would, such as its owners, a payout sample or refusal notices; what it shares stays confidential. If it does not answer within 30 days, the requirement is judged on public evidence alone, and one that only the firm’s own records could show as met stays conditional.
04
Right of reply
The firm receives the findings and has 14 days to correct a fact or add evidence. Its reply is recorded.
05
Decision
One person who did not review the firm, Reiko Tooming, decides the outcome and records the reasons, and every decision names them. There is one decider, not two: no second person checks a decision before it is made.
06
Appeal
The firm can appeal once. Reigo Tooming hears it and is named on the appeal record. Reigo reviewed the firm but did not decide; we have no outside appeal reviewer yet, so an appeal is not heard by someone independent of the review.
07
Public record
The passport shows the outcome and, for a certificate, its identifier, its grade, the programs it covers, issue and expiry dates, any conditions, and every change of status.
Who does it
Reigo Tooming · Reviews
Checks the evidence and records a level for each requirement. Never decides a firm they reviewed.
Reiko Tooming · Decides
Decides the outcome and records the reasons. Never reviews a firm they decide on.
Reigo Tooming · Hears appeals
Hears a firm’s one appeal. Reviewed the firm but did not decide, so not independent of the review.
05
After a decision
A certificate is a standing promise, so it is checked while it lasts.
01
Monitoring
Each quarter we check a smaller payout sample, watch for rule changes and read new complaints.
02
Suspension
A certificate is suspended at once if a requirement falls to not met, or a condition’s deadline passes.
03
Revocation
It is revoked if a suspension is not resolved within 30 days, or if evidence given to us was false.
04
Renewal
Every certificate expires after twelve months and is renewed only by a fresh review.
06
Our view before a decision
Before a firm’s review is decided, we may show our view from public sources. It is labelled “Our view”, never “Certified”; it says which requirements public evidence could not settle and counts none of them against the firm; and it is shown with the status “Not issued”. So in our view, payouts is judged on public evidence of payments, and the record sample that a review needs is listed as unsettled.
Checked against version 1.1 on , from public sources only
Nothing is not met, and “Who you are dealing with”, “Payouts are paid”, “Rules a trader can rely on”, “Fair enforcement, and a way to appeal” and “Honest claims” are conditional: a certificate shows those conditions, with a dated plan to close them within 90 days.
01Who you are dealing with
Conditional
Both companies behind the brand are registered and active: Five Percent Online Ltd in Israel and in the UK. The founder holds 75% or more of the UK company, and its directors are on the register. But the terms give both registrations without saying which company a trader contracts with, and neither the terms nor the payout pages say which company pays traders.
Not settled by public evidence Who owns and directs the Israeli operating company: its register lists no shareholders or directors. The method would ask the firm to disclose them to us; we have asked The5ers nothing.
The schedule, methods and fees are published, and the firm states one time for every method, counted from the request: a review that usually takes 24 to 48 business hours, then “up to 3 business days” to process, to the trader’s own Rise Works account, a bank or a crypto wallet. Two trackers reading a public blockchain count tens of thousands of payments through Rise. But since 3 August 2026 the terms have let the firm pay an approved payout above a threshold it does not publish in weekly instalments of up to $10,000, which contradicts the payout page’s “All approved withdrawal requests are typically processed in up to 3 business days”, and a trader cannot tell which applies. A payout taken as Hub Credits stays in the trader’s The5ers account and can only buy new accounts, so under the method it is not yet paid.
Not settled by public evidence Whether a random sample of payouts matches payment records and was paid on time; the trackers may also count payments to affiliates or vendors, and the firm’s own total is not audited. Whether the paying company can cover what it owes: the UK company’s latest accounts, for 2024 and unaudited, show turnover of 1,002,466 euros and net assets of 490,381 euros without saying it pays traders, and we could read no accounts for the Israeli company. Which company pays traders is counted under identity; payouts cancelled after the firm’s review are judged under fair enforcement.
Each program’s rules are published in detail, and help-centre answers carry dates. But the terms say a funded trader must accept additional terms, without naming or linking them, and we found no public copy. And in the last 12 months rules that can cost a payout or an account changed without a date or without saying which accounts they cover: in May 2026 the terms, still dated 25 February 2026, began requiring a verification interview to be held, not only booked, within 5 business days on pain of losing pending payouts; and between August and September 2026 High Stakes’ $50K and $100K accounts went from 5% daily and 10% maximum loss to 4% and 8%, with no date or scope given.
Fix before issue
Bring its own pages into line on High Stakes loss limits, Hyper Growth’s split, expert-advisor approval and Summer Plan refunds.
Commit in its terms not to apply rule changes to accounts already bought: they now bind traders to changes on posting and let trading rules change with or without notice.
Not settled by public evidence Whether the funded-account terms are shown before purchase, and whether the High Stakes limits and the May 2026 changes were applied to accounts already bought. No change log is on record. The May 2026 rewrite also added profit forfeiture for disparaging statements, counted under fair enforcement; the payout instalments added in August 2026 are counted under payouts.
In its public replies to disputed terminations, the firm names the sections of its terms it relied on, 3.2 on verification and 10.1 on termination for cause, and traders say it would not share its evidence. A trader can ask for a decision to be looked at again: the replies speak of an appeal reviewed several times and of decisions upheld after risk and compliance review, after which the firm calls them final. But no formal appeal is published, and the terms do not oblige the firm to give reasons. They also let the firm close accounts and forfeit accrued profits for “defamatory, disparaging, or harmful statements” about it on any public platform, including review sites.
Not settled by public evidence Whether every refusal notice names the rule and what the trader did, and who reviews a contested decision and how fast; that needs a sample of notices. We found no case of a trader losing an account or a payout for criticising the firm.
The terms say evaluation accounts are simulated, that funded traders are backed with simulated capital, and that the company is not a broker or an investment fund; no official page we read claims a licence. But a September 2025 press release from the firm ends by calling The5ers a private equity fund; the home page says “If you’ve earned it, it’s yours” under a “no nonsense” payout policy, without saying that the terms let the firm forfeit accrued profits; and the futures page shows an “Exchange Approved” badge reading “Approved by the CME” without saying what was approved. One clause of the terms also still says funded traders “trade with Our trading capital”.
Fix before issue
Date its payout total of over $43 million, or replace it with a current one.
Match “Instant, simple payouts” on the home page to the processing times it states.
Not settled by public evidence Whether the firm corrects these once they are raised; we have raised nothing with The5ers. What the CME approval refers to: we found no CME record to check it against. Whether Trustpilot warned about fake reviews at any point in the last 12 months; no warning was on the profile in November 2026.
No alert names The5ers or its companies in IOSCO’s I-SCAN database. The Bank of Russia has listed its website since April 2025, but the firm’s terms have barred residents of Russia since their 2 December 2025 version, and they also bar Israel, so neither is a market where it sells and the warning is noted, not counted. Traders can reach the firm by email and chat from its pages, and its Trustpilot profile shows it replying to 97% of negative reviews, typically within a week.
Fix before issue
Name a route for complaints and state a time to answer one.
Not settled by public evidence Whether the firm sold to residents of Russia before December 2025, when its terms did not name Russia, though their list was never exhaustive; and whether it has explained the Bank of Russia listing. Whether complaints made by email or chat get an answer: only public replies can be seen.
The5ers has not seen this view. It is not a review, a certificate, an approval or an endorsement, and what public evidence could not settle is never counted against the firm.
Checked against version 1.1 on , from public sources only
Nothing is not met, and “Payouts are paid”, “Rules a trader can rely on”, “Fair enforcement, and a way to appeal”, “Honest claims” and “Regulatory standing and complaints” are conditional: a certificate shows those conditions, with a dated plan to close them within 90 days.
01Who you are dealing with
Met
The CFD and futures terms, both updated on 1 November 2026, name the contracting company, FTMO s.r.o., ID 092 13 651, registered and active in Prague, and say the FTMO Trader Program, under which Rewards are paid, is offered by it. The register shows the two founders as its directors and their holding company, OMHC a.s., as its sole owner, and the founders say publicly that they own all of FTMO. The companies serving US residents (JV Prop Corporation and OANDA Prop US Corporation) and Australians (VRGK Tech Pty Ltd, active on Australia’s business register) are named on those sites.
Not settled by public evidence Who owns OMHC a.s.: the register lists no shareholder and the beneficial-owner register is not public, so this is what the method’s confidential disclosure would check. The Delaware register was not searched for the two US companies, which FTMO’s 2025 filing lists as group companies. FTMO calls VRGK Tech Pty Ltd an affiliate without saying who owns it, and it is not among the companies that filing lists as controlled by OMHC.
The payout schedule and methods are published, with no withdrawal fee, and FTMO reports monthly Reward totals, most recently over $14.4 million to about 7,100 traders in September 2026. For CFD Rewards it states a time for each method: a request is reviewed within 1 to 2 business days and the Reward typically sent 1 to 2 business days after the invoice is approved, and crypto requested before noon CE(S)T is processed the same day. But for futures it states none: its payout pages give no review or processing time, and no time at all for Wise or Revolut bank wire, only calling the two card methods instant. No source shows an approved Reward left unpaid; disputed closures and refusals are judged under fair enforcement.
Not settled by public evidence Whether a random sample of Rewards matches payment records and was paid on time: no independent payout record exists, and FTMO has not enabled third-party tracking. Whether the paying company can cover what it owes: the latest filed accounts, for 2025, are those of FTMO Evaluation Global s.r.o., which sold the evaluations before the November 2026 merger. They carry an unqualified audit opinion and show equity of CZK 15.1 million against liabilities of CZK 912 million, with no line for Rewards owed; the merged company has filed no accounts yet. The FTMO Account terms, which set the Reward conditions, are not public; that is counted under rules.
Each product’s rules are published on one Trading Objectives page, changes are announced in dated weekly Trading Updates, and the October 2026 Consistency rule applied only to new orders. But the FTMO Account terms, which govern funded accounts and Rewards and which Instant Account buyers accept when they buy, are not published: the terms pages list only the evaluation terms, and FTMO offers a sample on request. And in July 2026 a 0.7% charge on the profit or loss of trades in a currency other than the account’s was added to the terms and the FTMO Account Agreement and applied to accounts already open: it is charged when a position closes, whenever it was opened, and FTMO’s public notice gives no effective date, saying it depends on the trader’s product stage and is set out in their agreement.
Fix before issue
Give one start date for the Consistency rule, and update the 1-Step page that still shows the rule it replaced.
Commit in the terms not to apply a change to accounts already bought unless it favours the trader: today they let FTMO change the forbidden practices, the trading objectives and the terms of existing agreements, the last on seven days’ notice.
Not settled by public evidence What the FTMO Account terms contain beyond the rules on the website, and whether any other change in the last 12 months reached accounts already bought: we could not open archived copies of FTMO’s pages and did not read every weekly update.
The forbidden practices and their consequences are published, and some recent reviews show closures citing a named rule, such as copy trading or one-sided bets. But the terms say only that FTMO will endeavour to notify a trader of action it takes, not that it will name the rule and what the trader did. The only way to contest a decision is a complaint by email, which FTMO undertakes to settle within 30 calendar days, longer than 15 business days, with no one independent named; EU consumers can also go to the Czech Trade Inspection Authority. And the terms let FTMO end a trader’s agreements for acting in a way that may damage its reputation, even after an agreement has ended, which could reach public criticism. Some reviewers say they were given no reason, or told a closure was final.
Not settled by public evidence Whether notices name the rule and what the trader did in practice, whether the evidence is kept and summarised on request, and who decides complaints: that needs a sample of notices and FTMO’s procedure. We found no case of a trader losing an account for criticism; two Forex Peace Army reviewers say staff threatened to restrict accounts over negative reviews, which we could not check.
The CFD terms and the futures evaluation terms describe the accounts they cover as simulated and say FTMO is not regulated and its services are not regulated financial services, and the home page claims no licence and no guarantee of payouts. Trustpilot showed FTMO’s 4.8 rating with no warning when we read it on 12 November 2026. But FTMO’s pages contradict each other on whether any account is live. The futures terms say select traders may be offered a Live Funded Account, “an account for real trading on financial markets”, and the futures help centre says it is held with an external brokerage, belongs to FTMO and is traded “with real orders on a real market, not in a simulated environment”. Yet the footer of its pages, those help answers included, and its General Disclosure say “FTMO only provides services of simulated trading and educational tools for traders”, and a help answer says any account FTMO provides has “fully fictitious funds” and its clients “never actually perform any trades on live markets”. FTMO’s own pages also give inconsistent or undated headline figures: 3.5 million and 4.5 million users, 250 and 400 staff, and an undated $650 million payout total.
Fix before issue
Make its user and staff figures agree, and date its customer and payout totals.
Not settled by public evidence Whether FTMO corrects the contradiction once it is raised; we have raised nothing with FTMO. The licences FTMO lists for its Australian company (AFS licence 525757) and its Mauritius company (GB21027119) were not checked against the regulators’ own registers: ASIC’s register refused our request and the Mauritius register could not be read. We did not review FTMO’s advertising, or Trustpilot’s profile over the past 12 months.
The Reserve Bank of India’s Alert List, updated as on 19 November 2025, names FTMO (ftmo.com/en) among platforms authorised neither to deal in forex nor to run an electronic trading platform for forex in India, and FTMO’s eligibility page does not exclude residents of India. We found no explanation from FTMO. No alert names FTMO or JV Prop in IOSCO’s I-SCAN database, no enforcement action was found, and the founders describe inquiries from the Spanish regulator and ASIC without any finding. The terms publish a way to complain, by email, settled within 30 calendar days. Of 20 one-star Trustpilot reviews read on 12 November 2026, 5 say the reviewer raised the case with FTMO, and at least 4 of them describe an answer, often a refusal; FTMO replies publicly to none, which is not counted, since it may answer privately.
Not settled by public evidence Whether FTMO in fact serves residents of India, and whether it has answered or challenged the listing; if it does not sell there, the listing is noted, not counted. How many complaints made to FTMO get an answer overall: that needs its complaint records.
FTMO has not seen this view. It is not a review, a certificate, an approval or an endorsement, and what public evidence could not settle is never counted against the firm.
Checked against version 1.1 on , from public sources only
Nothing is not met, and “Rules a trader can rely on”, “Fair enforcement, and a way to appeal”, “Honest claims” and “Regulatory standing and complaints” are conditional: a certificate shows those conditions, with a dated plan to close them within 90 days.
01Who you are dealing with
Met
The terms name one contracting company, GrowthNext – F.Z.E. of the Ajman Free Zone, with its number and address, as the only counterparty and the operator of the website; affiliates act for it and create no contract with the trader. The companies that run the trading environment and process payments are named: FundedNext Ltd in Comoros, FundedNext Limited in Hong Kong and Incenteco Trading Ltd in Cyprus in the terms, and Abutor Investments Ltd in Cyprus in the footer; both Cyprus companies are listed as registered on the Cyprus register. The founders are named publicly as running the firm, and the Cyprus register shows them as directors of Incenteco.
Fix before issue
Give Incenteco Trading Ltd the address the Cyprus register and the terms show (16 Foti Kolakidi, Agia Zoni); the footer places it at 26 Pittaou Str., Agia Fyla.
Name Abutor Investments Ltd, which the footer says facilitates payment-related operations, alongside the payment companies in the terms.
Not settled by public evidence Whether GrowthNext – F.Z.E. and the Comoros and Hong Kong companies are registered and active, and who owns them: no Ajman Free Zone register could be reached, the Comoros register refused access, Hong Kong’s company search needs an account, and no owner is named publicly. Owners of 25% or more would have to come from the firm, which we have not asked.
The firm states one payout time for both brands: a reward is processed within 24 hours of the request, or $1,000 is added, except for bank transfers, requests on hold or under manual review, and wrong payout details. Its clock stops when the firm starts the transfer, not when the money reaches the trader; the futures help centre says arrival then depends on the method and provider. Rewards can also be deposited at FNmarkets, a brokerage the group launched in 2025, where the money is still held within the group. Outside data confirm large flows: an on-chain tracker attributed $225.9 million to FundedNext by September 2026, and Prop Firm Match lists 288,044 payouts with no reported delays. The payouts traders dispute were withheld in the firm’s review, so they are judged under fair enforcement, not here.
Not settled by public evidence Whether a random sample of payouts matches payment records and reached traders within 24 hours of the request: the firm’s own figures, a 4.74-hour median and 99.99% within 24 hours, run only to processing and are not audited, and the Deloitte review reported in the press has no published scope. Whether GrowthNext – F.Z.E. can cover what it owes: no register we could reach publishes its accounts.
Rules are published per program and on a general rules page, and the help centre dates several changes and keeps the older rules for accounts already bought (January and October 2026). But the inactivity rule, which ends an account, was shortened with no date and without saying whether accounts bought under the old period keep it. In March and May 2026 the help centre gave challenge and funded CFD accounts 60 days without a trade, and in March it added that no withdrawals were possible after deactivation; by 27 July 2026 it gave every Stellar account, funded ones included, 30 days, and it says the policy applies uniformly to all accounts. The general rules page still says 60 days.
Fix before issue
Make its pages agree on how the daily loss limit is measured and whether futures fees can be refunded.
Commit in the terms not to apply rule changes to accounts already bought: the general terms let the firm amend rules at any time, and the CFD terms allow exceptions to protect platform integrity.
Not settled by public evidence Whether any trader lost an account or a payout under the shorter period, and whether other changes went unlogged: archived copies of most rule pages were not compared, the CFD terms allow changes to active accounts to protect platform integrity, and the general terms let rules change at any time.
For three rules (quick trades, news trading and the risk limit) the dashboard’s Clarity Cards name the rule and list the trades that triggered it, and the help centre says what is deducted or when the account ends; one trader’s forum complaint about a Quick Strike termination describes the rule and the trades the firm cited. For other grounds the help centre promises only clear communication supported by proofs, and lets the firm pay part of a reward after finding abuse, by the severity of the abuse, with no published scale. The CFD terms let a trader ask for a review that the firm may, but need not, give, its decision then being final; the futures and instant-account terms say the firm will consider appeals case by case and may uphold its original decision. So a decision is looked at again only at the firm’s discretion, with no formal appeal: no deadline and no reviewer independent of the original decision is published. The terms bar traders from disparaging the firm on review sites and social media, on pain of losing rewards and a contractual penalty, and the futures terms end accounts for misleading reviews; we found no case of these clauses being used.
Not settled by public evidence Whether refusals on other grounds, such as abuse, a change in trading behaviour, KYC or location checks or a failed interview, name the rule and what the trader did, and whether the evidence is kept and shared. 9 of the 20 most recent one-star Trustpilot reviews, read on 12 November 2026, describe accounts closed or profit withheld, but the terms forbid traders from publishing the firm’s notices, which leaves less public evidence.
The terms say plainly that every account is simulated and that the contracting company is not a broker or regulated financial services provider. But the company page, still up on 12 November 2026, says “We are authorized and regulated by reputable authorities”, lists the FSCA (FSP 53187), the Seychelles FSA (SD 137, FNmarkets Ltd.), the Vanuatu FSC and a Dubai DED licence, two with placeholder numbers, and claims segregated client funds; the Seychelles FSA’s own list of securities dealers names no FNmarkets company. The home page promises “Rewards in 24h or get $1,000 extra” without the exclusions the help centre lists. The Labs page’s description promises real funded accounts, and a help article says orders are routed to real liquidity-provider quotes. Trustpilot showed the firm’s rating, with no warning about fake or manipulated reviews, in December 2025, March 2026 and November 2026.
Fix before issue
Make the reward page agree with itself on the payout total: on 11 November 2026 its live counter showed $411.5 million while its title read $402.9 million.
Not settled by public evidence Whether the firm corrects these once they are raised; we have not raised them with FundedNext. Whether FSP 53187 belongs to a group company: the FSCA’s register search did not load. The Seychelles list shows no licence numbers, so whether SD 137 belongs to a company under another name could not be checked. No copy of the Trustpilot profile was archived between March and November 2026.
The Reserve Bank of India added FundedNext to its Alert List of unauthorised forex platforms in October 2024. India is on neither of the firm’s restricted lists, and four recent one-star reviewers who bought accounts give India as their country, so the warning is in a market where it sells; the firm disputes it in a public statement backed by an Indian legal opinion. The Bank of Russia listed the website in September 2026; the firm’s public announcements address only the RBI listing, and its own pages disagree on whether it sells in Russia, so that listing is noted, not counted. I-SCAN has no alert. Complaints have a published email route with a written outcome within 30 days.
Not settled by public evidence Whether the RBI listing still stands (the RBI’s current list could not be opened), whether the firm sells in Russia, and whether complaints are answered: the firm replied publicly to none of the 20 most recent one-star Trustpilot reviews, though reviewers who describe a closure cite the grounds the firm gave them.
FundedNext has not seen this view. It is not a review, a certificate, an approval or an endorsement, and what public evidence could not settle is never counted against the firm.
Checked against version 1.1 on , from public sources only
Nothing is not met, and “Who you are dealing with”, “Payouts are paid”, “Rules a trader can rely on”, “Fair enforcement, and a way to appeal” and “Honest claims” are conditional: a certificate shows those conditions, with a dated plan to close them within 90 days.
01Who you are dealing with
Conditional
A company registered and active in Cyprus, Funding Pips Services Ltd, stands behind the brand, with its directors on record. But neither the terms nor the privacy policy names any company. Only the site footer does, as it has since at least November 2025: it says a Comoros company, FundingPips Corp, provides the simulated trading services, and calls the Cyprus company a non-operational support office. No page we read says which company takes traders’ fees or pays their rewards.
Not settled by public evidence Whether FundingPips Corp is registered and active (the Mwali register could not be reached, again on 12 November 2026); which company sells to and pays traders; and who owns any FundingPips company: no shareholder is public, and we have not asked the firm. The Customer Agreement funded traders sign may name the contracting company, but it is not published; that fact is counted under rules.
Public records show payouts being paid: a tracker reading a public blockchain counts $157.7 million in 71,047 Rise payments, and Prop Firm Match records no reported delays. But for card rewards the firm states two arrival times that contradict each other. Its reward page says every request is processed in 1 to 3 working days and the funds arrive 1 to 2 working days later, while its card section says standard card rewards typically arrive 1 to 5 working days after approval. The disputes in reviews concern accounts closed before payment, judged under fair enforcement, and the move of traders into PRIME is counted under rules.
Fix before issue
Make its pages agree on which models refund their fee: the terms say no refund applies, while the reward-methods page’s heading names the 1 Step model and its text excludes it.
Not settled by public evidence Whether a random sample of requested payouts matches payment records within the stated times; whether the company that pays can cover what it owes, since the firm does not say which company pays and we read no filed accounts for any FundingPips company; and whether any reward a trader had requested was moved into PRIME instead of paid. By the firm’s help centre, the profit after the split moves into the PRIME account, a simulated balance; Finance Magnates tracked at least 20 complaints about PRIME, most about the mandatory move and concerns that payouts were exchanged for PRIME starting balances, and the firm says nothing is replaced. A requested reward converted that way would make this not met. A reward a trader chooses to move to Tradin, a broker FundingPips calls its own, counts as paid only once withdrawn from Tradin.
Each program’s rules are published in detail, and most changes in the last 12 months are dated and spare accounts already bought: legacy pages keep the old program and PRIME rules for purchases and invitations before 28 September 2026. But archived copies show rules that can cost an account or a payout added to the terms between May and October 2026, while the effective date stayed 15 May 2026 and nothing said which accounts they cover: an appendix of prohibited practices whose listed actions include declining rewards and closing accounts, and new grounds such as repeated rapid account failures and all-or-nothing risk. The Customer Agreement funded traders sign is not published before purchase. And changes were applied to accounts already bought: temporary limits on weekend trades and on leverage for Master Accounts from 29 January and 16 March 2026, and the move of traders into PRIME, mandatory under the terms once granted, which Finance Magnates reports closed existing Master Accounts and which, by the firm’s help centre, turns the profit after the split into a simulated PRIME balance.
Fix before issue
Make its pages agree on the 2 Step Flex Phase 2 target, the 1% risk-per-trade guide and Zero’s single-trade limits.
Commit in its terms not to apply rule changes to accounts already bought: the terms reserve the right to change any part at any time without notice, and the promise on its trading objectives page that existing accounts keep their rules is not in them.
Not settled by public evidence Whether the live terms still make PRIME mandatory once granted: the archived copies of 18 May and 2 October 2026 contain that clause, our 11 November reading did not find it, and the live page could not be re-read on 12 November. Whether the move into PRIME refused any requested payout, which would make this not met, is disputed and noted under payouts. No archived copy of the terms from before 18 May 2026 was compared, and rule changes are not kept in one public log.
In its public replies to disputed closures, the firm gives a reason, usually a device ID match with another user, and its terms now set out the rules such closures rest on, barring shared or third-party access and coordinated trading, with device and IP data reviewed. But a decision can be looked at again only informally. No appeal process is published in its terms or help centre, the help centre says accounts may be closed without prior notice for clear policy violations, and the terms refuse any request to reopen accounts closed because the trader disputed an order payment. Of the 20 most recent one-star Trustpilot reviews on 12 November 2026, the firm had replied to 7: two replies say the decision remains final, one that the closure decision stands, and none offers an appeal. In that last case the trader says they appealed the same day and were later shown the device report, and the firm’s reply says the closure was upheld following a review: the firm does look at a decision again on request, though only informally. The terms also forbid traders to make public any part of their communications with the firm, on pain of losing access, which would reach a trader who posts a refusal to criticise it; no review we read describes that being used.
Not settled by public evidence Whether each refusal, closure or profit deduction names in writing the rule and what the trader did, rather than only a category, and whether support ever reverses a decision on request: one reviewer on Prop Firm Match says tick-level logs were refused as confidential. That needs a sample of notices.
The terms and footer say plainly that every account is simulated and that the firm is not a broker. But it advertises zero payout denials and guaranteed payment without saying what the guarantee covers, while its terms let it decline reward requests and remove profits. Its footer also claims a licence for FundingPips Corp, an International Brokerage and Clearing House Licence numbered Bfx2024004, which the method checks against the regulator’s own record; that record could not be reached. Trustpilot shows no withheld rating or warning about fake or manipulated reviews, on 12 November 2026 or in archived copies from November 2025 and February 2026; its 2024 suspension is more than 12 months old.
Fix before issue
Date its payout totals and make them agree: its pages give $253 million, $277 million and $330 million, and a live counter $329.6 million.
Not settled by public evidence Whether the firm corrects the payout guarantee once it is raised; we have not raised it. Whether the Mwali register records licence Bfx2024004 for FundingPips Corp, and whether the FSC Mauritius register records the licence of Tradin, which FundingPips calls its regulated broker: neither register could be read.
No alert names FundingPips or its companies in IOSCO’s I-SCAN database, and no other regulator warning was found. Traders have a published way to complain: the terms send questions to a support email, and the help centre directs traders to contact support. Most complaints get an answer: Trustpilot shows the firm replying to 99% of negative reviews, typically within 48 hours. Of the 20 most recent one-star reviews on 12 November 2026, 7 had a reply, and all 13 without one were posted on 11 or 12 November; one of the 20 reviewers says the firm did not communicate with them. But no complaints procedure or time to answer is published.
Fix before issue
Publish a complaints procedure and a time to answer.
Not settled by public evidence Regulator lists outside I-SCAN, which we could not search fully, and whether complaints sent to support, rather than posted on Trustpilot, are answered.
FundingPips has not seen this view. It is not a review, a certificate, an approval or an endorsement, and what public evidence could not settle is never counted against the firm.
Checked against version 1.1 on , from public sources only
Nothing is not met, and “Who you are dealing with”, “Rules a trader can rely on”, “Fair enforcement, and a way to appeal” and “Honest claims” are conditional: a certificate shows those conditions, with a dated plan to close them within 90 days.
01Who you are dealing with
Conditional
The site names TopstepTrader, LLC as operator of the Trading Combine and Express accounts and TopstepFunded LLC, an Illinois company, as the party to Live accounts, both described as wholly owned by Topstep LLC of Delaware, and the chief executive and leadership are named. But the Terms of Use contract with Topstep LLC and its affiliated entities “collectively”, and the payout policy names no paying company, only “Topstep”, so which company contracts with a Combine or Express trader, and which pays Express payouts, is not stated. That the Express Funded Account Agreement is not public bears on this too; it is counted under rules.
Not settled by public evidence Whether the companies are registered and active: on 12 November 2026 the Illinois register still refused access, and Delaware’s search needs a CAPTCHA. Who owns 25% or more, and who controls the FMC Irrevocable Trust, named with Topstep Holdings LLC and FMC Holdings LLC as a parent in a June 2026 court disclosure: the method confirms owners from registers or documents a firm shares with us, and we have asked Topstep nothing.
The payout policy is published in detail and states a time for each of its five payment methods, from same day or instant to 5 to 10 business days, after an internal approval that “can take 1-3 business days”, so each method has one time counted from the request; the 9-second average its prop and payouts pages give for auto-approved payouts fits the instant method. The firm says it approves 99.26% of requests and that 33.3% of funded-level traders received a payout in 2025. In recent reviews, 6 of 20 five-star reviews mention payouts received and 1 of 20 one-star reviews describes an international payout still missing after a month. Balances forfeited in bans are judged under fair enforcement.
Not settled by public evidence Whether a random sample of payouts requested in the last 90 days matches bank and payment records, timed from the request to money in an account the trader controls: no tracker can see Topstep’s payouts, which go by bank, Aeropay, Wise or transfer to its own brokerage, and its totals are not audited. Whether the same-day time for a transfer to a Topstep Brokerage account also waits on the approval window, and whether money there counts as money the trader controls. Whether the contracting company can cover what it owes: no filed accounts for Topstep LLC or its subsidiaries appear in any source we read.
Each program’s rules are published in detail, and help-centre answers carry dates. But the Express Funded Account Agreement, which traders accept at activation, is not public before purchase: the terms say Express and Live accounts are governed by separate or supplemental written agreements, and the rules pages say they override those agreements where the two conflict. Over the last 12 months, archived copies of the payout policy from October 2025 to June 2026 show lower payout caps for new $50K and $100K accounts announced with their 28 April 2026 start and kept off accounts already bought, and the help centre says the January 2026 split change spared earlier traders. But the Prohibited Conduct article, whose responses run to closing an account or denying a payout, now lists grounds absent from its October 2025 version, bad-faith payment disputes and an explicit ban on VPNs and proxies, and a profile hold that pauses payout requests until it is lifted, telling traders to wait 7 business days for it to be lifted or for next steps. It does not say when these were added, only that Prohibited Conduct applies at every level of the program. Official pages also contradict each other: the Express rules page, last updated June 2025, still gives $5,000 and $6,000 caps for every size and a 7-day Back2Funded window, where the help centre gives caps by size and 30 days.
Fix before issue
Update the June 2025 Express rules page to the help centre’s payout caps and 30-day window.
Commit in its terms that rule changes never apply to accounts already bought unless they favour the trader.
Not settled by public evidence Whether every change in the last 12 months was dated and kept off accounts already bought: Topstep publishes no change log, and the archive holds only the versions it happened to capture. What the Express and Live agreements say. A trader’s pending lawsuit makes claims about Topstep’s practices; no court has ruled on them.
The firm says every ban email names the conduct found, when it happened and the clause of the Terms of Use it breaks, and it publishes a formal written appeal of its own: one appeal with evidence within 30 days, after which the decision is final. But the appeal has no deadline: the firm says only that traders typically hear back within a few business days, from an unnamed “reviewing team”. The appeal is published for bans; other responses to prohibited conduct, such as deleting a trading day or delaying or denying a payout, have no published route beyond asking support. And the terms let Topstep restrict a trader’s access without notice, compensation or refund for acting in a way that “may cause Topstep risk of or actual reputational damage”, while the professional-behaviour policy checked before every payout counts publicly posting private correspondence against a trader. Neither names criticism, but both are wide enough to reach it; no source we read describes either being used against a critic. Recent one-star reviewers dispute the notices: six of the 20 most recent say no reason or evidence was shared, or the appeal explained nothing.
Not settled by public evidence Whether every notice names the rule and what the trader did, whether the evidence is kept for twelve months and summarised for the trader on request, and whether appeals are decided by someone not involved in the ban. That needs a sample of notices and appeal outcomes.
Topstep’s terms, page footers and prop page say the Trading Combine and Express accounts are simulated and that Live accounts trade real capital, and its terms say it is not a broker-dealer. But its home page invites traders to “trade futures with our prop firm capital” under a “Trade Our Money” button, and its payouts page says “you trade our capital, not your own”, then describes passing the Trading Combine and getting funded, which means a simulated Express account; only 0.71% of Express traders were called up to Live in 2025. Its own pages also give different, undated figures: $1.5 billion, $1.4 billion and “more than $1 billion” paid; 750,000 traders, a 300,000 community and a 200,000 community; up to $6,000 and up to $12,000 a payout. Trustpilot shows the firm’s rating and no warning about fake or manipulated reviews; its only label, that the firm may be associated with high-risk investments, is not about reviews.
Fix before issue
Date its payout totals and community figures, and make them and its per-payout caps agree.
Not settled by public evidence Whether Topstep Brokerage LLC is a registered introducing broker and a member of the NFA, as the site footer says: the NFA’s BASIC, the regulator’s own record, treats a search as accepting its terms of use, which we did not do. Whether the firm corrects its capital claims once they are raised: we have raised nothing with Topstep. Whether a review platform warned the public about fake or manipulated reviews of the firm earlier in the last 12 months.
No alert names Topstep, its companies, its domain or its platform in IOSCO’s I-SCAN database, and it is not on the CFTC’s RED list; the pending federal suit is a trader’s private claim, not regulatory action. Traders have published ways to complain: support around the clock with stated response times, and a written ban appeal. Of the 20 most recent one-star Trustpilot reviews, read on 12 November 2026 (23 October to 11 November), 10 say the reviewer complained to Topstep through support or an appeal; 2 of them say they got no answer, and the rest describe an answer, often one they found unhelpful. Topstep replies publicly to few reviews (1 of those 20, about 4% of negative reviews overall), but an unanswered review is not by itself an unanswered complaint.
Not settled by public evidence The NFA’s own records for Topstep Brokerage and Topstep Advisory, including any disciplinary history: its BASIC search counts as accepting its terms of use, which we did not do. How many complaints made through support are answered across the firm, which needs its complaint records: the reviews are a small, self-selected sample, and the firm’s 8-minute average first response and 90.6% of cases closed the same day are its own, undated figures.
Topstep has not seen this view. It is not a review, a certificate, an approval or an endorsement, and what public evidence could not settle is never counted against the firm.
Checked against version 1.1 on , from public sources only
“Fair enforcement, and a way to appeal” is not met, so the method would not certify the firm.
01Who you are dealing with
Met
The terms and risk disclosure name Apex Trader Funding Inc, a Texas corporation, which the Texas record shows registered on 27 July 2021 and active; its 2025 report names Darrell Martin, whom the firm names publicly as founder and CEO. No other company appears on the pages we read as selling to, funding or paying traders: the terms say live traders trade capital that Apex Trader Funding provides, and payouts are sent by ACH in the US and through a payment partner, Plane, elsewhere.
Fix before issue
Give the company’s Texas file number in its terms, which the state record already shows.
Not settled by public evidence Who owns 25% or more and who the directors are: Texas does not publish shareholders, and its record lists one officer. The user agreements that govern the accounts are not public, so the company they name could not be read; that fact is counted under rules. The brokerage partner that holds live accounts is not named, though the terms say Apex provides their capital.
The firm states one time for both its payment methods, counted from the request to the trader’s bank: it reviews a request within 2 business days, sends approved funds within 3 to 4, and says most traders receive them within 5 to 11 business days in all, by ACH in the US or through Plane to a local bank elsewhere, where it adds that timing depends on the local bank. It lists approved payouts every day, and Trustpilot’s summary of 4,757 reviews says reviewers find payouts easy to request, though some note delays in processing. For the live program, entered only by invitation, the stated 48 hours runs only to a payment processor. Payouts traders say were withheld after identity checks or closures are judged under fair enforcement.
Fix before issue
Make its pages agree on how payouts outside the US are sent: the help centre names Plane, an article on its own site Deel.
Not settled by public evidence Whether a random sample of payouts matches payment records and reached traders within 5 to 11 business days: no independent tracker covers Apex, and its own totals are not audited. Whether Apex Trader Funding Inc can cover what it owes: the Texas record we read publishes no accounts.
Each program’s limits are set out size by size in help-centre pages, the terms and risk disclosure carry an effective date of 22 October 2025, and the firm says the rules launched on 1 March 2026 apply only to accounts bought from then, with Legacy accounts keeping theirs. But the two user agreements that the terms say govern the evaluation, Performance and live accounts, and prevail over the terms, are not public before purchase. And the live program’s FAQ, first published on 22 May 2026 by the metadata of an archived copy and shown on the site without a date, closes every open evaluation and Performance Account of a trader moved to live, whenever it was bought, refunding only evaluations still active, and moves their simulated profit balances into a Bonus Vault it says is not money, from which it may pay monthly bonuses tied to live withdrawals. The homepage’s promise of no payout denials, against payouts its other pages call discretionary and final, is counted under honest claims.
Fix before issue
Make its pages agree on the payout cycle: the general payout page gives eight trading days, the pages for the new accounts five.
Commit in its terms not to apply rule changes to accounts already bought: the live-program FAQ reserves the right to change rules at any time, with or without notice, and the terms make changes effective when posted.
Not settled by public evidence Whether the user agreements match the help centre, and whether closing accounts on a move to live changed the terms of accounts already bought: the terms, effective 22 October 2025, already refer to a live account agreement, and the FAQ presents its bonus as replacing an outright forfeit of simulated balances. No public change log was found, and the Internet Archive’s first copy of the FAQ is from 1 June 2026.
The risk disclosure, effective 22 October 2025, says any decision to grant or deny a payout is final, and no page we read offers a route of the firm’s own, formal or informal, to have a decision looked at again; the helpdesk is a general support channel, and the payout pages say only that a trader denied for unmet requirements may request again. Nothing we found shows it looking at a decision again on request: none of its public Trustpilot replies to one- and two-star reviews from the last 12 months that we could read does, and one trader reports a termination notice saying the decision was final and would not be reconsidered. The terms send disputes to binding arbitration in Travis County, Texas, or to a small-claims court, but that is open against any firm and is not a way to contest a decision with Apex. Six of the 20 most recent one-star Trustpilot reviews describe accounts closed or approved payouts withheld, most after a failed identity check, with no clear reason given, and several prohibited practices set no measurable threshold. No term we read lets the firm refuse a payout or close an account for criticising it: the terms bar defamatory language and harassment of Apex and its staff, which is narrower.
Not settled by public evidence Whether refusal and closure notices name the rule and what the trader did, which needs a sample of notices, and whether the user agreements, which are not public, offer any review of a decision. The Code of Conduct asks traders for professionalism towards the company, and the live FAQ says a breach of it can close an account, but its rules are given in a video we did not watch, so whether it reaches public criticism is open. Whether complaints get an answer is judged under standing.
Its terms, risk disclosure and homepage say plainly that evaluation and Performance Accounts are simulated, with no real capital at risk, and that Apex is not a broker, futures commission merchant or adviser and is not regulated; no page we read claims a licence. But its homepage promises “No Payout Denials” and “No denied payouts. No payout reviews.”, while the same page’s footer calls payouts discretionary, the risk disclosure calls them discretionary and any decision to grant or deny one final, the help centre reviews each request within 2 business days and denies it automatically below the minimum balance, and an article on the firm’s own site lists payout denial as a penalty. Trustpilot showed no notice about fake or manipulated reviews on the firm’s profile on 11 November 2026, nor on archived copies of 9 January and 7 March 2026.
Fix before issue
Make its payout figures reconcile: the monthly averages its homepage has shown do not fit its totals since 2022.
Make its pages agree on when it started: a help-centre page says 2008, and the company was registered in July 2021.
Make its pages agree on whom it serves: the terms and the homepage footer say United States users only, the homepage and help centre over 100 countries.
Make the homepage footer’s statement that no live market execution occurs agree with the live program the same page offers.
Make clear that the homepage’s “5 Days for Payouts” means five qualifying trading days, since its help centre puts the time to be paid at 5 to 11 business days.
Not settled by public evidence Whether the firm corrects the payout promise once it is raised: we have not raised it with Apex Trader Funding. Whether a review platform posted such a notice between March and November 2026, months of which the archive holds no copy of the profile.
No alert names Apex Trader Funding in IOSCO’s I-SCAN database or on the Bank of Russia’s warning list; the FCA warning that matches “Apex Trader” concerns a different site. NFA’s register returns no firm of that name, which its page says can mean a firm that is not and has not been registered with the CFTC. Private suits filed in 2026 are pending; none is a regulator’s action. Traders can complain through a published helpdesk. Eight of the 20 most recent one-star Trustpilot reviews say their tickets or emails went unanswered, some for one to three weeks, which is fewer than half. The firm has replied publicly to 61 of 1,045 negative reviews in Trustpilot’s count, which Trustpilot shows as 5%, and to none of those 20, but an unanswered review is not by itself an unanswered complaint.
Fix before issue
Publish a time to answer complaints.
Not settled by public evidence Whether most complaints sent through the helpdesk get an answer, which needs the firm’s records, and whether the CFTC has acted against the firm: its own enforcement records were not searched. The firm’s Better Business Bureau profile could not be read.
Apex Trader Funding has not seen this view. It is not a review, a certificate, an approval or an endorsement, and what public evidence could not settle is never counted against the firm.
Checked against version 1.1 on , from public sources only
Nothing is not met, and “Payouts are paid”, “Rules a trader can rely on”, “Fair enforcement, and a way to appeal” and “Honest claims” are conditional: a certificate shows those conditions, with a dated plan to close them within 90 days.
01Who you are dealing with
Met
The terms name the contracting company, Alpha Capital Group Limited, and say it pays performance fees from its own funds; apart from the payment providers it uses, it is the only company the terms name as selling to, funding or paying traders, and Companies House shows it active since November 2021. Its owners are on the public register down to three people: a holding company owns it, and that is owned in equal bands by companies controlled by George Kohler, Alexander Hagan and Andrew Blaylock. The two directors are named on the register and by the firm.
Not settled by public evidence Confirmation of the owners against documents the firm would share; why the register dates the holding company’s control from before its incorporation; who owns the Seychelles company that holds the broker licence; and which company runs Alpha Prime, the live program that traders reaching the payout thresholds must join or leave the group. The help centre names no company for it, and the register shows an active Alpha Prime Markets Limited that the firm does not say runs it.
The firm states one payout time for every method: processed and paid within 2 business days of the trader’s request, through the payment providers Rise or Wise or by bank transfer, not into a wallet the firm runs, or up to 14 business days when it requires extra verification. A tracker reading a public blockchain counts 38,718 payments worth $74.2 million from the firm’s Rise wallets, the latest on 11 November 2026. But the contracting company’s latest filed accounts, unaudited and for the year to 31 March 2025, show £4,653,506 owed within a year against £2,376,997 of current assets, £890,760 of it cash, and net liabilities of £2,084,776, so they cannot show it can cover the payouts it owes; the directors prepared them as a going concern. Most payouts traders dispute in recent one-star reviews were refused or withheld over alleged rule breaches, often with the account closed, so they are judged under fair enforcement, not here.
Not settled by public evidence Whether a random sample of payouts matches payment records and reached traders within the stated time, which needs the firm’s records: the tracker sees only Rise and may count payments to affiliates and staff, and the firm has not enabled Prop Firm Match’s payout tracking. Whether the next accounts, due at Companies House by 31 December 2026, or a statement of reserves would show the company can pay what it owes.
Each plan’s rules are published in the terms and in help-centre answers, and the Max Risk Rule of July 2026 applies only to accounts bought after its announcement. But archived copies show rules that can cost a payout or an account changed in the last 12 months without saying from when or which accounts they cover. Between January and May 2026 a prohibited strategy came to cost the whole payout window’s profit, not only the profit of the trades concerned. Between June and October 2026 the news blackout on Qualified Alpha Pro 8% and 10% accounts widened from 2 to 5 minutes either side of listed news. Between May and November 2026 order book spamming, banned with no threshold, became position spamming: three or more positions on one trade idea, each within 60 seconds of the last. Each page shows only when it was last updated, the news rule now covers every Qualified Pro, One, Three and Direct account, and the terms let changes apply as soon as they are posted. The gambling, Swing and allocation pages changed only in wording.
Fix before issue
Make the terms, help centre and checkout agree on Alpha One’s scaling limit and bi-weekly rule and on the spamming rule, which the terms still describe as order book spamming, and remove Alpha Three from the terms.
Commit in its terms that rule changes never apply to accounts already bought unless they favour the trader.
Not settled by public evidence Whether the firm announced these changes anywhere with a date and the accounts they cover, since it keeps no public change log; whether rewording the 2-minute rule to count short trades taken below the starting balance, and the IP rule’s new closure for an unnotified VPN or shared IP, changed how they are applied; and how the terms changed over the year, since an archived copy from March 2026 did not load.
In its public replies to disputed terminations, the firm names the rule it relied on, the ban in condition 9.1.8 on anyone but the account holder trading the account, and what it found, such as the account being reached from devices linked to other people’s accounts. But a decision can be contested only informally: the terms say customer service will do their best to resolve any problems a user has, no appeal process, deadline or reviewer is published, and one trader describes a 14-day window to appeal. The terms also let the firm end a user’s access for disparaging it, with the firm’s own determination final and binding, as it is for abusive conduct toward the firm or its staff; none of the 20 one-star reviews we read says an account was closed or a payout refused for criticism.
Not settled by public evidence Whether every refusal or termination notice names the rule and what the trader did in writing, whether the evidence is kept and summarised on request, and who decides appeals and how long they take. That needs a sample of notices and the appeal procedure.
The terms, disclaimer, help centre and home page say plainly that every account is simulated, the home page says nothing is guaranteed, the broker it calls regulated is on the Seychelles FSA’s list as ACG Markets Ltd, and the diploma it calls Ofqual-regulated is on Ofqual’s register. But the About page says Alpha Capital itself received FSA Seychelles approval, which the FSA’s list shows ACG Markets Ltd holding while the terms say Alpha Capital Group Limited carries out no regulated business, and it describes the 2021 launch as an investment initiative for individual and institutional investors. Trustpilot withholds the firm’s rating for a breach of its guidelines and tells readers it has removed a number of fake reviews.
Fix before issue
Date its payout totals and make them agree: the home page, the About page and the figures it gave the press differ.
Update the disclaimer, last changed in December 2021, which says ACG Markets is not a broker while the home and About pages present it as the regulated broker.
Make the help centre’s payout time, 2 business days for all requests, match the terms, which allow up to 14 business days when extra verification is needed.
Not settled by public evidence Whether the firm corrects the About page once it is raised; we have not raised it with Alpha Capital Group. Its advertising off its own site was not checked.
No alert names alphacapitalgroup.uk in IOSCO’s I-SCAN database, and the FCA register lists no firm under its name. Hong Kong’s SFC listed an unlicensed ‘Alpha Capital Group Limited’ at alphacapital-group.com in July 2026, but an archived copy of that site shows a Chinese-language investment and wealth-management business in Wan Chai with nothing linking it to this firm, whose official-channels page says sites with similar names are not its own; so the alert is noted, not counted. A Spanish alert for alphacapg.com names another company. The terms publish a complaint route through customer service, and 4 of the 20 one-star Trustpilot reviews we read on 12 November 2026 say the firm stopped answering or did not answer them.
Fix before issue
Publish a time to answer complaints.
Not settled by public evidence Whether complaints sent by email are answered and how quickly, since no time to answer is published.
Alpha Capital Group has not seen this view. It is not a review, a certificate, an approval or an endorsement, and what public evidence could not settle is never counted against the firm.
Checked against version 1.1 on , from public sources only
Nothing is not met, and “Who you are dealing with”, “Rules a trader can rely on”, “Fair enforcement, and a way to appeal” and “Honest claims” are conditional: a certificate shows those conditions, with a dated plan to close them within 90 days.
01Who you are dealing with
Conditional
E8 Funding, LLC, the company the terms name, is registered in Texas and active, and its director, Dylan Elchami, who is named publicly as chief executive, is on the public record, as he is for the Puerto Rico company the website answers to. But the footer says MT5 accounts are run by E8 Markets Ltd in Saint Lucia, which the terms never mention, so for an MT5 trader it is unclear which company contracts with them and which pays them.
Not settled by public evidence Whether E8 Markets Ltd is registered and active, and who runs it: no Saint Lucia company register could be reached. Who owns the three companies: Texas does not publish an LLC’s members and the Puerto Rico record lists only administrators, so the method would ask the firm.
Payouts go through Rise, WorkMarket or Aeropay with no E8 fee, and the help centre times them from the trader’s request to an account the trader holds: a median of 24 hours to funds in the trader’s Rise or WorkMarket account, and up to 5 business days at times, with no processing at weekends. The terms say bank and ACH payments, which include Aeropay’s transfers, are processed within 7 days. These figures do not contradict each other: the median, like the payouts page’s average of 21 hours, is a typical time, and up to 5 business days sits within the terms’ 7 days. Two trackers show payments flowing at scale: $72.2 million across 20,017 tracked payouts since June 2024 with no reported delays, and $46.8 million in on-chain payments through Rise. The refusals traders dispute came during the firm’s reviews, so they are judged under fair enforcement; which company pays MT5 traders is counted under who you are dealing with.
Fix before issue
Make the terms agree with the help centre on payout methods: the terms still offer direct payouts in USDC, USDT, bitcoin and ether, which the help centre says are not offered.
Not settled by public evidence Whether a random sample of payouts matches payment records and was paid within those times: the trackers are not audited, and two recent one-star reviews say payouts were denied or never paid, without showing whether they had been approved. Whether the terms’ 7 days, which say only processed, run until the money reaches the trader. Whether E8 Funding, LLC can cover what it owes: neither the Texas nor the Puerto Rico record we read publishes accounts.
Each product’s rules are published and help answers carry dates. Against an archived copy from October 2025, the changes we found on the trading-policies page, now dated 23 September 2026, favour traders, such as letting them copy trades between their own challenge accounts, and the 1% risk cap it allows where prohibited practices are found was already published then. But the terms bind traders to an Educational Simulation Participant Agreement that prevails over them and covers reward eligibility, and it has no public copy, so a document that binds traders is not public before purchase.
Fix before issue
Make its pages agree on how many payouts an E8 Zero account allows, E8 Signature’s $150K drawdown and inactivity limit, whether risk per trade is limited, whether expert advisors are allowed, and refunds.
Take down or correct the E8 Signature forex product page, which shows 0% for its target, drawdown and split.
Commit in its terms that rule changes never apply to accounts already bought unless they favour the trader.
Not settled by public evidence Whether rule changes in the last 12 months reached accounts already bought, as the terms allow: E8 Zero launched in July 2026 for forex and other classic markets with a 3% static loss limit, and is now sold only for futures, with an end-of-day drawdown and a 40% best-day rule in the challenge; E8 Pro’s 2% daily profit cap, on a help page dated 17 August 2026, is not mentioned in two reports of the launch of E8Pro V2 on 1 June 2026; and a commercial news site reports that E8 retired forex Signature from 20 October 2026. No page we read says which accounts these cover, and one trader on Prop Firm Match says some rules were changed for older E8 Pro accounts. Whether traders can read the participant agreement before they buy: the help centre says every user must sign it, opened with a code sent by email, and is emailed a signed copy, but not at what stage.
The trading-policies page names its grounds and penalties, from closing the account and losing accrued profit to a 1% risk cap or withheld payouts, and sets some measurable thresholds; two refused traders say the firm gave a reason, a breach of its identity-check rules, one of them that someone else had helped with the check. But some grounds, such as irresponsible trading or extreme behaviour, set no threshold, and there is no formal appeal. The terms let E8 end accounts with or without notice for any reason and withhold payouts at its sole discretion, and a decision can be looked at again only informally or at E8’s discretion: by writing to support, or, for a closed account, by a request for reinstatement that E8 may consider at its sole discretion, with no deadline and no independent reviewer. Arbitration under the terms does not count as a way to contest, and the terms call E8’s decisions final only in referral disputes, not for refusals or closures. The terms also bar posting defamatory, misleading or harmful content about E8, let it end an account and deny pending or future rewards for any breach, and let it end an account for conduct it deems damaging to its reputation: terms that could punish public criticism, though we found no case of their use.
Not settled by public evidence Whether every refusal, termination or cut payout names the rule and what the trader did in writing, and whether the evidence is summarised on request: that needs a sample of notices. Whether support or a reinstatement request ever reverses a decision. One trader says a payout was cut to 25% under the 1% risk cap after passing; a single, unverified account.
The terms and help centre say plainly that every account is simulated and that E8 is not a broker. But a help answer on identity checks, still up on 12 November 2026, calls E8 a regulated business: it names no regulator, the terms say E8 is not a regulated financial entity in any jurisdiction, and the only regulator record found, in IOSCO’s alerts database, lists it as unlicensed in Ukraine. A promotional piece published in July 2025, still online, promised no payout denials while the terms let E8 withhold payouts at its sole discretion. And Trustpilot withholds E8’s rating for a breach of its guidelines and says it removed fake reviews.
Fix before issue
Make its payout totals agree: $80.5 million on the payouts page and $71 million on a help page updated in October 2026.
Make its trader counts agree: 500,000 traders on the home page and more than 300,000 registrations in the help centre.
Stop saying that a Trader Score sets payouts while the how-it-works page lists it as coming soon.
Not settled by public evidence Whether E8 corrects these within 30 days of our raising them; we have not raised them. Trustpilot does not say who wrote the removed reviews. Advertising beyond the pages we read was not checked.
IOSCO’s alerts database holds one alert: Ukraine’s securities regulator lists E8 Markets as unlicensed there. E8 does not accept traders from Ukraine, so it is noted, not counted. Traders can complain to support, and the refund page asks them to email support before any dispute. None of the 20 most recent one-star Trustpilot reviews, posted from late August to 10 November 2026 and read again on 12 November, shows a public reply, but that alone is not an unanswered complaint: of the 5 reviewers who say they contacted E8, one says it stopped replying to their complaints, two call support slow or useless, and two were given a reason for the firm’s decision, one after a week of vague replies.
Fix before issue
Publish a time to answer complaints.
Not settled by public evidence Whether most complaints sent to support get an answer, which needs the firm’s complaint records; this sample holds only 5 complainants who say they contacted the firm. The records of regulators that do not report to IOSCO’s database.
E8 Markets has not seen this view. It is not a review, a certificate, an approval or an endorsement, and what public evidence could not settle is never counted against the firm.
Checked against version 1.1 on , from public sources only
Nothing is not met, and “Who you are dealing with”, “Payouts are paid”, “Rules a trader can rely on”, “Fair enforcement, and a way to appeal” and “Honest claims” are conditional: a certificate shows those conditions, with a dated plan to close them within 90 days.
01Who you are dealing with
Conditional
The terms say the site is operated by Iconic Exchange FZCO, trading as Blue Guardian, a Dubai free-zone company, and that Blue Guardian Limited, which Saint Lucia’s IBC registry lists by name, provides the simulated platforms; the footer adds that Iconic Exchange FZCO handles payment processing. But Iconic Exchange FZCO could not be found in any register we could search; the company that signs the Trader Agreement with funded traders is not public, as the agreement is issued only after the evaluation; and futures Live accounts trade real capital through a brokerage the firm does not name, so which company funds them is unclear. The founder is named as CEO; no owner is named publicly. Two dissolved UK companies of the operator’s name were owned by a person with the founder’s name, but no record ties them to the firm. The unpublished Trader Agreement also bears on rules, where it is noted, not counted.
Not settled by public evidence Iconic Exchange FZCO’s licence, status and owners, and Blue Guardian Limited’s number, status and directors, which Saint Lucia keeps behind a paid search and confidentiality rules. Who owns 25% or more of each company, which the method has the firm show us; we have not asked.
Payments are visible in public records: a tracker reading public blockchains counts 25,064 payments worth $39.2 million through Rise and direct crypto by 12 November 2026, and the two payouts we opened from the firm’s list of latest payouts were completed transfers. But the firm’s stated times contradict each other. Its help centres say payouts by Rise or crypto are processed within 24 business hours, counted from when a request is eligible for processing, with weekends, holidays and reviews excluded, or the trader gets an extra 10% profit share. The pay-later page promises funds in under 24 hours of a request under the heading Guaranteed 24h Payouts, and the futures page a 24-hour guarantee with $1,000 extra; pages also give averages of 1 hour and 4 hours. These contradicting times are counted here and noted under honest claims. The payouts traders dispute were refused during the firm’s review, so they are judged under fair enforcement.
Not settled by public evidence Whether a random sample of payouts requested in the last 90 days matches payment records and reached traders’ own Rise accounts or wallets within one stated time, counted from the request. Whether the contracting company can cover what it owes: neither company’s accounts are public, as Saint Lucia’s public IBC record holds only a company’s constitution, agent and office, and no Dubai free-zone register could be searched. The tracker can count payments to affiliates and staff, and the firm’s own $47 million total is higher and not audited.
Each program’s rules are published in detail in two help centres, which the terms make part of the contract, and many changes are dated and kept off accounts bought earlier: no news trading on Instant accounts bought after 13 November 2025, the Direct daily limit from 21 July 2026, Reserve payout goals from 27 July 2026, Express limits from 2 September, and futures plans sold before 6 July, which keep their old rules. But the Reserve maximum loss was lowered after 4 August 2026, from $1,500 to $1,000 on the $25K account, $3,500 to $3,000 on $100K and $5,000 to $4,500 on $150K, and the rules now give the lower limits with no date and no word on which accounts they cover; a September comparison found the $25K limit cut from $1,500 to $1,000 on the plan it calls Standard, whose limits match today’s Elite rules, which do not date the change either. In August the firm withdrew a Windfall Strategy Rule from futures accounts about a month after adding it, saying, as two affiliate sites report, that the rule had been communicated unclearly. The Fast-Track page points to a rule sheet in the trader’s dashboard. The Trader Agreement funded traders sign is not published before purchase; that fact is counted under identity and noted here.
Fix before issue
Make its plan tables agree with its help centres on 1 Step leverage, Express loss limits, Elite payout caps, Direct payout goals and the number of accounts per level.
Commit in its terms that rule changes never apply to accounts already bought unless they favour the trader.
Give the year for changes dated only by day and month, such as 20 August, 2 September and 6 July.
Not settled by public evidence Whether the lower Reserve and Elite limits, or the Windfall Strategy Rule, were applied to accounts bought before them, and whether any payout was refused under a rule added after purchase: one affiliate site reports a payout refused under the Windfall Strategy Rule and reversed the same day, without saying when the account was bought. Whether the Fast-Track rule sheet holds rules beyond the page’s FAQ. No change log was found, and the terms let the firm change them at its sole discretion.
The rules name the grounds for refusing a payout, among them a shared device or CID match, copying other traders and margin use above 80%, and say some breaches are found only in a manual review at payout. The help centre says all compliance and risk decisions of the firm’s Risk Team are final and binding, and no appeal process is published; the terms offer only arbitration in Dubai, which does not count as a way to contest a decision. But decisions are looked at again informally: one of the reviews below says the firm closed an internal appeal as final, and an affiliate site reports that a payout refused under the Windfall Strategy Rule was reversed the same day once the trader shared the refusal publicly. So a decision can be contested only informally, with no formal appeal. Of the 20 most recent one-star Trustpilot reviews, read on 12 November 2026, 9 describe a payout refused or withheld; where a reason is reported it is a category, a shared device or CID match in 3 and copy trading in 2, and those reviewers say no evidence was shared. The first Guardian Shield trigger cuts the split to 50% for good, under a published rule. No term we read lets the firm refuse a payout or close an account for public criticism.
Not settled by public evidence Whether refusal notices name the rule and what the trader did, and whether the evidence is kept; 3 of those reviews report no reason from the firm, which a sample of the firm’s notices would settle. When the firm agrees to look again at a decision, and who decides: no route is published.
The footer, the terms and the help centre say plainly that every account is simulated, that the firm is not a broker and that it is not a licensed investment services provider; no page we read claims a licence. But other published claims say traders trade real capital: the terms say traders who pass are allocated capital to trade in a live account, the Fast-Track page promises real capital from day one, a real $100K account and every loss covered, the Instant Starter page a real $5,000 account, and the How it works page the live market. Trustpilot says it removed fake reviews for the firm and withholds its rating for a breach of its guidelines, as it still did on 12 November 2026. The 24-hour payout guarantees on the sales pages, shown without what they cover, are counted under payouts with the help-centre times they contradict.
Fix before issue
Make its payout totals agree, or date them: its pages give over $47 million, $40 million, $32 million and $25 million.
Make its highest profit split agree across pages, which give up to 90%, 95% and 100%.
Not settled by public evidence Whether the firm corrects these claims once they are raised; we have not raised them with Blue Guardian. When Trustpilot’s notices were placed.
No alert names Blue Guardian or Iconic Exchange in IOSCO’s I-SCAN database, the Bank of Russia’s warning list does not list it, and the FCA’s register returned no firm named Blue Guardian, blueguardian or Iconic Exchange. Traders can complain by live chat, by email, or in writing as the terms direct. The firm replied publicly to none of the 20 most recent one-star reviews on its main Trustpilot profile, read on 12 November 2026, but only one of them says none of its emails was answered, while 9 quote a reason or a reply from the firm. It answers reviews on its former futures profile, which no longer accepts new ones.
Fix before issue
Publish a time to answer complaints.
Not settled by public evidence The FCA’s warning list page itself, which showed a browser check, and national warning lists outside I-SCAN; and how the firm handles complaints sent to it, which needs a sample of its complaint records.
Blue Guardian has not seen this view. It is not a review, a certificate, an approval or an endorsement, and what public evidence could not settle is never counted against the firm.
Checked against version 1.1 on , from public sources only
Nothing is not met, and “Payouts are paid”, “Rules a trader can rely on” and “Fair enforcement, and a way to appeal” are conditional: a certificate shows those conditions, with a dated plan to close them within 90 days.
01Who you are dealing with
Met
The terms name TakeProfitTrader LLC as the company that owns and operates the service, and the terms, home page and payout pages name no other company that sells to, funds or pays traders: payouts are sent by the firm through Plaid, PayPal, Wise or Routable, and live PRO+ accounts trade what the firm calls TPT’s own capital through Tradovate. Florida’s register shows the LLC active with every annual report filed. The company that manages it has one officer, the founder and CEO, James Sixsmith, who is named publicly as the person in charge.
Fix before issue
Show its Florida company number, L21000145354, on its own pages, beside the name and address its terms and footer already give.
Not settled by public evidence Who owns the LLC. Its listed member, Oslo Six Investment Services LLLP, has no public owners, Florida holds no record of it and Arizona’s partnership register could not be reached. Whose account at Tradovate holds the live capital: the power-of-attorney form funded traders sign names the trader as manager, and the help centre does not say who the account holder is. The terms also mention a parent company and affiliates without naming them; nothing public says they sell to, fund or pay traders.
Once money is in the TPT wallet, which the firm runs, the help centre gives a time for the main payout methods: a payout request is approved by staff within up to 12 business hours, then Plaid is typically real time but can take 1 to 2 business days, and PayPal and Wise take up to 12 business hours, with same-day deposit not guaranteed. But the firm’s pages contradict those times: its payout page offers instant payouts through Plaid, PayPal or Wise, and its home page calls the withdrawal process immediate. No time is stated for Routable, which the payout page also lists, or for the manual review that Rithmic PRO, PRO+ and cancelled accounts need before money reaches the wallet; for most Tradovate PRO accounts that step takes 5 to 10 seconds. On public evidence payouts are paid: 7 of the 20 most recent Trustpilot reviews praise its payouts, 6 of them as fast, easy or smooth, and neither the 20 most recent one-star reviews nor BBB’s most recent complaints say an approved payout went unpaid. BBB’s pattern-of-complaints alert names payout problems among its subjects without saying what they were, and the firm’s reply to BBB speaks of shortening payout processing. The disputes on record concern accounts closed before a payout, so they are judged under fair enforcement.
Fix before issue
Make its payout pages agree on the methods offered: the payout page names three options, Plaid, PayPal and Wise, then lists Routable as well, which the withdrawal guide does not mention.
Not settled by public evidence Whether a random sample of payouts matches bank and payment records and was paid within the time stated for its method: that needs the firm’s records, it publishes no total, and no third party tracks its payouts. Whether TakeProfitTrader LLC can cover the payouts it owes: it publishes no accounts, its Florida filings could not be opened, and it says PRO payouts are funded from test fees, tech fees and its share of PRO+ profits.
Each rule is published and dated in the help centre, the numbers agree across pages, and the August 2026 cut to 3 test days applied only to tests bought afterwards. But the PRO trader contract that governs funded accounts is not public before purchase. And in the last 12 months rules that can cost an account or a payout were added with nothing to spare accounts bought before them, so they reach those accounts: the Sustainable Trading Policy, shown as dated 1 July 2026, lets the firm part ways with a funded trader without prior notice on its own judgement, and the Universal Trading Policies and the Independent Trade Execution Policy, shown as dated 6 March and 7 April 2026, apply to Test, PRO and PRO+ accounts alike and allow profit forfeiture, which the second says may come before, during or after a payout review. PRO+ Development, dated 28 May 2026, lets the firm put existing live accounts on smaller limits, leaving payouts unchanged.
Fix before issue
Commit in its terms that rule changes never apply to accounts already bought unless they favour the trader.
Make the payout Q&A agree with the trading policies on what can stop a payout: it says a withdrawal can be denied for only four technical reasons, while the Independent Trade Execution Policy allows forfeiture before, during or after a payout review.
Not settled by public evidence What the PRO trader contract says, since it is not public. Whether any of these policies has been used to refuse a payout on an account bought before it appeared, and what each replaced: the firm keeps no dated change log, help-centre pages show only their latest edit date, and archived copies were not checked.
A decision can be contested only informally: the firm publishes no appeal of its own for a closure, a restriction or a forfeiture, but its public replies show support looking at disputed decisions again. On 10 November 2026 it replied on Trustpilot to a trader whose account had been held over a payment flag that, after the trader spoke to its Risk team, the dispute had been fully reviewed and cleared and access restored. The same day it told a trader who had disputed an unintended trade, and whom it had told on 28 October that there was nothing further it could do to modify the account status, that it had sent instructions for submitting platform logs for further review. Its terms and help pages do not declare its decisions final. In one public reply, to a trader whose purchases and resets were permanently disabled for shared-device activity (review dated 28 October 2026), it called the outcome definitive after what it described as a multi-layered review, offering only clarification from its Risk Team; that is a reply to one trader, not a term or help page. Apart from refused registrations, which come before any purchase, its 88 help-centre articles offer a review only of a move to PRO+ Development, by email, with no deadline and no named decider, and nothing for closures or forfeitures under the counter-position, coordinated-trading or sustainable-trading rules; the terms offer only Florida courts and individual arbitration, which do not count. Counter-position closures do name the rule and what the trader did, through a report of the trades. No public term lets the firm refuse a payout or close an account for public criticism: the terms let it end access for any reason, and their rule on content covers posts made with the firm’s own site tools. PRO+ Development cuts contract sizes, not the 90% profit share. The Sustainable Trading Policy’s power to part ways without notice is counted under rules.
Not settled by public evidence Whether every refusal or closure notice names the rule and what the trader did, and whether the evidence is kept and shared on request. That needs a sample of notices. Whether support will look again at any disputed decision on request, and who decides. Whether the PRO trader contract, which is not public, provides an appeal or has a term about public criticism.
The firm says plainly that test and PRO accounts are simulated and PRO+ is live, says it is not a broker, and claims no licence: its home page says neither the NFA nor the CFTC requires it to register, and NFA’s records show no registration. We found no review platform withholding its rating or warning the public over fake or manipulated reviews: Trustpilot showed no notice on 12 November 2026, and BBB’s withheld rating is over a pattern of complaints, so it is judged under standing. The payout Q&A’s statement that a withdrawal can be denied for only four reasons concerns the automated step to the wallet and is recorded under rules. Some home-page figures disagree with the help centre: live support 24 hours a day against chat hours of Sunday to Friday, and a failed test costing at most $360 against a subscription that renews until cancelled. Its claims of immediate and instant payouts are counted under payouts.
Fix before issue
Make its home page agree with its help centre on support hours and on what a failed test can cost.
Not settled by public evidence Whether Trustpilot showed a fake-review notice at any time in the last 12 months: the Internet Archive’s four captures of the profile from that period did not load. Whether the firm’s figure of over 90,000 active traders and its pass rates hold up. We have not raised any of these with Take Profit Trader.
No alert names Take Profit Trader in IOSCO’s I-SCAN database, and NFA’s records show no registration or action. Traders can complain through the live chat and support email the help centre publishes. BBB is withholding its rating while it evaluates a pattern of complaints about unresponsive customer service, account activation and disabling, and payouts; it wrote to the firm on 20 March 2026, and the firm has since replied with commitments, among them more support staff, clearer explanations of account restrictions and faster payout processing. BBB is not a regulator, and its alert gives no share of complaints left unanswered. Where complaints can be seen, they get an answer: BBB marks all 261 complaints of the last three years answered (207) or resolved (54), and each of the 10 most recent, from 21 July to 23 September 2026, carries a business response, though in none did the firm grant what was asked. The firm also replies publicly to most negative reviews: 67% on Trustpilot, and 17 of the 20 most recent one-star reviews on 12 November 2026.
Fix before issue
Publish a complaints procedure and a time to answer.
Not settled by public evidence Whether most complaints made through live chat and the support email get an answer, which only the firm’s records can show; BBB’s alert says complaints describe unresponsive customer service, without numbers. Whether the firm’s model needs CFTC registration, a legal question public sources do not settle; the CFTC’s own site search could not be read. Whether complaints are answered within a reasonable time, and whether the firm has kept the commitments in its reply to BBB, which BBB does not date.
Take Profit Trader has not seen this view. It is not a review, a certificate, an approval or an endorsement, and what public evidence could not settle is never counted against the firm.
Checked against version 1.1 on , from public sources only
Nothing is not met, and “Who you are dealing with”, “Payouts are paid”, “Rules a trader can rely on”, “Fair enforcement, and a way to appeal” and “Honest claims” are conditional: a certificate shows those conditions, with a dated plan to close them within 90 days.
01Who you are dealing with
Conditional
Two companies are named, each with a number: CTI FZCO in Dubai Silicon Oasis and City Traders Imperium Limited in the Comoros. But the terms define the company traders deal with as both, while the footer says the programs are provided by the Comoros company alone, so which one contracts with and pays a trader is unclear. Neither is on a public register we could reach, and no owner of either is named. The founders were directors and, through their holding companies, owners of the UK company until it was dissolved in June 2026; the firm names its chief executive and co-founder.
Not settled by public evidence Whether both companies are registered and active, which one contracts with and pays traders, and who owns 25% or more of each: Dubai Silicon Oasis has no free public register, and the only listing of the Comoros company is on a website the Comoros central bank disputes. The firm would have to share its ownership documents. The licence claim is counted under honest claims, not here.
No public record shows CTI payments: no tracker counts them, PropFirmMap holds no payout proofs for any firm, and TheTrustedProp has no blockchain data for CTI. The firm publishes no total or count. Its stated times contradict each other: the home page and payout-proof post promise payouts within 24 hours and an 8-hour average, while the help centre allows up to 2 business days for a risk review into a wallet the firm runs, then 1 business day to send, before the bank’s own time. The companies that pay file no public accounts.
Fix before issue
Give one payout time on every page, counted from the request to money the trader controls: the home page and payout-proof post say 24 hours and an 8-hour average, the help centre up to three business days.
Not settled by public evidence Whether a random sample of payouts requested in the last 90 days matches bank or blockchain records, and how many reached traders within the stated time counted to money they control; and whether the paying company can cover what it owes. The chief executive says reserves would cover a year without revenue; that is his statement, not a record.
Each program’s rules are published before purchase, on the program pages and in a dated help centre, and the terms are public. But rules that can void profit or end an account, such as one-sided bets, over-leverage and the one-minute stop-loss, sit only in the help centre; the one-sided bets answer, updated on 20 August 2026, says the firm’s detection logic was updated without saying when or which accounts it covers; and the chief executive says stricter changes apply only to new purchases except around copy trading and VPN use, which are handled case by case.
Fix before issue
Make its pages agree on whether open losses count toward the stop-out level, how the 2-Step daily limit works, whether hedging is banned and whether VPNs are allowed.
Commit in its terms not to apply rule changes to accounts already bought: clause 17.3 lets changes take effect for contracts already entered into.
Not settled by public evidence Whether any rule change in the last 12 months reached accounts already bought and cost a trader a payout, which would mean not met: the firm keeps no public change log, and only archived copies or its own records could show it.
In its public replies to disputed closures and refused payouts, the firm usually names the rule and often the trades, such as missing stop-losses or a one-sided run on one pair. A complaint can be escalated to senior management, who review it within 5 business days. But the Code of Conduct lets the firm sanction public complaints, reviews or posts aimed at forcing a favourable response, with payouts forfeited or a permanent ban, though we found no case of it being used; and decisions on one-sided bets are made by the firm’s risk team with no stated appeal beyond that escalation.
Fix before issue
Name the escalation route in the terms, which send complaints to a different address with a 30-day limit and mention no appeal.
Not settled by public evidence Whether every refusal, closure or cut names the rule and what the trader did in writing, whether the evidence is kept and summarised on request, and whether escalations are decided within 15 business days by someone not involved in the first decision: that needs a sample of notices and complaint outcomes.
The terms and footer say plainly that every account is simulated and that neither company is a broker. But the help centre calls CTI a licensed firm regulated in the Union of the Comoros, operating under its own regulated brokerage licence, L15969/CTI; that licence is listed only by a body the Comoros central bank has called a fictitious structure, saying such licensing is its exclusive remit. The payout-proof post says CTI is registered in England and Wales and keeps regulatory compliance, citing a company dissolved in June 2026, and other pages speak of live capital and live market execution.
Fix before issue
Date its track-record claims and give figures for them: the home page and About page claim eight years of payouts approved within 24 hours and an 8-hour average, with no totals or period.
Not settled by public evidence Whether CTI corrects these within 30 days of our raising them; we have not raised them. If the licence claim stays up after that, the method rates this requirement not met and the firm not certifiable. No review platform has withheld CTI’s rating or warned about its reviews.
No alert names City Traders Imperium or its website in IOSCO’s I-SCAN database, and no other regulator warning naming the firm was found; the Comoros central bank’s 2022 warning names the body that lists CTI’s licence, not CTI. Traders have a published way to complain, acknowledged within 1 business day with escalation to senior management, and the firm replied publicly to 93% of negative Trustpilot reviews and to 18 of the 19 latest one-star ones.
Fix before issue
Give one complaints route and one time to answer: the contact page promises up to 30 business days via support, the terms 30 calendar days via the admin address.
Not settled by public evidence Regulator lists outside I-SCAN, which we could not search fully, and whether complaints sent privately get an answer, which needs the firm’s complaint records.
City Traders Imperium has not seen this view. It is not a review, a certificate, an approval or an endorsement, and what public evidence could not settle is never counted against the firm.
Checked against version 1.1 on , from public sources only
Nothing is not met, and “Who you are dealing with”, “Payouts are paid”, “Rules a trader can rely on”, “Fair enforcement, and a way to appeal” and “Honest claims” are conditional: a certificate shows those conditions, with a dated plan to close them within 90 days.
01Who you are dealing with
Conditional
The terms name Orion Global FZCO, of Dubai Silicon Oasis, as the provider every trader contracts with, under UAE law. But the funded stage, the Orion Trader Program, is offered by an applicable third-party entity that neither the terms nor the help centre names, and Orion Global FZCO says it is in no way involved in that agreement, so which company funds and pays traders is unclear. The footer also names OGM International Ltd., which Saint Lucia’s registry lists as an international business company, without saying what it does for traders. No owner of either company is named; a July 2026 press release names David Viota Estévez as chief executive of OGM Group, the group behind Orion Funded.
Fix before issue
Show the company numbers of Orion Global FZCO and OGM International Ltd. on its own pages, beside the names and addresses the terms and footer already give.
Not settled by public evidence Whether Orion Global FZCO is registered and active, and under what number: Dubai Silicon Oasis has no free public register we could find. OGM International Ltd.’s number, date and status, which need a paid search. Which company signs the Orion Trader Account Agreement and pays rewards, and who owns 25% or more of each company: the firm would have to share its documents.
Public evidence shows payouts flowing: an on-chain tracker counts 583 payouts worth $591,516 in the last 90 days, on 21 of the last 30 days, though these are wallet totals rather than matched trader payouts, from a site that gave the firm an award. The firm publishes no payout count and no audited total. Its stated times are incomplete and contradict each other: the program pages promise payment in under 48 hours with 0 delays and the futures page about 15 minutes, but the guarantee counts 48 hours from approval, not the request, and pauses for compliance, risk and fraud reviews that have no stated time; and the terms allow the first request at once while the help centre makes traders wait 14 days. Rewards are paid by Rise or USDT, the home page says. Refused payouts described in reviews are judged under fair enforcement; the guarantee’s wording is counted under honest claims.
Fix before issue
Give one first-payout rule on every page: the terms allow the first request at once, the help centre only after 14 days.
Not settled by public evidence Whether a random sample of payouts requested in the last 90 days matches Rise or blockchain records and reached traders within a stated time counted from the request. Whether the paying company, which the terms do not name, can cover what it owes: no company in the group files public accounts we could find.
Each program’s targets and loss limits are published before purchase on the program pages and in terms dated 16 September 2026, and they agree. But the Orion Trader Account Agreement that governs funded accounts is made available only after a trader passes and completes identity checks, so it is not public before purchase. The firm keeps no change log and its help-centre answers carry no dates. Two Trustpilot reviewers say the maximum loss was cut from 10% to 8% on accounts already bought and passed, without notice; the firm replied that accounts keep the conditions in force when bought and that its New Generation program has different rules.
Fix before issue
Make its pages agree on when the trailing drawdown locks, what counts as gap trading and when the trading day resets.
Commit in its terms not to apply rule changes to accounts already bought: clause 18 lets a change reach every agreement 7 days after notice, and rejecting it ends them all.
Not settled by public evidence Whether any rule change in the last 12 months, such as the move to the New Generation program, reached accounts already bought and cost a trader a payout, which would mean not met: only archived pages or the firm’s records could show it, and none was checked. What the Orion Trader Account Agreement says.
Reasons reach traders, but often only as a category. In public replies the firm sometimes names the rule, such as grid trading, but refused traders quote decisions citing coordinated trading, mechanical strategy execution or non-authentic execution patterns, and one reply cites internal detection systems and methodologies. A decision can be looked at again only informally: a trader who thinks a suspension is a mistake can write to support, complaints are answered in writing within 30 calendar days, and the firm’s replies invite reviewers to write in for a review, but no appeal, deadline or independent decider is named, and the terms let it act without notice. The terms make payout reviews and decisions confidential, bar traders from posting them on review platforms, and let the firm withhold or void payouts and end accounts for that or for disparaging statements. Two reviewers say the firm threatened legal action, one over the review itself, and two that a fee refund came only with confidentiality and non-disparagement terms, but we found no case of a trader losing a payout or an account for criticism.
Not settled by public evidence Whether every refusal or closure notice names the rule and the trades, whether the evidence is kept and summarised on request, and who decides a disputed case and how fast: that needs a sample of notices and complaint outcomes. Whether the confidentiality or non-disparagement terms have been used against a trader.
The terms, footer and help centre say plainly that every account is a simulated demo account, that the firm is not a broker, takes no deposits and is not regulated; it claims no licence. But the program pages promise payment in under 48 hours or a full refund without saying there what the guarantee covers: the terms count the 48 hours from approval and suspend them for weekends, holidays, payment delays and compliance, risk or fraud reviews. The futures page calls $7,347,878 verified payouts without naming a verifier and claims payouts in about 15 minutes. Trustpilot showed no notice about fake or manipulated reviews on 13 November 2026; one reviewer says the firm asked for good ratings in exchange for accounts, which the firm denies.
Fix before issue
Date its track-record figures and make them agree: the program pages claim more than 200,000 traders, the help centre 150,000 clients.
Not settled by public evidence Whether Orion Funded corrects the guarantee wording within 30 days of our raising it; we have not raised it. Whether Trustpilot showed a fake-review notice at any time in the last 12 months: no archived copy was checked.
No alert names Orion Funded, its website or OGM International in IOSCO’s I-SCAN database, and no other regulator warning naming the firm was found. Traders have a published way to complain, by email or the client area, with receipt and outcome confirmed in writing within 30 calendar days. Complaints made in public get an answer: the firm replies to 98% of negative Trustpilot reviews and replied to 19 of the 20 latest one-star reviews.
Not settled by public evidence Regulator lists outside I-SCAN, which we did not search one by one, and whether complaints sent privately get an answer, which needs the firm’s records.
Orion Funded has not seen this view. It is not a review, a certificate, an approval or an endorsement, and what public evidence could not settle is never counted against the firm.
Checked against version 1.1 on , from public sources only
Nothing is not met, and “Who you are dealing with”, “Payouts are paid”, “Rules a trader can rely on”, “Fair enforcement, and a way to appeal” and “Honest claims” are conditional: a certificate shows those conditions, with a dated plan to close them within 90 days.
01Who you are dealing with
Conditional
Two companies are named and their roles are plain. The Terms of Use name Breakout Trading Group, LLC, a Delaware limited liability company, as the company behind the website, and the help centre says it runs the evaluations; Payward Oceanic, Ltd (POL) signs a separate Funded Trader Agreement with traders who pass, and approves and sends their payouts. The LEI register shows Payward Oceanic Ltd. as an active British Virgin Islands company, number 2061297, renamed from Payward OTC Ltd. in May 2025. Kraken announced that it acquired Breakout with effect from 1 September 2025, and its release names Breakout’s co-founder and chief executive, Alex Miningham. But no register we could open shows Breakout Trading Group, LLC, and no record names an owner or director of either company: POL’s LEI record reports no parent.
Not settled by public evidence Whether Breakout Trading Group, LLC is registered and active: Delaware’s search returned no result in our browser and bars automated tools, and Florida shows no company of that name. Who owns 25% or more of each company and who directs them, including which Kraken company holds Breakout and whether POL belongs to the same group: the firm would have to share its ownership documents.
Payouts are sent in USDC on Ethereum, a public blockchain, but Breakout publishes no paying wallet, and TheTrustedProp says live blockchain payout data is not yet available for the firm; no other tracker or audit was found. The firm’s own evidence is a leaderboard of lifetime payouts by trader handle and a paid total that differs between pages, $80M or more on the home page and $60M or more on the Kraken page. Its stated times contradict each other: the pricing page promises no waiting periods and no approval delays, while the help centre says POL’s approval can take 12 to 24 hours, and no page gives a time from approval to the transfer. We found no public accounts for POL.
Fix before issue
Give one payout time on every page, counted from the request to USDC in the trader’s wallet: the pricing page says no approval delays, the help centre 12 to 24 hours.
Not settled by public evidence Whether a random sample of payouts requested in the last 90 days matches blockchain records and reached traders’ own wallets within one stated time, counted from the request; and whether POL can cover what it owes, which needs its accounts or a statement of reserves. One of the 20 latest one-star reviews says a payout was blocked after a first $900 payout; it has no public reply.
Each plan’s target, loss limits and leverage are published before purchase, on the pricing page and in help-centre answers dated September 2026, and the Terms of Use are public. But the breach rules point to an Evaluation Agreement and a Funded Trader Agreement, which define prohibited trading, and neither has a public copy: the Funded Trader Agreement is emailed after a trader passes. When the 2-Step evaluation was withdrawn, evaluations already bought kept the rules in force when bought, though the help centre gives no date for the change, and the cut in trading fees on non-crypto markets favours traders. Leverage is reviewed periodically and may change, with no date or scope given.
Fix before issue
Make the home and pricing pages agree with the help centre on whether a passed evaluation becomes a funded account automatically, or only after a KYC check, the Funded Trader Agreement and a final approval.
Commit in its terms not to apply rule changes to accounts already bought: the Terms of Use let Breakout revise them at any time, with continued use counted as acceptance.
Not settled by public evidence What the two agreements say, and whether any rule change in the last 12 months, such as a change of leverage, reached accounts already bought and cost a trader a payout: the firm keeps no public change log, and archived copies of its pages were not checked.
The help centre lists the banned practices and their penalties, from a warning for a first, inadvertent cross-account hedge to ending every linked account and forfeiting profit, but sets no thresholds and leaves the decision to Breakout’s discretion, or to POL’s sole discretion for trading it says threatens its relationships with exchanges or market makers. No appeal is published: the contact page offers email and live chat, and the terms ask for a written notice and 60 days to settle before arbitration, which does not count as a way to contest a decision. In public replies to four traders whose accounts were closed after identity checks, the firm cites its terms on KYC and account integrity and declines to discuss specifics, which names a category, not what the trader did; one of the four says an appeal was rejected, so decisions are looked at again informally. No term we read lets the firm act against a trader for public criticism; one reviewer says a caller threatened legal action over a review, which the firm replied was unacceptable.
Not settled by public evidence Whether every refusal, closure or cut names the rule and what the trader did in writing, whether the evidence is kept and summarised on request, and whether a second look is decided within 15 business days by someone not involved: that needs a sample of notices and outcomes. What the Evaluation and Funded Trader Agreements say about closures and criticism, since neither is public; that they are not public is counted under rules.
The help centre says plainly that evaluation and funded accounts trade simulated capital, and the site disclosure explains that POL may book a funded trader’s ideas internally or route them for its own account. No page we read claims a licence or regulation, and the help centre says payouts are not insured or guaranteed. But the home page headline reads Trade our money, and Kraken’s announcement of the acquisition, which promotes Breakout with a discount code, says traders can access up to $200,000 in live trading capital, while the help centre says a funded account trades simulated capital, not real capital. Trustpilot shows no notice about fake reviews, only one saying the company may be associated with high-risk investments.
Fix before issue
Date its paid-to-traders figure and make its pages agree: $80M or more on the home page, $60M or more on the Kraken page.
Make its Trustpilot figures agree with the profile: the home page shows 4.7 with 1,000 or more reviews in one place and 950 or more in another, while Trustpilot showed 4.6 from 1,286.
Not settled by public evidence Whether Breakout and Kraken correct the capital claims within 30 days of our raising them; we have not raised them. Whether Trustpilot showed a fake-review notice at any time in the last 12 months: archived copies of the profile were not checked. Advertising beyond the pages we read.
No alert names Breakout or breakoutprop in IOSCO’s I-SCAN database. Traders can complain through the support email and live chat the contact page publishes, and the terms ask for a written notice before any dispute. Of the 20 most recent one-star Trustpilot reviews, the firm replied publicly to 12, though to none of the six posted since 27 October 2026, and the profile shows replies to 42% of negative reviews; an unanswered public review is not by itself an unanswered complaint.
Fix before issue
Publish a complaints procedure and a time to answer.
Not settled by public evidence Regulator warning lists outside I-SCAN, which we did not search one by one, and whether complaints sent to support get an answer, which needs the firm’s complaint records.
Breakout has not seen this view. It is not a review, a certificate, an approval or an endorsement, and what public evidence could not settle is never counted against the firm.
Checked against version 1.1 on , from public sources only
Nothing is not met, and “Payouts are paid”, “Rules a trader can rely on”, “Fair enforcement, and a way to appeal” and “Honest claims” are conditional: a certificate shows those conditions, with a dated plan to close them within 90 days.
01Who you are dealing with
Met
The Terms of Use and the Evaluation Services Agreement name Tradeify Holdings, Corp as the company that runs the site and contracts with traders, and both name two others: Tradeify Brokerage LLC, trading as Slay Markets, an affiliated introducing broker, and Novaflame LTD of Cyprus, a payment agent processing funds on behalf of Tradeify Holdings. All three are active on a register we opened: Florida’s for the first two, with the corporation’s 2026 annual report filed, and Cyprus’s for Novaflame. Payouts are paid by Tradeify Holdings through Rise, whose invitation comes from it. Florida lists Brett Simberkoff, Vinan Mistry and Dane Nakama as the corporation’s officers and directors; the first two are named publicly as its CEO and COO and its co-founders, and NFA lists all three, with Tradeify Holdings, as owners of 10% or more of the brokerage.
Fix before issue
Show its Florida company number, P25000043724, on its own pages, beside the name its terms already give.
Give the same principal address in its terms and on the Florida register, which shows Cedar City, Utah, where the terms say Boca Raton.
Not settled by public evidence Who owns 25% or more of Tradeify Holdings, Corp and of Novaflame LTD: Florida does not publish shareholders, and the free Cyprus record lists directors only. Which company holds the capital of Elite Live accounts, which the agreement says are issued through NinjaTrader and GFF Brokers. What Tradeify Funding LLC, a Florida company managed by the CEO and Tradeify Holdings and not named in the terms, does. Which companies merged into Tradeify Holdings in September 2026. The Tradeify FX brand, sold by a Saint Lucia company, is outside this view.
The firm’s stated payout times contradict each other. The agreement says approved payouts are typically issued within 24 to 48 hours, or up to 72 outside business hours, but also lets the firm take until the end of the next payout cycle to approve, review or deny a request. The help centre says payment follows within 24 hours of approval and promises 24 hours for Select Daily, after which Rise takes 1 to 3 business days by bank or hours to a day in crypto; money held in Rise is not yet in an account the trader controls. The home page promises payment in minutes and 1-hour payouts. On public evidence payouts are paid: the firm says over $350 million has been paid, Trustpilot shows 4.6 from 7,152 reviews, and none of the 20 most recent one-star reviews shows an approved payout left unpaid for good. But 9 of those 20 describe payouts held under review, denied or late, three after identity or KYT checks of one to three weeks; holds without a stated rule are judged under fair enforcement. The home page’s claim of a 0% denial rate is counted under honest claims.
Not settled by public evidence Whether a random sample of payouts matches Rise and bank records and was paid within the time stated for its method: that needs the firm’s records, its payout totals are neither dated nor audited, and Prop Firm Match’s payout tracker turned automated requests away. Whether Tradeify Holdings, Corp can cover the payouts it owes: it publishes no accounts.
Each plan’s limits are published size by size, the Evaluation Services Agreement that binds funded traders is public before purchase, and the dated changes we found spared accounts already bought: new Select payout caps from 1 September 2026 apply only to accounts bought from then, and accounts bought before 12 September 2025 keep their older sizes and caps. But in the last 12 months rules that can cost a payout or an account were added without saying which accounts they cover: the Risk and Compliance Guidelines, last updated on 15 September 2026 and published on 1 October, and the Know Your Trader policy, shown without a date, let the firm restrict or withhold payouts, void activity and close accounts after reviews it starts at its discretion, with no measurable threshold. The agreement lets help-centre rules, which prevail over it on trading rules, change on posting, and allows enforcement for past conduct in accounts already passed or funded.
Fix before issue
Make the Terms of Use and the agreement agree on disputes: the terms name courts in Dallas, Texas, the agreement binding arbitration in Florida.
Commit in the agreement that rule changes never apply to accounts already bought unless they favour the trader.
Not settled by public evidence Whether any of these reviews has refused a payout on an account bought before the rule appeared, and what earlier versions of the rules said: most help-centre articles show only a relative update date, no change log is published, and archived copies were not checked.
Reasons may be given only as a category: the Risk and Compliance Guidelines say the firm may give the general basis or the policy category of an enforcement action and need not disclose its risk indicators. No appeal is published: none of the 80 article titles in the help centre’s index names one, and the terms and the agreement offer only courts or arbitration, which do not count. The guidelines also say not every determination can be reconsidered and that one communicated as final gives no right to a new review. But a decision can be looked at again informally: the guidelines say the firm may ask for more information where that could resolve an issue, the KYT policy says a staff member reviews every interview, and on Trustpilot the firm told a trader whose payout had been under review for over a week that the account was cleared and the payout approved. The hedging rule names the rule and its thresholds. No term we read lets the firm refuse a payout or close an account for public criticism.
Not settled by public evidence Whether refusal and closure notices name the rule and what the trader did, which needs a sample of notices, and whether a review on request is open to every trader, with a deadline, and decided by someone not involved. One of the 20 most recent one-star reviews says the reviewer’s access to a program was revoked after an earlier one-star review; the firm’s public reply denied offering rewards for reviews. It is one person’s account, and no term we read supports it.
The home page, the agreement and the help centre say plainly that evaluation and funded accounts are simulated and that only Elite Live accounts are live, and the terms say Tradeify Holdings, Corp is not registered with the CFTC or the NFA; the registration they claim for Slay Markets matches NFA’s record, an introducing broker since 20 April 2026. Trustpilot showed no notice about fake or manipulated reviews on 13 November 2026. But the home page claims a 0% payout denial rate and no hidden rules, while the agreement lets the firm suspend payouts and forfeit profits, the risk guidelines say a payout request does not guarantee approval, the hedging rule lists payout denial as a consequence, and recent one-star reviews describe denials. Its claims of payment in minutes are counted under payouts.
Fix before issue
Make its figures agree: $400 million against $350 million paid, 100,000 against 80,000 traders, and support 24/7 against 24/5.
Not settled by public evidence Whether the firm corrects the 0% denial claim once it is raised: we have not raised it with Tradeify. Whether a review platform posted a fake-review notice earlier in the last 12 months: archived copies of the Trustpilot profile were not checked. Whether its trader counts and payout totals hold up.
No alert names Tradeify, Slay Markets or Novaflame in IOSCO’s I-SCAN database, and NFA’s record of Tradeify Brokerage LLC shows no NFA, CFTC or exchange action, arbitration decision or reparations case. Traders can complain through the support the home page advertises, and the firm answers most public complaints: Trustpilot shows replies to 93% of negative reviews, typically within a week.
Fix before issue
Publish a complaints procedure and a time to answer.
Not settled by public evidence Whether most complaints made to support get an answer, which only the firm’s records can show: 6 of the 20 most recent one-star reviews say support stopped answering or closed tickets unresolved, and the firm had replied publicly to 3 of the 20, though it may answer privately. No complaints procedure or time to answer is published.
Tradeify has not seen this view. It is not a review, a certificate, an approval or an endorsement, and what public evidence could not settle is never counted against the firm.
Checked against version 1.1 on , from public sources only
Nothing is not met, and “Who you are dealing with”, “Payouts are paid”, “Rules a trader can rely on”, “Fair enforcement, and a way to appeal” and “Honest claims” are conditional: a certificate shows those conditions, with a dated plan to close them within 90 days.
01Who you are dealing with
Conditional
The terms name the contracting company, Blueberry Markets (SVG) LLC trading as BlueberryFunded, and the footer gives its number, 2090 LLC 2022, and a Kingstown address. Saint Vincent’s register lists number 2090 as an active LLC incorporated on 12 April 2022, but under the name BlueberryFunded LLC; no entity named Blueberry Markets (SVG) LLC is on it. The footer also names BBF Treasury Pty Ltd for treasury services, an Australian company whose ABN has been active since June 2024, and Odeonpay ALE S.R.L. (Paysagi) as merchant of record for purchases. No owner of any of these companies is named publicly; trade press reported a general manager’s appointment in 2024.
Fix before issue
Use one company name in the terms, the footer and the register, or state the former name: the terms and footer say Blueberry Markets (SVG) LLC, the register BlueberryFunded LLC.
Not settled by public evidence Whether Blueberry Markets (SVG) LLC and BlueberryFunded LLC are one company under a former and a current name; who owns 25% or more of it and of BBF Treasury Pty Ltd, and who manages them: Saint Vincent’s public register lists no members or managers, and ASIC’s extract is a paid search we did not buy. Which company sends rewards to traders, the Saint Vincent company the terms name or the treasury company. Paysagi was not checked on a register. The firm would have to share its ownership documents; we have not asked.
Payments are visible in public records: TheTrustedProp counts 3,570 payouts worth $4,488,154.91 on public blockchains, though the latest it lists is dated 19 June 2026. But the firm’s stated times do not make one time from request to money: processing takes 1 to 2 business days counted from approval, whose own length is not stated, and the help centre says some rewards are now taking 7 to 14 business days while the firm upgrades its payment systems. The home page advertises on-demand rewards, while payouts run every 14 days, or every 7 with a paid add-on. Rewards go through RiseWorks or, up to $5,000, stablecoins.
Fix before issue
Make the terms and the help centre agree on payout methods: the terms say rewards go to a bank account the trader nominates, the help centre offers RiseWorks and crypto.
Not settled by public evidence Whether a random sample of payouts requested in the last 90 days matches Rise, blockchain or bank records, and how many reached traders within one stated time counted from the request; whether payouts kept going on-chain after June 2026 or moved outside the tracker; and whether the company that pays can cover what it owes: we found no public accounts for the Saint Vincent or the Australian company. The firm’s own total, over $9 million, is unaudited.
Each program’s rules are published before purchase in the Outline and Fees, dated 5 October 2026, which makes the help centre’s rules binding, and changes in the last 12 months were dated and announced: the ruleset of 12 March 2026 and the changes of 17 August 2026 apply only to accounts bought from those dates. But the synthetic changes of 8 October 2026 move funded accounts bought earlier onto the new rules at their next payout, adding a ban on grid trading and martingale, a 25% consistency rule in place of 30%, and a 5-minute minimum hold; we found no case of a payout refused under them. The Independent Contractor Agreement funded traders sign is not published. The firm may also impose a 1% risk limit, a 30% consistency rule or more trading days on any funded account at its sole discretion, telling the trader by email first.
Fix before issue
Make the home page, the Outline and Fees and the help centre agree on news trading, hedging within one account, martingale and grid trading, and whether the 1-Step is still sold.
Commit in the terms not to apply rule changes to accounts already bought: the Outline and Fees lets changes to fees, criteria or payouts apply to a trader after 1 day’s notice.
Not settled by public evidence Whether any payout was refused, or an account closed, under a rule added after the account was bought, such as the synthetic rules of 8 October 2026: only the firm’s records could show it, and no change log beyond its announcements was found. How often the discretionary risk limit adjustment is used, and what the unpublished Independent Contractor Agreement adds.
A breach can be appealed within 7 days, with a first response within 72 hours and a final outcome within 5 business days, and the firm’s public replies to disputed closures and refused payouts usually name the rule, such as shared access between accounts or households, matching devices, or hedging between accounts. But every appeal is reviewed by the Risk team, which also decides the conduct breaches it hears, so no appeal is decided by someone uninvolved; after 7 days a breach is final. The terms let the firm forfeit fees and payments for a contravention and end the service without cause. No term we read lets the firm refuse a payout or close an account for public criticism.
Not settled by public evidence Whether refusal and closure notices name, in writing, what the trader did as well as the rule, and whether the evidence is kept and summarised on request: three of the 20 latest one-star reviewers say they were given no reason or only a vague one, which a sample of the firm’s notices and appeal outcomes would settle.
The footer and the terms say plainly that every account is simulated, with no real capital allocated, and no page we read claims a licence for Blueberry Funded; the terms say its services are not financial services. But Trustpilot withholds the firm’s rating for a breach of its guidelines and says it removed a number of fake reviews, as it still did on 13 November 2026. A page on the firm’s site calls the broker Blueberry Markets regulated across multiple jurisdictions, naming no regulator; it makes no such claim for the prop firm. The advertised on-demand rewards, which the help centre’s 14-day cycle contradicts, are counted under payouts and noted here.
Fix before issue
Give a dated payout total: the home page says over $9 million paid out, with no date.
Not settled by public evidence When Trustpilot’s notice was placed, which Trustpilot does not show. The broker’s licences were not checked against regulators’ records, since no page or term says they cover Blueberry Funded.
No alert names Blueberry Funded, its website or its companies in IOSCO’s I-SCAN database. One alert there, from Malaysia’s Securities Commission, names the broker brand Blueberry Markets and blueberrymarkets.com as an unlicensed entity dealing in securities; it gives no company name and does not mention the prop firm, so it is noted, not counted, though Blueberry Funded’s terms name a company bearing the Blueberry Markets name and its restricted countries do not include Malaysia. Traders can raise problems by live chat or email and appeal a breach, and the firm replied publicly to all 20 of the latest one-star Trustpilot reviews.
Fix before issue
State a time to answer a complaint: the terms name no complaints procedure, and only appeals have a stated time.
Not settled by public evidence Whether the Malaysian alert concerns the company that runs Blueberry Funded, which only the firm or the regulator could settle: if it does, this requirement is conditional until the firm explains it. Regulator warning lists outside I-SCAN, which we did not search, and how the firm handles complaints sent to it privately.
Blueberry Funded has not seen this view. It is not a review, a certificate, an approval or an endorsement, and what public evidence could not settle is never counted against the firm.
Checked against version 1.1 on , from public sources only
Nothing is not met, and “Who you are dealing with”, “Payouts are paid”, “Rules a trader can rely on” and “Fair enforcement, and a way to appeal” are conditional: a certificate shows those conditions, with a dated plan to close them within 90 days.
01Who you are dealing with
Conditional
The terms name Lucid Trading Group LLC as the company traders deal with, and the plan, payout and refund pages name no other company that sells to, funds or pays traders: payouts go out through Plaid, WorkMarket by ADP or crypto. Florida’s register shows Lucid Trading Group LLC active there as a foreign company from Delaware since 12 October 2026, and New Jersey’s register lists it as a foreign LLC. But no owner, manager, director or executive is named on the firm’s pages or on those records, so the people in control are not named publicly; Florida’s filing names only an authorised person, with no stated role. The broker partner that holds live accounts, which the firm says it funds with its own capital, is not named either.
Fix before issue
Give its registration number and principal address on its own pages, beside the name its terms give: Florida’s register shows no. M26000016198 and a principal address in Rockaway, New Jersey, while the site gives only a Dover, Delaware address.
Not settled by public evidence Whether the company is active in Delaware, where it was formed: Delaware’s register showed a bot check we did not try to pass, and the image of the Florida filing could not be read. Who owns 25% or more and who runs it, which the firm would have to show with ownership documents. Which company holds the live accounts. The terms also mention affiliates without naming them; nothing public says they sell to, fund or pay traders.
8 sources
Terms of UseLucid Trading (Lucid Trading Group LLC)
Once a request is approved, the help centre says the money leaves the account within minutes and reaches the trader’s payment method within 2 business days, with WorkMarket funds as early as the next business day. It gives no time for the approval itself, or for crypto payouts, so no time is stated from request to money the trader controls; the home page advertises about 15 minutes from request to bank, which the help centre does not repeat. On public evidence payouts are paid: 13 of the 20 most recent Trustpilot reviews mention payouts received or paid fast, and of the 20 most recent one-star reviews one says an approved payout had not arrived after three weeks. The one-star reviews that describe payouts lost after bans, hedging findings or chargebacks concern accounts closed before a payout, so they are judged under fair enforcement.
Fix before issue
Give one payout time, counted from request to money the trader controls, on the home page and in the help centre: the home page says about 15 minutes, the help centre up to 2 business days after an approval it does not time.
Not settled by public evidence Whether a random sample of payouts requested in the last 90 days matches payment records and was paid within a stated time: that needs the firm’s records, it publishes only an undated figure of over $700 million earned by traders, and no independent payout record was found. Whether Lucid Trading Group LLC can cover the payouts it owes: it publishes no accounts. Whether the approved payout reported as late was paid.
Each plan’s target, loss limits, consistency rule and payout caps are published in dollars before purchase, on the home page and in a help centre that dates each article, and the changes we could date in the last 12 months spared accounts already bought: LucidPro’s payout consistency rose from 35% to 40% only for accounts bought or reset from 28 November 2025, and the live rules of February 2026 apply only to accounts bought or reset after 27 February 2026, as the firm’s March 2026 release also said. But every payout article requires traders to keep to an account agreement for their plan, and none of those agreements is public before purchase.
Fix before issue
Make its pages agree on the 25K LucidPro daily loss limit, on whether LucidFlex has a daily loss limit and on LucidDirect’s minimum days to payout.
Commit in its terms that rule changes never apply to accounts already bought unless they favour the trader: the terms make every change effective as soon as it is posted.
Not settled by public evidence What the account agreements say. Whether any other change in the last 12 months reached accounts already bought: the firm keeps no change log, help articles show only their latest update, archived copies were not checked, and the help centre keeps a legacy and a new live structure without saying which accounts the new one covers. The terms let changes take effect as soon as they are posted.
A decision can be appealed only in part: the help centre offers an appeal against microscalping and high-frequency-trading flags, with no deadline and no named decider, and names none for hedging findings, bans or closures, while the refund policy makes decisions on chargebacks final and binding. Hedging flags come with an email notice, and two of the 20 most recent one-star reviewers say they were sent the overlapping trades behind a cross-user hedging ban, one adding that he appealed, so some notices name what the trader did. The terms let the firm disable an account for any or no reason. They also let it bar a trader from a reward, or cancel one already earned, for disparaging Lucid or its competitors, though we found no case of it being used; the terms describe rewards as incentives for US residents, separate from payouts. The terms offer only Delaware courts and arbitration at the firm’s discretion, which do not count.
Not settled by public evidence Whether every refusal, closure or cut names the rule and what the trader did, and whether the evidence is kept and shared on request: that needs a sample of notices. Whether bans and hedging findings can be appealed on request, by whom and how fast. Whether the account agreements, which are not public, provide an appeal or a term about criticism, and whether the live bonus counts as a reward under the terms.
The home page and the terms say plainly that evaluation and funded accounts are simulated, the terms say the firm is not a broker-dealer, and it claims no licence; NFA’s records show no registration. The home page says traders the firm selects can move to a live brokerage account funded with its capital; no public source confirms or contradicts this, since the broker and account holder are not named, so it is left unsettled rather than counted. Trustpilot showed no notice about fake or manipulated reviews on 13 November 2026; one recent one-star reviewer alleges paid reviews, an allegation rather than a platform’s warning. The home page’s figures of over $700 million earned by traders and 500,000 traders are undated and unaudited. Its claim of about 15 minutes from request to bank is counted under payouts.
Fix before issue
Date the home-page figures for money earned by traders and traders served, and say what they count.
Update the terms, last modified on 20 March 2025, which describe subscriptions that renew automatically and a website only for people in the United States, while the firm sells one-time accounts to traders abroad.
Not settled by public evidence Whether Trustpilot showed a fake-review notice at any time in the last 12 months: archived copies of the profile were not checked. Whether the firm’s figures for money earned and traders served hold up. Whether traders moved live trade the firm’s own capital, and with which broker. We have not raised any of these with Lucid Trading.
No alert names Lucid Trading in IOSCO’s I-SCAN database, and NFA’s records show no registration or action. Traders have a published way to complain, through live chat, help-centre tickets and the support email the terms give, though no complaints procedure or time to answer is published. The firm replies publicly to no negative Trustpilot reviews, and 6 of the 20 most recent one-star reviews say support did not answer or closed tickets without a reply, fewer than half; an unanswered public review is not by itself an unanswered complaint.
Fix before issue
Publish a complaints procedure and a time to answer.
Not settled by public evidence Whether most complaints made through chat, tickets and email get an answer, which only the firm’s records can show. Whether the firm’s model needs CFTC registration, a legal question public sources do not settle. Regulator warning lists outside I-SCAN, which were not searched.
Lucid Trading has not seen this view. It is not a review, a certificate, an approval or an endorsement, and what public evidence could not settle is never counted against the firm.
Checked against version 1.1 on , from public sources only
Nothing is not met, and “Who you are dealing with”, “Payouts are paid”, “Rules a trader can rely on” and “Fair enforcement, and a way to appeal” are conditional: a certificate shows those conditions, with a dated plan to close them within 90 days.
01Who you are dealing with
Conditional
The terms name MyFunded Futures, LLC as the company providing the services, and the Texas Comptroller’s record shows it a Delaware limited liability company registered to do business in Texas since 29 September 2025, active, with a registered agent in Frisco. Simulated payouts are requested from the firm and paid through Riseworks, and no other company is named as selling to or paying simulated traders. But live accounts are offered, by the firm’s own footer and terms, through one of its affiliated companies, and the live-account FAQ refers to a partner futures commission merchant; neither is named, so which company funds and pays live traders is unclear. The people in control are not on the firm’s pages: the Texas record lists no officer, manager or member, and only the press names Matthew Leech as chief executive.
Fix before issue
Show its company’s Texas file number, 0806236794, and registered address on its own pages, beside the company name its terms and footer already give.
Not settled by public evidence Who owns 25% or more of MyFunded Futures, LLC and who manages it: Texas lists no one, and Delaware’s record was not searched because its search page prohibits automated tools. Which affiliated company offers live capital and which broker holds live accounts. Whether MyFunded Holding LLC, which NFA lists as a principal of an inactive introducing broker, belongs to the same owners. What the Simulated Trader Agreement, which governs funded accounts and is not public, names as its counterparty.
The help centre says most requests are approved automatically and that every payout is processed in 6 to 12 business hours, excluding holidays, through Riseworks by bank transfer, cryptocurrency or, for US traders, Plaid and ACH. But it states no time for money to reach the trader’s bank or wallet from Riseworks, for any method, and the home page contradicts the processing time, saying more than 75% of payouts are auto-approved in milliseconds. On public evidence payouts are paid: the firm says it has paid more than $300 million, undated, and of the 20 most recent one-star Trustpilot reviews, one says a $3,000 payout was left pending after the account was restricted and none says an approved payout was refused outright. The other review that concerns a payout describes a cut under a rule on short holding times, which is judged under rules and fair enforcement.
Not settled by public evidence Whether a random sample of payouts matches Riseworks, bank and blockchain records and was paid within the stated time: that needs the firm’s records, and no third-party payout tracker could be read. Whether MyFunded Futures, LLC can cover what it owes: it publishes no accounts. Who pays live traders, which is counted under identity.
Each plan’s rules are set out size by size in help-centre guides that show the date of their last update, and the changes we could date in the last 12 months spared accounts already bought or favoured traders: subscriptions bought before 20 August 2026, when plans moved to one-time payments, keep the terms in force when they were bought; the redesigned Pro plan leaves existing Pro accounts, and their live accounts, on the old rules; and the Rapid split rose to 90% on 12 January 2026. But the terms say funded accounts are governed by a Simulated Trader Agreement and its appendices, which take precedence over the terms, and that agreement is not public before purchase; a first payout also needs agreements signed through Riseworks that are not published. And rules that can cost a trader profit are published with no date and without saying which accounts they cover: on Rapid, profit above $10,000 on the day a trader is moved to live is forfeited, and up to $5,000 of simulated profit is held in a reserve until 20 profitable live days.
Fix before issue
Commit in its terms that rule changes never apply to accounts already bought unless they favour the trader: the terms can change at any time, with or without notice.
Make the terms and the refund policy name the same arbitration body: the terms name JAMS, the refund policy the American Arbitration Association.
Bring the live-account FAQ of November 2025 into line with the plan guides, and make the Builder 50K guide agree with itself on when the live drawdown locks.
Not settled by public evidence What the Simulated Trader Agreement and its appendices say. When the Rapid live-transition forfeiture and the reserve were introduced, and whether they reached accounts bought before them: the firm keeps no dated change log, and archived copies were not checked. Whether the rule on short holding times that one reviewer says cut a payout is published anywhere.
A decision can be looked at again only informally. The terms give the firm sole and absolute discretion over whether a rule was broken and what follows, including withholding or forfeiting payouts and ending an account without notice, and the fair-play policy confiscates profits from banned practices; neither they nor any of the help centre’s 13 collections name an appeal or complaints procedure, though nothing declares a decision final. In the 20 most recent one-star Trustpilot reviews, 11 reviewers say they asked support to look again, and one says a decision was upheld after documents were sent; the firm replied publicly to none. Of the 9 that describe an account closed, failed or banned, 6 say a rule or reason was named, sometimes only as a category such as a policy violation or a partner broker’s internal policies, 2 only in part, and 1 says support would not go into any detail. The terms also list acting in a way that may cause the company reputational harm, or conduct that could damage its reputation or goodwill, as violations that allow corrective action, a term broad enough to cover public criticism; we found no case of it being used.
Not settled by public evidence Whether every refusal, closure or cut names the rule and what the trader did, and whether the evidence is kept and shared on request: that needs a sample of notices. Whether support will look again at any disputed decision on request, how long it takes and who decides. Whether the Simulated Trader Agreement, which is not public, provides an appeal or says more about criticism.
The firm says plainly, in its terms and on every page’s footer, that all accounts are simulated, that trades are executed on a demo basis with no real capital, and that live capital is offered only by invitation; it says it is not a broker-dealer, introducing broker, futures commission merchant or money manager, and claims no licence. Trustpilot showed no notice about fake or manipulated reviews on 13 November 2026; its only notice says the company may be associated with high-risk investments. Its careers board describes it as providing capital to traders, a recruiting line that its trader-facing pages qualify. Some figures are undated or disagree: $300 million paid with no date, pass rates for an unstated period, and a footer that calls evaluation fees non-refundable while the refund policy refunds an untraded account within 14 days. Its claim of approvals in milliseconds is counted under payouts.
Fix before issue
Date its total paid and say what period its pass rates cover.
Make the footer agree with the refund policy on when evaluation fees are refunded.
Not settled by public evidence Whether Trustpilot showed a fake-review notice at any time in the last 12 months: no archived copy was checked. Whether the $300 million total and the pass rates hold up. We have not raised any of these with MyFundedFutures.
No alert names MyFundedFutures in IOSCO’s I-SCAN database. One I-SCAN alert, posted by Ukraine’s securities regulator on 23 August 2024, names MyFundedFX, a separate Texas entity and a forex brand that Finance Magnates links to the same chief executive and says has been rebranded SeacrestFunded; Ukraine is on MyFundedFutures’ list of restricted countries, so it is noted, not counted. Traders can raise problems through the live chat the help centre publishes. Where complaints can be seen, most get an answer: of the 20 most recent one-star Trustpilot reviews, most describe support replying, often with a reason the reviewer disputes, and 3 describe support that was slow or reached no resolution. The firm replies publicly to none of its negative Trustpilot reviews, which is not by itself an unanswered complaint.
Fix before issue
Publish a complaints procedure and a time to answer.
Not settled by public evidence Whether most complaints made through live chat get an answer, which only the firm’s records can show. How long answers take. Whether the firm’s model needs CFTC registration, a legal question public sources do not settle.
MyFundedFutures has not seen this view. It is not a review, a certificate, an approval or an endorsement, and what public evidence could not settle is never counted against the firm.
Checked against version 1.1 on , from public sources only
Nothing is not met, and “Who you are dealing with”, “Payouts are paid”, “Rules a trader can rely on”, “Fair enforcement, and a way to appeal” and “Honest claims” are conditional: a certificate shows those conditions, with a dated plan to close them within 90 days.
01Who you are dealing with
Conditional
The terms name the company traders deal with as BBEducation Ltd, a Cayman Islands company, together with affiliated entities they do not name; the site footer and About page call it BBEducation Incorporated, at an address in George Town, Grand Cayman, and add BBFH Pty Ltd for treasury services and Odeonpay ALE S.R.L., trading as Paysagi, as merchant of record. BBFH Pty Ltd is active on Australia’s business register, with an ABN from 24 April 2025. Which company funds and pays traders is unclear: the terms speak of the trading capital of Blueberry, the home page of allocation from Blueberry Funds, and the footer of treasury services facilitated by BBFH Pty Ltd, and funded accounts are governed by a Trader Agreement that is not public. The firm names none of the people who own or run it; only a commercial comparison site names two chief executives.
Fix before issue
Give the operating company one name, with its Cayman company number, in the terms and the footer: the terms say BBEducation Ltd, the footer and About page BBEducation Incorporated.
Not settled by public evidence Whether BBEducation is registered and active, under which of its two names, and who owns 25% or more of it and of BBFH Pty Ltd, and who their directors are: we found no free public search of the Cayman register, OpenCorporates returned a bot check, and Australia’s business register does not show officers or owners. Which company signs the Trader Agreement and pays traders. Where Odeonpay ALE S.R.L. is registered: the footer gives no country or number. The firm would have to share its ownership documents.
No public record shows Blueberry Futures’ payouts: Prop Firm Match says it has not enabled payout tracking, and the firm’s only total, $8M+, covers the whole Blueberry brand. Payouts go to a Rise wallet, from which traders withdraw to a bank or in crypto themselves, or directly in USDT. The stated times contradict each other: the help centre gives 24 to 48 hours to approve and 24 to 48 hours to send to Rise, about 3 to 5 business days in all for crypto and 5 to 7 for banks, but since its update of 18 August 2026 it warns that the transfer to Rise currently takes up to 7 to 14 business days, where an archived copy from July 2026 gave 24 to 48 hours with no warning; the home page promises fast payouts. No time is stated for direct USDT payouts. Of the three one-star Trustpilot reviews read, from February 2026, one describes a payout delayed and one a funded account delayed.
Fix before issue
Give one payout time for each method, counted from the request to money the trader controls, on every page: the help centre gives a standard 3 to 7 business days while warning of up to 7 to 14 business days for one step, and the home page says fast.
Not settled by public evidence Whether a random sample of payouts requested in the last 90 days matches Rise and blockchain records, and how many reached traders within the stated time; and whether the company that pays, which the firm does not name, can cover what it owes. It publishes no accounts.
Each plan’s target, drawdown, contract cap and payout conditions are published before purchase, on the home page and in a help centre whose answers carry dates. But the Trader Agreement funded traders sign, which the terms call the separate agreement that governs funded and live accounts and the only basis on which funded profits are paid, is not public. Over the last 12 months, archived copies show the consistency limits unchanged between March and November 2026, and the live-account milestone cut from 8 payout cycles in July 2026 to 7 by September, a change in traders’ favour. The terms let trading rules change at any time, with or without notice, and do not say that changes spare accounts already bought; the prohibited-behaviours answer, updated on 27 August 2026, sets consent rules for automated trading without saying what changed or which accounts they cover.
Fix before issue
Commit in its terms that rule changes never apply to accounts already bought unless they favour the trader, and give one notice rule: one section of the terms says rules change on reasonable notice, another with or without notice.
Make its pages agree on the live-account milestone (the About page says after 4 payouts, the help centre and terms 7 payout cycles or $28,000), on the $25K Accelerated price ($110.40 on the home page, $129 in the help centre) and on whether the evaluation fee is monthly or one-time.
Not settled by public evidence What the Trader Agreement says, since it is not public. Whether any rule change in the last 12 months reached accounts already bought and cost a trader a payout: the firm keeps no change log, help-centre answers show only their latest date, and the Internet Archive holds no copy of the prohibited-behaviours answer from before its August 2026 update.
The terms let the firm decide in its sole discretion what counts as prohibited conduct and then remove profits, delete a trading day, reset or close an account, ban the trader, or forfeit withdrawals from every other account; they also let it end access for any or no reason. The help centre says a detected gambling-type strategy ends the account at once and that profit from trades opened in a news blackout is deducted, but neither it nor the terms says a refusal or closure will name the rule and what the trader did, and no appeal is published. Neither declares decisions final either: the terms and help centre give live chat and a support email, and the refund policy says support first tries to fix a problem. The only remedy the terms name is individual arbitration, which does not count. No term lets the firm refuse a payout or close an account for public criticism: the terms’ ban on derogatory or defamatory content covers content posted on its own sites. The firm has replied publicly to none of its negative Trustpilot reviews, so no public reply shows how it explains a decision.
Not settled by public evidence Whether refusal and closure notices name the rule and what the trader did, whether the evidence is kept and summarised on request, and whether support will look again at a disputed decision, how quickly and who decides: that needs a sample of notices and complaint outcomes. Whether the Trader Agreement, which is not public, provides an appeal or has a term about public criticism.
The home page, the terms and the footer’s CFTC Rule 4.41 notice say plainly that evaluation and funded accounts are simulated, and the terms say their funds are fictitious; the firm claims no licence, and its terms and footer say it is not registered with the SEC, the CFTC or the NFA, which NFA’s records bear out. But the home page’s section on the pathway to a live funded account promises instant access to capital after the evaluation, with allocation up to $450K from Blueberry Funds, while the help centre says $450,000 is the cap on three simulated funded accounts and the live account offered after 7 payout cycles equals the plan’s maximum drawdown, $1,000 to $4,500. No review platform has withheld the firm’s rating or warned about fake reviews: Trustpilot showed no notice on 13 November 2026.
Fix before issue
Date its figures and say what they count: the home page gives 15K+ active traders and $8M+ total payouts across the brand, with no date or period.
Not settled by public evidence Whether Blueberry Futures corrects the home page within 30 days of our raising it; we have not raised it. Its claim that its payouts are powered by a regulated broker’s infrastructure names no broker or regulator, so it could not be checked against a regulator’s record; the help centre links the brokerage to blueberrymarkets.com, which an IOSCO alert from Malaysia names, noted under standing. Whether Trustpilot showed a notice earlier in the last 12 months: no archived copy of the profile was checked.
No alert names Blueberry Futures, its website or BBEducation in IOSCO’s I-SCAN database, and NFA’s records show no registration or action. One I-SCAN alert, published by Malaysia’s Securities Commission in August 2025, names Blueberry Markets, the broker the firm says is in its brand family, as an unlicensed entity dealing in securities; it does not name this firm, so it is noted, not counted. Traders have a published way to complain: live chat and the support email the terms and help centre give. The firm has replied publicly to none of the three one-star Trustpilot reviews read; an unanswered public review is not by itself an unanswered complaint.
Fix before issue
Publish a complaints procedure and a time to answer.
Not settled by public evidence Whether most complaints sent through live chat or email get an answer, which only the firm’s records can show; two of the three one-star reviews read say support was slow or absent. Regulator warning lists outside I-SCAN, which were not searched one by one.
Blueberry Futures has not seen this view. It is not a review, a certificate, an approval or an endorsement, and what public evidence could not settle is never counted against the firm.
Checked against version 1.1 on , from public sources only
Nothing is not met, and “Who you are dealing with”, “Payouts are paid”, “Rules a trader can rely on”, “Fair enforcement, and a way to appeal” and “Honest claims” are conditional: a certificate shows those conditions, with a dated plan to close them within 90 days.
01Who you are dealing with
Conditional
The terms name TradeDay LLC, an Illinois limited liability company, “and its affiliated entities”, and count among the services those “offered by an applicable affiliate of TradeDay” without naming any affiliate; the agreements for funded accounts, which would say which company funds and pays them, are not public. So which company funds or pays traders is not settled by the terms. The help centre describes TradeDay processing payouts through Riseworks and moving live profits out of the trader’s live account at Tradovate, and the terms call a live account one funded by TradeDay, so nothing public points to another company, but none is ruled out. The US trademark register records TradeDay LLC as an Illinois limited liability company that owns the TradeDay name, registered in September 2025. The co-founders, James Thorpe as chief executive and Steve Miley as chief operating officer, are named on the firm’s About page. Who owns the company is not public.
Not settled by public evidence Whether TradeDay LLC is registered and active in Illinois, and who its managers and members are: the Illinois Secretary of State’s business search returned Access Denied to an automated request and to a browser, and OpenCorporates showed a bot check. Who owns 25% or more. Which affiliates, if any, sell to, fund or pay traders, and what the Funded SIM and Funded Live agreements say about it.
The help centre states a time for Funded Sim payouts: requests received before 5:30 pm CT are processed within 24 hours on business days, after which the trader withdraws through Riseworks. But the Quick Pay payout policy gives the cutoff both as 5:30 pm CT and as 5:30 pm ET, processed by the next business day, and no time is stated for Funded Live payouts, which wait for Tradovate to transfer funds out of the live account before TradeDay authorises payment at Riseworks. On public evidence payouts are paid: 3 of the 20 most recent Trustpilot reviews describe receiving one, one of them within two minutes of approval, and of the 20 most recent one-star reviews only one describes funds withheld, after accounts were disabled following a first payout; the firm replied that refusals follow documented breaches of its banned practices. Funded Sim profit above $10,000 is forfeited at the move to live under a published rule, not withheld, so it is judged under rules and value, not here.
Fix before issue
Make the withdrawal guide agree with the home page and the Quick Pay payout policy on whether a buffer must be cleared before a payout.
Not settled by public evidence Whether a random sample of payouts matches payment records and was paid within the stated time, which needs the firm’s records; no third-party payout tracker could be read, Prop Firm Match refusing our request. How long Riseworks takes to put money in an account the trader controls. Whether TradeDay LLC can cover what it owes: it publishes no accounts.
The numbers for both evaluations are published on the home page and in the help centre, and the July 2026 Fast Pass changes, a 45% consistency rule and lower caps on each payout, apply only to accounts opened on or after 26 July 2026, sparing accounts already bought. But the Funded SIM Account Agreement every funded trader signs, and the separate agreement for live accounts, are not public before purchase. And in the last 12 months a rule that can cost profits or an account was added without a date or a statement of which accounts it covers: the Order Splitting and Microscalping policy, last edited on 3 September 2026 with no effective date, allows resets, profit deductions and suspension for trading that relies mostly on trades held under about 10 seconds, with no numeric threshold; the firm told a Trustpilot reviewer in June 2026 it had been on its website since 19 May. The Quick Pay payout policy also says splits are now worked out per account rather than over lifetime withdrawals, without a date. The terms let the trading rules change “with or without notice” in one section and on reasonable notice in another.
Fix before issue
Make the terms say one thing on notice of rule changes, and commit that changes never apply to accounts already bought unless they favour the trader.
Make the home-page account cards and the help centre agree on how the Quick Pay funded drawdown is calculated.
Not settled by public evidence What the funded-account agreements say. Whether the microscalping policy or the per-account split was applied to accounts bought before them, and whether either has cost a payout: the firm keeps no dated change log, help articles show only their latest edit, and only one archived home page, from November 2025, was read; it promised 80% of profits from day one, rising to 95%, where Quick Pay now starts at 50%.
A decision can be contested only informally. The terms and the help centre set out no way to appeal a closure, a breach or a forfeiture, and a help-centre search for appeal found none; disputes go to arbitration after a 30-day notice period, which does not count. But the terms and help pages do not declare the firm’s decisions final, and its public replies show it looking at disputed decisions again: it offered traders who disputed a breach trade reports with IP and device details, and told a reviewer in September 2026 that a disputed charge was under internal review. The microscalping policy sends severe cases to the Head of Trading to confirm. Reasons are mixed: 3 of the 20 most recent one-star reviews say an account was banned, suspended or failed without a clear reason, and the firm’s reply to one cited account management and trading style, a category. Profits from banned practices are confiscated, and several grounds rest on the firm’s sole discretion. The terms bar user content that is derogatory or injurious to TradeDay; it is defined as content a user submits or posts, and no case of it being used against a critic was found.
Not settled by public evidence Whether every refusal or closure notice names the rule and what the trader did, and whether the evidence is kept and shared on request: that needs a sample of notices. Whether a review on request is open to every trader, who decides it and how fast. Whether the user-content rule reaches posts outside TradeDay’s own sites, and whether the funded-account agreements provide an appeal or a term about public criticism.
The terms define evaluation and Funded Sim accounts as simulated, and the site says plainly that TradeDay LLC is not registered with the SEC or CFTC; NFA’s records show no registration. But the terms open with “Pass our evaluation and you get funded in the live markets from day one”, while a passing trader gets a simulated Funded Sim account that is reviewed for live trading at $10,000 of gross profit on Quick Pay, or moved at the firm’s discretion on Fast Pass: a claim that traders trade real capital which the firm’s own rules contradict. No review platform was found withholding a rating or warning about fake reviews: Trustpilot showed no notice on 13 November 2026. The home page gives two payout totals, $15M+ and over $10 million, both called verified.
Fix before issue
Use one dated payout total on every page.
Make the help centre agree with the home page on subscriptions and the activation fee.
Not settled by public evidence Whether Trustpilot showed a fake-review notice at any time in the last 12 months: archived copies of the profile were not read. Who verified the payout totals, whether the 36% pass rate holds up, and what the Bloomberg, Reuters and CNBC logos on the home page refer to. We have not raised any of these with TradeDay.
No alert names TradeDay in IOSCO’s I-SCAN database, and NFA’s BASIC database holds no record of it; the firm says it is not registered with the SEC or CFTC. Traders have a published way to complain: a support email the home page lists as available 24/7, and a ticket form linked from the footer. Where complaints can be seen, they get an answer: Trustpilot shows the firm replied to 90% of negative reviews, typically within two weeks, and it replied publicly to 18 of the 20 most recent one-star reviews, dated November 2025 to September 2026.
Fix before issue
Publish a complaints procedure with a time to answer.
Not settled by public evidence Whether most complaints made by email and ticket get an answer, which only the firm’s records can show. Whether the firm’s model needs CFTC registration, a legal question public sources do not settle.
TradeDay has not seen this view. It is not a review, a certificate, an approval or an endorsement, and what public evidence could not settle is never counted against the firm.
Checked against version 1.1 on , from public sources only
Nothing is not met, and “Who you are dealing with”, “Payouts are paid”, “Rules a trader can rely on”, “Fair enforcement, and a way to appeal” and “Honest claims” are conditional: a certificate shows those conditions, with a dated plan to close them within 90 days.
01Who you are dealing with
Conditional
Kraken’s terms name the two companies traders deal with: Breakout Trading Group, LLC provides the evaluation, and Payward Oceanic Ltd., a British Virgin Islands company, runs the funded stage and pays; Kraken says it is not a party. Payward Oceanic is active on the LEI register as company 2061297, fully corroborated against the registration authority, and its director signs the agreement. Breakout’s own SEC filing shows a Delaware LLC formed in 2023. No public record names anyone who owns 25% or more of either company today.
Fix before issue
Give Payward Oceanic’s company number, 2061297, in the agreement and on the Kraken Prop pages, which name the company without it.
Not settled by public evidence Who owns 25% or more of Payward Oceanic and of Breakout, and whether Breakout is active on the Delaware register: the BVI register is not free to search, Delaware’s search sits behind a CAPTCHA, the LEI record lists no parent, and Breakout’s only SEC filing, signed on 2 September 2025, still lists its founders’ companies as managing members after Kraken announced the acquisition. The firm would have to share its ownership documents. The claim that traders trade Kraken’s capital is counted under honest claims, not here.
No public record shows Kraken Prop payments: payouts are internal transfers to the trader’s Kraken account, not public blockchain transactions, no tracker counts them, and the firm’s figures, 35,000 wallets funded since 2023 and $4.5 million in global payouts, are undated and do not separate Kraken Prop from Breakout. The help centre states one time, typically under 12 hours and guaranteed within 24. No accounts of Payward Oceanic, the company that pays, were found in our research.
Fix before issue
Make the agreement describe the payouts Kraken pays: its Trading Rules still say USDC on the ERC-20 network, requested through the Breakout Terminal, while the help centre says USD or USDG to the trader’s Kraken account.
Not settled by public evidence Whether a random sample of payouts requested in the last 90 days matches Kraken’s ledger and reached traders within 24 hours; whether money credited to a trader’s Kraken account, which another Kraken company holds, counts as paid under the method or only once withdrawn; and whether Payward Oceanic can cover what it owes. All of that needs the firm’s records and accounts.
The Program Rules, dated 30 September 2026, and the program page set out each plan’s target and loss limits before purchase, and the plans archived on 5 October 2026 match today’s. But the Breakout Evaluation Terms of Service that buyers accept, Kraken’s terms say, are linked from no Kraken Prop page we read and sit behind the checkout login; the funded agreement lets Payward Oceanic amend it and the Trading Rules at any time without prior notice and change drawdown levels in response to market conditions; and the Program Rules show no record of what the 30 September update changed. A commission cut on non-crypto markets was applied to accounts already bought, in traders’ favour.
Fix before issue
Make its pages agree on leverage: the plan cards say up to 5x, the Program Rules 10x on BTC and the index contracts.
Give one list of barred countries: the Program Rules, the help centre and the agreement each give a different one.
Write the funded agreement for Kraken Prop: it names the Breakout Terminal, Breakout’s FAQs and Breakout’s support address.
Commit in the agreement not to apply rule changes to accounts already bought: clause 19 lets changes take effect on notice, and clause 3(d) lets drawdown levels change with market conditions.
Not settled by public evidence Whether the evaluation terms are public before purchase, what the 30 September 2026 update changed, and whether any change in the last 12 months reached accounts already bought and cost a payout, which would mean not met: the Program Rules page has no archived copy and the firm keeps no public change log.
A breach of a loss limit comes with a notice giving the reason, the time and the equity at breach. But other breaches are decided at Payward Oceanic’s sole discretion, and it may end a funded account on confidential criteria it is not obliged to disclose, with splits forfeited. No appeal of a breach or closure is described: only an identity-check rejection can be contested, through support, and Kraken’s general complaints process, answered within 15 business days with escalation to the BVI consumer affairs department, does not mention Kraken Prop. The agreement bars public statements about its terms, not criticism of the firm.
Fix before issue
Name the complaints route in the Program Rules and the agreement, which describe a way to contest only identity checks.
Not settled by public evidence Whether refusals and closures on risk grounds name the rule and the trades in writing, whether a complaint about Kraken Prop is reviewed by someone not involved in the decision and within 15 business days, and whether the ban on public statements about the agreement’s terms has ever been used against a trader: that needs a sample of notices and complaint outcomes.
Kraken’s Kraken Prop pages say plainly that it is an unregulated service and that evaluations are simulated, and the Lite and commodities pages that traders hold no real positions and payouts are based on simulated performance. But the program page and its FAQ say a funded trader trades up to $200,000 of Kraken’s capital and that Kraken covers any trading losses, while Kraken’s terms say every signal in the funded stage is simulated with virtual funds and that Kraken is not a party. The Lite page also shows “100+ Active licenses” beside an unregulated program; those licences belong to other Kraken companies.
Fix before issue
Date its track-record figures and say what they cover: 35,000 wallets funded since 2023 and $4.5 million in global payouts carry no date or period, and do not say whether they include Breakout.
Not settled by public evidence Whether Kraken corrects the capital claims within 30 days of our raising them; we have not raised them. No review platform has withheld Kraken’s rating or warned about its reviews.
No alert names Kraken Prop, Payward Oceanic or Breakout Trading in IOSCO’s I-SCAN database; searches for Kraken and Payward return three warnings about other websites using those names, one marked a clone and one as having no relation to Kraken. Kraken publishes a complaints process with times to acknowledge and answer and an outside body for its BVI companies, Payward Oceanic among them, and it replied publicly to 99% of negative Trustpilot reviews and to all 11 that mention prop.
Not settled by public evidence Regulator lists outside I-SCAN, which we could not search fully, and whether complaints about Kraken Prop sent privately get an answer, which needs the firm’s complaint records. Regulatory actions involving other Kraken companies and services were not researched.
Kraken Prop has not seen this view. It is not a review, a certificate, an approval or an endorsement, and what public evidence could not settle is never counted against the firm.
Checked against version 1.1 on , from public sources only
Nothing is not met, and “Payouts are paid”, “Rules a trader can rely on” and “Fair enforcement, and a way to appeal” are conditional: a certificate shows those conditions, with a dated plan to close them within 90 days.
01Who you are dealing with
Met
The terms, version 17 of 10 November 2026, name the contracting company, Fintokei a.s., ID 09110127, which the Czech register shows registered in Brno since April 2020 and active, and name no other company that sells to or pays traders. Fintokei’s report on related parties for 2025, filed with the register, names its sole owner, Purple Holding a.s., whose board is on the register; the register shows David Varga as Fintokei’s sole director, and the firm names him publicly as its chief executive.
Not settled by public evidence Who owns 25% or more of Purple Holding: its extract lists no shareholder and the beneficial-owner register is not public, so this is what the method’s confidential disclosure would check. The help centre’s footer says Fintokei is also a registered business name of AXSE Brokerage Ltd in Seychelles, which runs its trading platforms and which the Seychelles regulator lists as a securities dealer; the Seychelles company register is not public, and whether AXSE sells to or pays any Fintokei trader is not stated.
Payouts visibly flow: Prop Firm Match tracks over 5,000 Fintokei payouts worth over $12 million, with a median time under a minute and recent payouts listed. The schedule, methods and fees are published, and requests are approved automatically. But the firm’s stated times contradict each other: the program pages say funds are sent within 3 to 5 hours, the payouts page within 24 hours, and the help centre within 1 business day for bank and crypto. Instant payouts land in a Walletory e-wallet that traders open separately.
Fix before issue
Give one payout time for each method on every page, counted from the request to money the trader controls: the program pages say 3 to 5 hours, the payouts page 24 hours, the home page an average of 3 hours 4 minutes and the help centre 1 business day.
Make the terms and the help centre agree on transfer fees: the terms say each party bears its own, the help centre that Fintokei covers fees on fiat payouts.
Not settled by public evidence Whether a random sample of payouts requested in the last 90 days matches bank, Walletory or blockchain records and reached traders within one stated time: the tracker does not say where its records come from. Whether Walletory Pte Ltd is linked to the Walletory s.r.o. that Purple Holding controls, which would make a Walletory balance money in a wallet the group runs. Whether Fintokei a.s. can cover what it owes: its 2024 accounts were not opened and its 2025 accounts are not yet filed.
Each program’s rules are on its page and in a help centre dated October and November 2026, and the 2026 changes to SwiftTrader (15 July) and StartTrader (21 October) were dated and kept off accounts bought before them. But the provider-program terms that govern funded accounts and rewards are emailed only to traders who pass, so a document that binds traders is not public before purchase. And the two-level Consistency Rules in force since 19 August 2026, which cut the reward share by 15 or 30 points, reach a trader’s existing accounts without saying whether accounts bought before that date are covered.
Fix before issue
Make the loss-limit article agree with the program pages: it still gives StartTrader and SwiftTrader a 3% daily and 6% overall limit, which now apply only to older accounts.
Commit in the terms not to apply rule changes to accounts already bought: article IX.8 lets the firm change trading conditions and the parameters for passing at any time without notice.
Not settled by public evidence Whether any change in the last 12 months reached accounts already bought and cost a trader a payout, which would mean not met: we checked no archived copies, and only the firm’s records could show how Consistency Rules were applied. Five of the 20 latest one-star reviews, all by one trader, say the rules tightened after purchase; the firm replies that the rule he cites did not change.
The help centre says every measure is explained by email and restrictions escalate from warnings, and in its public replies the firm usually names a category, such as Consistency Rules or hedging across accounts. But some funded traders were ended under its right to end the cooperation when their trading data no longer suits its framework, with no rule named. Consistency Rules can be reviewed only after 3 to 6 months, at the firm’s discretion, and no formal appeal is published. The terms also forbid any criticism of Fintokei, online reviews included, and a breach of the terms can end contracts and rewards; we found no case of it being used for that.
Not settled by public evidence Whether notices name the rule and what the trader did, whether the evidence is kept and summarised on request, and who decides a complaint: that needs a sample of notices and the firm’s procedure. One reviewer says the firm reported a critical review to Trustpilot as defamatory and Trustpilot restored it; we found no payout or account lost over a review.
The terms, the footer of every page and the program FAQs say plainly that Fintokei is not regulated, is not a broker, takes no deposits and that every account is simulated with virtual money, and no page claims a licence for Fintokei. The only licence in the picture is AXSE Brokerage Ltd’s, which the Seychelles regulator does list. Payout claims are qualified as not typical or not guaranteed. Trustpilot showed Fintokei’s 4.3 rating with no warning on 13 November 2026.
Fix before issue
Fix the counters on the payouts and about pages, which showed $0 for the 2025 average and total payouts when read.
Name the partner broker and its regulator instead of calling it a globally regulated brokerage.
Not settled by public evidence The registration in Japan as a foreign company, number 1800-03-027272, which the firm cites and Japan’s commercial register would show; the tax agency’s record shows a different number and no Japanese address. We did not review the firm’s advertising, or Trustpilot’s notices over the past 12 months.
No alert names Fintokei or AXSE Brokerage in IOSCO’s I-SCAN database, and the Japanese FSA’s list of businesses warned for operating without registration, updated on 10 November 2026, does not name Fintokei, in its largest market. Traders can complain to the support email, and EU consumers can go to the Czech Trade Inspection Authority. The firm replies publicly to 96% of negative Trustpilot reviews, and replied to 19 of the 20 latest one-star ones.
Fix before issue
State a time to answer a complaint: the terms set none.
Not settled by public evidence Regulator lists outside I-SCAN and Japan’s FSA, which we could not search fully, and whether complaints sent privately get an answer, which needs the firm’s complaint records.
Fintokei has not seen this view. It is not a review, a certificate, an approval or an endorsement, and what public evidence could not settle is never counted against the firm.
Checked against version 1.1 on , from public sources only
Nothing is not met, and “Who you are dealing with”, “Payouts are paid”, “Fair enforcement, and a way to appeal”, “Honest claims” and “Regulatory standing and complaints” are conditional: a certificate shows those conditions, with a dated plan to close them within 90 days.
01Who you are dealing with
Conditional
The General Terms name the contracting company, Eightcap International Ltd, company 8427413-1 in Seychelles, and the footer names it as the site’s operator. The Seychelles FSA lists it among securities dealers and names Joel Brian Murphy as a securities dealer accredited with it. But no public record names its owners or directors, the terms say a payout may be paid by the company or an unnamed nominee, so which company pays a trader is unclear, and three different addresses are given for it. The owners of the group’s UK company, Eightcap Group Ltd, are on the UK register, but that register does not reach the Seychelles company.
Fix before issue
Give one registered address for Eightcap International Ltd on every page and policy: the challenges footer says Office 12, 3rd Floor, IMAD Complex, the FSA list IMAD Complex, Office 2, and Eightcap’s broker site the Providence Complex.
Link website terms for the challenges site: the footer’s Website Terms and Conditions link opens Eightcap Global Limited’s terms for www.eightcap.com.
Not settled by public evidence Who owns 25% or more of Eightcap International Ltd and who its directors are, whether it is active on the Seychelles register, which the FSA opens only on written request, and which company sends payouts: the firm would have to share these.
No public record shows the challenges’ payments: TheTrustedProp holds no payout data for the firm, and the firm publishes no total or count, only twelve payout certificates and three client videos it chose. Its stated times are close but not one figure: the Rules say approved payouts are typically processed within 24 to 48 hours of an eligible request, the FAQ within 1 to 2 business days after approval, plus 4 to 5 business days for international bank transfers. One of the 20 latest reviews on Eightcap’s Trustpilot profile describes an approved challenge payout not received after several days.
Fix before issue
Give one payout time on every page, counted from the request to money the trader controls: the Rules say 24 to 48 hours, the FAQ 1 to 2 business days after approval plus the bank’s time.
Not settled by public evidence Whether a random sample of payouts requested in the last 90 days matches bank or blockchain records and reached traders within the stated time, counted to money they control, and whether Eightcap International Ltd can cover what it owes: we found no public accounts for it.
The General Terms and the Rules and Conditions, which bind every trader, are public before purchase, carry version numbers and dates (22 January and 22 October 2026), and set out each program’s limits, prohibited strategies and payout conditions. The changes they record from the last 12 months are dated and applied by purchase date, with older purchases keeping their rules: Two Phase targets for challenges bought from 23 February 2026, the Two Phase profit cap and new daily profit limits from 11 February 2026, and the Two Phase limits from 28 September 2026. We found no change applied to accounts already bought.
Fix before issue
Make the FAQ agree with the Rules on the qualification stage’s minimum trading days (3 or 5), on how the maximum loss is measured and on whether the news ban covers every stage.
Commit in the terms not to apply rule changes to accounts already bought: the Rules let a change be notified as soon as practicable after it takes effect, and the General Terms allow amendment at any time by notice.
Correct the Rules’ references to clauses 3.1 and 21 of the General Terms, which put amendments and leaving in clauses 4 and 22.
Not settled by public evidence Whether any rule changed in the last 12 months without a date or reached accounts already bought: archived copies could not be reached, the firm keeps no public change log, and the One Phase profit cap carries no start date while the Two Phase cap starts on 11 February 2026. Free accounts, which are given rather than sold, carry a lifetime payout limit the firm sets and does not publish; whether it is stated when such an account is granted needs the firm’s records.
The FAQ says the specific reason for a declined payout is sent by email and that breach emails give details of the violation, and the complaints policy lets a trader escalate a decision in writing. But the Rules give the risk team sole and absolute discretion over payouts, and the verification policy lets the firm refuse a payout for unacceptable risk, reputational risk included, without giving reasons. Escalations are reviewed by a member of the compliance team that handled the complaint, with no time limit, and may be declined as without merit. No term we read lets the firm penalise public criticism. One recent reviewer says profits were removed for copy trading without the copied trades being shown.
Not settled by public evidence Whether every refusal, closure or cut names the rule and the trades in writing, whether the evidence is kept and summarised on request, and who decides escalations and how fast: that needs a sample of notices and complaint outcomes.
The footer, the terms and every policy say plainly that the challenges are simulated, that the bankroll is not real money and that they fall outside any regulated service or licence; no page claims the challenges are regulated, and the FAQ says only that they are part of Eightcap, a globally regulated provider. But Trustpilot withholds the rating of Eightcap’s profile, where challenge buyers post their reviews, for a breach of its guidelines, saying it removed a number of fake reviews; the challenges’ own profile has no reviews. And a home-page banner says funds are held securely by a bank and are segregated, audited and insured, on a site where traders hold no funds.
Not settled by public evidence When Trustpilot added its notice, which the profile does not show; and whether the firm corrects the banner within 30 days of our raising it, which we have not done.
IOSCO’s I-SCAN database holds an alert from the Securities Commission Malaysia, published on 31 March 2025, listing Eightcap at its broker page eightcap.com/my as an unregistered or unlicensed entity offering financial products or services, noting unlicensed capital market activities of dealing in securities. Malaysia is on neither of the challenges’ restricted-country lists, so the brand they are sold under is named in a market where they are sold, and we found no explanation from the firm. The four other alerts name eightcapinvest web addresses, not the challenges site. Traders have a published complaints route with set times; none of the 20 latest reviews on Eightcap’s Trustpilot profile shows a public reply, which alone is not an unanswered complaint.
Not settled by public evidence Whether the Malaysian alert concerns the company that runs the challenges (nothing we read shows which Eightcap company runs eightcap.com/my), and how the firm answers it; regulator lists outside I-SCAN, which we could not search fully; and whether complaints sent privately get an answer, which needs the firm’s records.
Eightcap Challenges has not seen this view. It is not a review, a certificate, an approval or an endorsement, and what public evidence could not settle is never counted against the firm.
Checked against version 1.1 on , from public sources only
Nothing is not met, and “Who you are dealing with”, “Payouts are paid”, “Rules a trader can rely on” and “Fair enforcement, and a way to appeal” are conditional: a certificate shows those conditions, with a dated plan to close them within 90 days.
01Who you are dealing with
Conditional
The terms name Funded Futures Family LLC, which they call a California limited liability company, and traders sign a contract with Funded Futures Family, LLC through Rise before their first payout; the firm names its founder and CEO, Manuel Meraz. But which company sells to and pays traders, and which takes the profit share, is not stated plainly: the help centre opens by describing Funded Family One as the prop firm, its payout rules give the 10% share to Funded Family One and the Professional Stage’s 20% to FFONE, the Trustpilot profile carries that name, and a blog post on the firm’s own site of 27 October 2026 says Funded Family One is a separate company from Funded Futures Family. No owner of either is named.
Fix before issue
Make its pages agree on one address, beside its company number: the terms’ contact section gives 32357 Daybrook Terrace, Temecula, while the disclosures, FAQ and About page give 28780 Single Oak Dr, Temecula.
Not settled by public evidence Whether Funded Futures Family LLC is registered and active, where it was formed, and who manages it and owns 25% or more: California’s register turned automated requests away with a bot check, as did OpenCorporates, and we passed neither. Whether Funded Family One is a registered company and what part it plays in the futures program. Whose capital live accounts trade, and through which broker: the Live Stage article names only Rithmic as the infrastructure.
Public on-chain records show payouts being paid: Payout Junction, a tracker the firm’s payout page links to, counts 15,633 payouts worth $32,175,994 sent through Rise and matched to the blockchain from November 2024 to 12 November 2026. But the firm’s stated times contradict each other: the FAQ promises payouts within 24 hours and the home page shows 24 hours or less as its payout time (its payout section says payment usually follows within 24 hours), while the help centre reviews requests on business days, before 5 PM Eastern or within 5 business days if more time is needed, then pays through Rise in 1 to 3 business days by bank, or from the same day to 24 hours in crypto, and a first payout also waits on Rise onboarding and a signed contract. Of the 20 most recent one-star Trustpilot reviews, one says two approved payouts of $1,250 never arrived after a Rise invitation failed, and two describe delays; the firm replied that Rise manages its own onboarding. Denied payouts are judged under fair enforcement, and the firm’s differing payout totals under honest claims.
Fix before issue
Give one payout time on every page, counted from the request to money the trader controls: the FAQ says within 24 hours, the help centre a same-day or 5-business-day review followed by 1 to 3 business days by bank.
Not settled by public evidence Whether a random sample of payouts requested in the last 90 days matches Rise and bank records and reached traders within the stated time: the tracker counts only on-chain Rise payouts and does not time them from the request. Whether the approved payouts one reviewer says never arrived were paid. Whether Funded Futures Family LLC can cover what it owes: it publishes no accounts.
Each plan’s target, drawdown, contract limits, consistency rule and payout caps are published before purchase, in the challenge selector and the help centre, and the year’s announced changes were dated and applied by purchase date: Premier+ consistency and contract limits for accounts bought from 9 September 2026, and the S2F Accelerate consistency step-up, profit target and $500 cap for accounts bought from 22 and 30 October 2026, with earlier accounts keeping their rules. But the contract traders sign with Funded Futures Family, LLC through Rise before their first payout is not public. And the All-or-Nothing Trading and Account Rolling article, which sets an 80%-of-loss-limit threshold and lets Compliance close every account affected by account rolling and deny the affected payouts, pending requests included, and the Prohibited Trading Conduct article show no effective date and do not say which accounts they cover, while the terms let trading rules change without notice.
Fix before issue
Make its pages agree on daily loss limits and the S2F rules: the FAQ says there is no daily loss limit while S2F Payday has a $1,000 hard limit and Choice Daily Pay a two-strike limit, and the general S2F articles give 25% consistency where the Payday article gives 40%.
Make the terms and the refund policy agree: the terms call every fee non-refundable, the help centre refunds an untraded first account within 14 days.
Commit in its terms that rule changes never apply to accounts already bought unless they favour the trader.
Not settled by public evidence Whether the all-or-nothing threshold, or its review across the accounts a trader owns or controls, was introduced in the last 12 months and used to refuse payouts on accounts bought before it, which would mean not met. One recent one-star reviewer says a drawdown rule introduced two weeks earlier was applied to trades three months old; the firm replies that its all-or-nothing rule has been in place since 2024. The help centre shows no dates, the firm keeps no change log, and the Internet Archive could not be reached to compare earlier versions.
A payout held or denied comes with a notice that, by the help centre’s account, names the rule, the affected accounts and the dates or trades, and summarises the finding; the trader can reply within 7 days with evidence, a different reviewer examines the case, and that second decision is final. No deadline is set for the second decision, and no review is described for closures outside a payout review, such as for device sharing, which the prohibited-conduct policy says can come without prior warning. In its public replies to the 20 most recent one-star reviews the firm names a rule or policy in 13, the all-or-nothing rule in 8, but cites no specific trade. No term we read lets the firm refuse a payout or close an account for public criticism; one reply says an account was banned for filing card payment disputes, which the terms forbid for authorised charges.
Not settled by public evidence Whether every notice names the rule and the trades in writing, as the help centre says, and whether second reviews are decided within 15 business days by someone not involved in the first decision: that needs a sample of notices and outcomes. Whether the payout contract signed through Rise, which is not public, has a term on public criticism or its own appeal.
The terms, the site’s disclosures and the FAQ say plainly that evaluation and funded accounts are simulated, that no orders reach the market, that buying an account is a fee and not a deposit, and that the firm is not a broker and is not registered with the CFTC, NFA or SEC; it claims no licence, and NFA’s records show no registration. Trustpilot showed no notice or warning about the firm’s reviews on 13 November 2026. The payout data page’s statement that no eligible payout has been denied since continuous monitoring replaced manual review sits beside a help centre that has reviewers check every request; the denials themselves are judged under fair enforcement, and payout times under payouts. Several figures disagree, which is housekeeping: payout totals from more than $24 million to more than $29 million, and a Trustpilot rating the firm quotes as 4.6 from 2,900 or 3,000 reviews against 4.3 from 4,026 on Trustpilot.
Fix before issue
Publish one dated payout total on every page, and quote its current Trustpilot rating or none.
Make the payout data page agree with the help centre on whether payouts are reviewed by hand.
Not settled by public evidence Whether Trustpilot withheld the firm’s rating or warned about its reviews at any time in the last 12 months: the Internet Archive could not be reached to check earlier copies of the profile. Whether the Professional Stage, which the help centre calls the firm’s live market trading program, trades live capital from the start. We have not raised any of these with Funded Futures Family.
No alert names Funded Futures Family, Funded Family One or its CEO in IOSCO’s I-SCAN database, and NFA’s records show no registration or action. Traders can complain by email, phone and chat, and the terms ask for a support ticket before any card dispute, with at least 15 business days to respond. Where complaints can be seen they get an answer: Trustpilot shows replies to 99% of negative reviews, typically within 24 hours, and the firm replied to all 20 of the most recent one-star reviews.
Fix before issue
Publish a complaints procedure with a time to answer.
Not settled by public evidence Whether most complaints sent privately get an answer, which needs the firm’s records. Regulator warning lists outside I-SCAN and NFA were not searched.
Funded Futures Family has not seen this view. It is not a review, a certificate, an approval or an endorsement, and what public evidence could not settle is never counted against the firm.
Checked against version 1.1 on , from public sources only
Nothing is not met, and “Who you are dealing with”, “Payouts are paid”, “Rules a trader can rely on” and “Fair enforcement, and a way to appeal” are conditional: a certificate shows those conditions, with a dated plan to close them within 90 days.
01Who you are dealing with
Conditional
The terms define the company traders deal with as Funding Perpetuals Holdings, Inc., d/b/a MyFundedPerpetuals, and the legal footer and disclaimer say it owns and operates the site. No other company is named as selling to, funding or paying traders: the terms say payouts come from the company’s own funds, and the FAQ that they are sent through Rise. Delaware’s register shows the corporation, file number 10726540, incorporated on 6 August 2026. No owner or director is named publicly; a paid press release names Granger Davig as chief operating officer.
Fix before issue
Show the company’s Delaware file number and an address on its own pages: the footer and disclaimer give only the state of incorporation.
Not settled by public evidence Who owns 25% or more of Funding Perpetuals Holdings, Inc. and who its directors are: Delaware’s public register does not show them. Whether the company is in good standing: Delaware sells its status for a fee, which we did not buy. The firm says it comes from the team behind My Funded Futures and is backed by it, while its refund policy calls MyFunded Futures, LLC a separate company; whether My Funded Futures or Funding Predicts holds a stake is not public. The firm would have to share its ownership documents.
Public records show payouts being paid: a tracker reading the firm’s Rise account on the Arbitrum blockchain counts $2.63 million across 6,296 payments to 1,326 Rise accounts since 10 September 2026, though the same account can pay affiliates and vendors. But the firm states no time for a payout: every request is reviewed by hand, its blog says there is no promised delivery time, and the FAQ says review and delivery can take longer than the daily request window. The company files no public accounts. Accounts closed around a payout request are judged under fair enforcement.
Fix before issue
Make the blog and FAQ agree on payout details: the blog post of 15 October says a rejected request uses up that day’s allowance and store credit gets a 10% boost, the FAQ that the allowance is given back and the boost is 5%.
Not settled by public evidence Whether a random sample of payouts requested in the last 90 days matches Rise records and reached traders within a stated time, counted from the request; and whether Funding Perpetuals Holdings, Inc., incorporated in August 2026, can cover what it owes, since the terms say payouts come from its own funds and no accounts are public.
Each plan’s target, loss limits and payout rules are published before purchase in the FAQ, and the terms say active evaluations keep the rules in effect when they were activated. But the Funded Trader Customer Agreement, which governs funded accounts and takes precedence over the terms, is signed only after passing and is not among the documents the site publishes. And between the FAQ archived on 6 October 2026 and 13 November, terms changed with no date and no word on which accounts they cover: a $100,000 lifetime payout cap was added where the October FAQ said there was none, counting payouts from accounts already bought and ending new purchases once reached, though active funded accounts keep paying; the store-credit boost fell from 10% to 5%; and the profit target moved from realised balance to equity.
Fix before issue
Commit in the terms that rule changes never apply to funded accounts already bought unless they favour the trader: the terms let any change take effect on continued use, and the commitment they make covers active evaluations only.
Make the terms and refund policy agree on profit earned before a termination: the terms say it will be paid out after audit, the refund policy that payouts may be forfeited.
Update the blog post of 15 October, which still says Select, Prime and Signature have no lifetime payout cap.
Not settled by public evidence What the funded-account agreement says. Whether any change reached a funded account already bought in a way that cost a payout: the firm keeps no change log, and the archive holds copies of the FAQ from 6 to 9 October 2026 only.
A decision can be looked at again only informally: the FAQ tells a trader to review the failure reason and contact support if they believe a result is incorrect, and to contact support about an enforcement decision, but the home page’s legal footer says voided gains, disqualifications and terminations for program abuse are final and not subject to appeal, and no appeal procedure, deadline or reviewer is published. The terms let the firm decide at its own discretion, in reasonable good faith, what counts as prohibited conduct. The refund policy lets it terminate an account immediately for conduct that causes it reputational harm, with payouts liable to be forfeited, wording broad enough to reach public criticism, though we found no case of it being used. In its public replies to one-star reviews, the firm named its rule against multiple accounts and what it found, and called the decision final; one reply, of 31 October 2026, says the case had been fully reviewed before the decision was called final, the one sign found of a decision being looked at again after a trader disputed it.
Not settled by public evidence Whether every refusal, closure or cut names in writing the rule and what the trader did, whether the evidence is kept and shared on request, and who decides when support looks at a decision again, and how fast: that needs a sample of notices. One one-star review says all of a trader’s accounts were closed after a payout request with no trade identified. Whether the funded-account agreement, which is not public, provides an appeal.
The terms, legal footer, disclaimer and FAQ say plainly that every evaluation and funded account is simulated, that orders are never sent to an exchange and that there is no path to a live account, and the disclaimer says the firm is not a broker-dealer, futures commission merchant or investment adviser; it claims no licence. The payout figures on its home page, $250 million paid and 100,000 payouts, are labelled as My Funded Futures’ track record since 2023. Trustpilot showed no warning about fake or manipulated reviews on 13 November 2026; its notice that the company may be associated with high-risk investments is not one.
Fix before issue
Date the My Funded Futures figures on its home page: $250 million paid and 100,000 payouts carry no date, and its press release of 2 October 2026 gave $225 million.
Not settled by public evidence Whether Trustpilot showed a fake-review warning at any time since the profile was claimed in September 2026: no archived copy of it was checked. We have not raised anything with MyFundedPerps.
No alert names MyFundedPerps, myfundedperpetuals or Funding Perpetuals in IOSCO’s I-SCAN database, and no other regulator warning naming the firm was found. Traders can raise a problem through the chat, email address and phone line the FAQ publishes. The firm answers 28% of negative Trustpilot reviews, usually within 24 hours, and replied publicly to 2 of its 12 one-star reviews; an unanswered public review is not by itself an unanswered complaint.
Fix before issue
Publish a complaints procedure and a time to answer.
Not settled by public evidence Whether most complaints sent through chat, email or phone get an answer: only the firm’s records can show it, and one one-star review says email support did not reply. Regulator lists outside I-SCAN were not searched in full.
MyFundedPerps has not seen this view. It is not a review, a certificate, an approval or an endorsement, and what public evidence could not settle is never counted against the firm.
Checked against version 1.1 on , from public sources only
Nothing is not met, and “Payouts are paid”, “Rules a trader can rely on”, “Fair enforcement, and a way to appeal”, “Honest claims” and “Regulatory standing and complaints” are conditional: a certificate shows those conditions, with a dated plan to close them within 90 days.
01Who you are dealing with
Met
The terms name The Trading Pit Challenge GmbH as the company traders contract with, and the footer names the group’s other companies and their roles: The Trading Pit AG as holding company, The Trading Pit Champions GmbH for platform services and The Trading Pit Limited in Cyprus for business and administration services. The three Liechtenstein companies are on the Liechtenstein register, entered in 2022 with no deletion shown and entries as recent as 26 October 2026, and the Cyprus register shows The Trading Pit Limited active, with Illimar Mattus and Daniela Egli as directors. The people in control are named publicly: the imprint names Daniela Egli, Illimar Mattus and Maximilian Dejaco as managing directors, and the firm says it is majority-owned by Pinorena Capital, founded by Illimar Mattus.
Not settled by public evidence Who owns 25% or more of The Trading Pit AG, and through which company: Liechtenstein’s free extract shows no shareholders or managers, the firm gives no legal name or share for Pinorena Capital, and a certified extract was not ordered. Which company pays rewards, which the terms do not say, and what TTP Trading Ltd., named only in an MT5 set-up guide and not on the Cyprus register, does: nothing public says it sells to, funds or pays traders.
No public record shows The Trading Pit’s payments: no tracker or on-chain data was found, and its rewards page gives a total of $18,672,417, an average reward of $1,420 and ten recent rewards with no certificates or transaction links. Its stated times contradict each other: the rewards page heading and the CFD and Stocks help articles promise processing within 24 business hours, the same rewards page shows an average of 56.5 hours, and the Futures Instant articles promise 1 business day; transfers then take the same day for crypto, 1 to 3 business days by SEPA and 5 to 7 by SWIFT. Payouts refused, removed or cut, as described in reviews, are judged under fair enforcement.
Not settled by public evidence Whether a random sample of rewards requested in the last 90 days matches bank or blockchain records and reached traders within the stated time, and whether The Trading Pit Challenge GmbH can cover what it owes: no accounts of the Liechtenstein companies were available to us.
Each program’s rules are published before purchase on the product pages and in help-centre articles, and most changes are dated by purchase date: trailing drawdowns for accounts bought from 29 April 2026, a consistency rule from 6 July 2026, the futures daily pause removed from funded accounts on 14 July 2026 and a lower futures payout threshold from 27 July 2026. The terms say the version in force when an account is bought applies, but let changes to parameters and banned practices reach active accounts for platform integrity, newly found abusive practices or legal reasons. In the last 12 months the firm added limits on energy and metal futures, until geopolitical conditions stabilise, with no date and no word on which accounts they cover; a one-star review describes them applied to an account bought in October 2026. And the terms make compliant trading data a condition of every reward, by criteria that include, but are not limited to, those in the help centre.
Fix before issue
Make the Stocks page and the help centre agree on the Stocks target, maximum drawdown and price.
Give one start date for the profitable-days rule: the CFD Prime rules, the rewards article and the product page give three.
Commit in the terms not to apply rule changes to accounts already bought unless they favour the trader: clause 19.2 allows it for platform integrity or newly identified abusive practices.
Not settled by public evidence Whether any payout was refused under a rule or criterion not published before the account was bought, which would mean not met: several one-star reviews say so, the firm keeps no change log, and only its records could show it.
A trader can ask for a human review of an automated or risk-team decision, such as a breach, answered within 30 days or, with notice, up to 90, and until it ends a forfeiture, refund denial or ban is not final; the help centre says the company’s review team decides, and nothing says the reviewer was not involved in the first decision. Breach reasons are shown in the client area. In the 20 latest one-star reviews, refusals and closures are described as explained by category, such as risk-related concerns or non-independent trading, and one reviewer was offered the payout with either an end to the account or a split cut from 80% to 40%. The terms let the firm withhold rewards not yet determined and end the account if a trader publishes its communications without consent, a term that can reach a review quoting the firm, though we found no case of it being used. They also let the firm set any reward down to 0% at its reasonable discretion.
Not settled by public evidence Whether every refusal, termination or cut names in writing the rule and what the trader did, whether the evidence is kept and shared on request, and who decides a review: that needs a sample of notices and review outcomes.
The terms and footer say plainly that every account is a demo account with virtual funds and that the firm is neither supervised nor regulated by Liechtenstein’s Financial Market Authority, and it claims no licence. But Trustpilot withholds the firm’s rating for a breach of its guidelines and says it has removed a number of fake reviews; the notice was showing on 13 November 2026. And the Stocks page invites traders to stop risking their savings and trade with the firm’s capital, with real liquidity, while the terms say trading is not real and balances fictitious.
Fix before issue
Date its track-record figures: the home page gives $18M+ in rewards and more than 10,000 active accounts a month, and the rewards page a total and averages, with no period.
Not settled by public evidence When Trustpilot’s notice was posted, which it does not date, and whether the firm corrects the Stocks page within 30 days of our raising it; we have not raised it.
Malaysia’s Securities Commission put The Trading Pit and thetradingpit.com on its investor alert list on 23 December 2025 as an unlicensed entity holding out as dealing in securities, and IOSCO’s I-SCAN carries the alert. The firm does not exclude Malaysia: the country is on none of the restricted-country lists it publishes (its CFD list gives only examples) and its website has a Bahasa Melayu version; we found no statement from the firm about the alert. No other I-SCAN alert names the firm. Traders have a published way to complain, by email or the client area with a 30-day target, and the firm replied publicly to 19 of the 20 latest one-star Trustpilot reviews.
Not settled by public evidence Whether the firm is challenging or has explained the Malaysian alert, which we have not asked; whether complaints sent privately get an answer, which needs its records; and regulator lists outside I-SCAN, which we did not search.
The Trading Pit has not seen this view. It is not a review, a certificate, an approval or an endorsement, and what public evidence could not settle is never counted against the firm.
Checked against version 1.1 on , from public sources only
Nothing is not met, and “Payouts are paid”, “Rules a trader can rely on” and “Fair enforcement, and a way to appeal” are conditional: a certificate shows those conditions, with a dated plan to close them within 90 days.
01Who you are dealing with
Met
The terms name Bradbury Capital Ltd, trading as Get Funded Now, company 17102934 in Exeter, as the company traders contract with, and name no other company that sells to, funds or pays traders: payouts are paid by the firm through Rise, a payments platform. The UK register shows the company active since 19 March 2026, with Samuel Philip Bradbury as its only director and its only person with significant control, holding 75% or more. Trade press names him publicly as the buyer and controlling owner of the firm.
Not settled by public evidence Who answers for accounts bought before August 2026 from the previous operator, TIGOGI FZCO in Dubai: Finance Magnates reports that Bradbury Capital took on existing accounts and customer obligations, but the terms do not say so, and no public register of the Dubai company was reached. The firm’s own pages name no person in control.
Payouts are due 14 calendar days after the first trade on a funded account and every 14 days after, or 7 with an add-on, paid through Rise by bank transfer, wire or crypto. The firm states no time for any method: the FAQ says processing depends on verification, the payment method and the provider. No public record shows payments: no tracker counts them, and the firm publishes no total or count. The new owner told trade press that no payouts were overdue when he bought the business; no figures were given. Bradbury Capital, incorporated in March 2026, has filed no accounts. Of the 20 latest one-star Trustpilot reviews, two describe payouts refused over trading rules, judged under fair enforcement, and one a payment through Rise the trader says never arrived, which the firm says Rise confirmed paying.
Not settled by public evidence Whether a random sample of payouts requested in the last 90 days matches Rise, bank or blockchain records, and how fast they reached traders’ own accounts; and whether Bradbury Capital can cover the payouts it owes, since its first accounts are not due until December 2027.
Each program’s rules are published before purchase on its program page, in a rules handbook and in terms both dated 13 September 2026, and the terms say later website or advertising changes will not rewrite an existing purchase’s core commercial terms, except where law, sanctions, security or fraud prevention require. But the terms put checkout terms and the dashboard ahead of the handbook, and the handbook tells traders to confirm in the dashboard, which they see only after buying, the inactivity rule, which can end an account, and the daily reset time. The FAQ says a stop loss is mandatory on some accounts, and that a trade without one may be acted on, without saying which accounts. In the last 12 months the operator changed, and the refund policy, terms and handbook were rewritten in August and September 2026.
Fix before issue
Make the challenges page agree with the 2 Step page on the 2 Step’s entry price: the first says from $20, the second $22.
Not settled by public evidence Whether any rule change in the last 12 months reached accounts already bought or cost a trader a payout: the firm keeps no change log, and archived copies of its pages would not open. A one-star review of April 2026 says a passed 1 Step was refused under an unwritten consistency rule; the new management replied that all its rules are now on its website.
The terms set out the grounds for refusing a payout or ending an account, a breach or prohibited conduct the firm reasonably determines, and in public replies of 2025 the firm named the rule and the trades, such as copying between accounts or 89 trades in seconds. But no appeal is published. The FAQ says support cannot reverse a breach, though GFN can investigate genuine platform incidents; the terms ask traders to try to settle a dispute through support before going to court, name a support email for complaints, and say the firm may ask for evidence before a final decision. One reviewer says an appeal against an inactivity closure was turned down, and in November 2026 the new management offered traders closed for inactivity a free retake. No term we read lets the firm act against a trader for public criticism.
Not settled by public evidence Whether every refusal or closure notice names the rule and what the trader did, whether the evidence is kept and shared on request, and who looks again at a disputed decision and how fast: that needs a sample of notices and complaint outcomes.
The terms, FAQ, program pages and the firm’s fact file say plainly that every account is simulated, that traders deposit no capital and that GFN is not a broker, financial institution or regulated, and the firm claims no licence. Trustpilot showed no notice about fake or manipulated reviews on 13 November 2026, noting only that the firm has not invited reviews recently. The FAQ’s statement that futures can already be traded is housekeeping.
Fix before issue
Make the FAQ agree with the futures page: the FAQ says futures can be traded now, while checkout opens on 15 November 2026.
Update its Trustpilot company details, which still give the UAE as its location.
Not settled by public evidence Whether Trustpilot showed a notice about the firm’s reviews at any time in the last 12 months: archived copies would not open. A one-star review of November 2024, outside that period, says the profile once carried a note about unsupported invitation methods. Under the previous operator, more than 12 months ago, the firm’s replies claimed a 100% payout record and, separately, over 99% of payouts processed without issue. We have not raised anything with Get Funded Now.
By the researcher’s reading, no alert names Get Funded Now, its website, Bradbury Capital or TIGOGI in IOSCO’s I-SCAN database (not re-opened at fact-check), and no other regulator warning naming the firm was found. Traders can complain by email or live chat, and the firm aims to answer emails within 24 hours on business days. Trustpilot says it has replied to 66% of negative reviews, typically after more than a month; it replied to 9 of the 20 latest one-star reviews, four of them in November 2026.
Fix before issue
Publish a complaints procedure with a time to answer a complaint.
Not settled by public evidence Whether most complaints sent to support get an answer, which needs the firm’s records; and regulator lists outside I-SCAN, which we did not search one by one.
Get Funded Now has not seen this view. It is not a review, a certificate, an approval or an endorsement, and what public evidence could not settle is never counted against the firm.
Checked against version 1.1 on , from public sources only
Nothing is not met, and “Who you are dealing with”, “Payouts are paid”, “Rules a trader can rely on”, “Fair enforcement, and a way to appeal” and “Honest claims” are conditional: a certificate shows those conditions, with a dated plan to close them within 90 days.
01Who you are dealing with
Conditional
The terms say a trader’s agreement is with TGN Media Ltd, a UK company the register shows active since January 2024, whose only director and owner of 75% or more is Archie Berry Instance Cade, named publicly by trade press as the founder. But the footer and help centre say the programs are provided by TTT Markets Ltd, a Saint Lucia company, and call TGN Media only its payment and marketing agent, so which company contracts with and pays a trader is unclear. Saint Lucia’s free registry lists TTT Markets Ltd. as an international business company by name only.
Not settled by public evidence Whether TTT Markets Ltd is active, and who owns 25% or more of it and directs it: Saint Lucia’s registry shows its number, status, directors and owners only through a paid search, and the firm names none. The firm would have to share its ownership documents and say which company sells the programs and pays traders.
No public record shows TTT Markets’ payments: TheTrustedProp has no blockchain data for it, and the firm publishes only an undated total of more than $2.5 million. Its stated times contradict each other: the home page promises payouts in around one hour, while the help centre says requests made before Monday 10pm GMT are generally reviewed by hand on Wednesday and then take 1 to 2 business days to arrive. Of the 14 latest one-star Trustpilot reviewers, 8 describe a payout refused, cut or left unanswered; the firm disputes several, saying in two cases that it had paid an earlier payout and in one that no request was made.
Fix before issue
Give one payout time on every page, counted from the request to money the trader controls: the home page says around one hour, the help centre a weekly review and 1 to 2 business days more.
Not settled by public evidence Whether a random sample of payouts requested in the last 90 days matches bank or blockchain records and was paid within a stated time; and whether the company that pays can cover what it owes: the footer calls TGN Media Ltd the payment agent, its micro-company accounts were not opened, and no accounts for TTT Markets Ltd were found.
Each program’s targets and loss limits are in the home page’s pricing table before purchase, and the terms are public. But none of the help-centre answers we read is dated and the firm keeps no public change log, so no rule that can cost an account or a payout says when it was added or which accounts it covers: among them the 1-Step consistency rule, the power to cut profit for inconsistent trading, and a weekend-holding ban that differs by program. The firm’s replies to closed traders cite a trading agreement that is not published. Against the home page archived in November 2025, the 1-Step’s prices and loss limits are unchanged and the Lite and Pro programs are new.
Fix before issue
Make the help centre’s examples match its rules: the 1-Step consistency example contradicts its thresholds, and the Instant Funding split example pays 80% where the cap is 70%.
Commit in the terms not to apply rule changes to accounts already bought: the terms let changes take effect as soon as they are posted.
Not settled by public evidence Whether any rule change in the last 12 months reached accounts already bought and cost a trader a payout, which would mean not met: only the firm’s records could show it. What the trading agreement the firm cites says, and whether traders accept it before purchase.
The terms forbid traders from publishing any online review, comment or public statement about the firm, and let it close the trading account, ban the trader and take legal action if they do; we found no case of it being used. That clause alone sets out written notice, 7 days to reply and an appeal within 14 days heard by staff not involved. For other decisions no appeal is published: the Instant Lite breach answer records the reason and says nothing about contesting it, and prohibited trading may bring payout cancellation or profit removal with no decider named. A decision can be looked at again informally: the firm’s public replies offer to review an account again through support. Some replies name the rule, such as high-frequency trading or a breach after the payout request.
Not settled by public evidence Whether every refusal, closure or cut names the rule and what the trader did, whether the evidence is kept and shared on request, and whether a review is decided within 15 business days by someone not involved: that needs a sample of notices and outcomes. Whether the review clause has ever been used against a trader.
The terms and help centre say plainly that evaluation accounts are simulated and that payouts are commissions from simulated trading, and no page claims a licence. But the footer says TTT Markets Ltd provides brokerage services, and the founder announced a CFD brokerage in January 2026 that Finance Magnates said would reportedly run under the company’s international licensing framework; no regulator or licence is named, none was found on the FCA register, and Saint Lucia’s registry lists the company by name only. Beside every price the pricing table shows an “Avg. Reward” that the page’s own code works out as a fixed 5.72% of the account size, with no source or period stated. Trustpilot showed no warning about the firm’s reviews.
Fix before issue
Date and reconcile its figures: the home page gives $2.5 million paid and 20,000 traders with no date, and promises 24/7 support where the footer says 24/5.
Not settled by public evidence Whether TTT Markets Ltd holds a licence for brokerage anywhere, and whether the firm explains how the average-reward figure is derived. We have raised neither with the firm. Whether Trustpilot showed a fake-review notice at any time in the last 12 months: only today’s profile was read.
No alert names TTT Markets, its website or TGN Media in IOSCO’s I-SCAN database, and the FCA register lists neither name. Traders can complain by email, WhatsApp or Discord, which the site publishes. The firm replies publicly to 78% of negative Trustpilot reviews, and to 12 of the 14 latest one-star reviewers; the other two posted in the last week.
Fix before issue
State a time to answer a complaint: no page gives one.
Not settled by public evidence Regulator lists outside I-SCAN and the FCA register, which we did not search, and whether complaints sent by email get an answer: several reviewers say emails went unanswered for weeks, which only the firm’s records can settle.
TTT Markets has not seen this view. It is not a review, a certificate, an approval or an endorsement, and what public evidence could not settle is never counted against the firm.
Checked against version 1.1 on , from public sources only
Nothing is not met, and “Who you are dealing with”, “Payouts are paid”, “Rules a trader can rely on”, “Fair enforcement, and a way to appeal” and “Honest claims” are conditional: a certificate shows those conditions, with a dated plan to close them within 90 days.
01Who you are dealing with
Conditional
The footer says the website belongs exclusively to Hola Prime Limited, Hong Kong, and the terms name Hola Prime Limited and put contracts under Hong Kong law and courts, but give no company number or address. The footer also names HOLAPRIME LIMITED in Cyprus, active on the Cyprus register since December 2023 with two directors on record, Hola Prime Ltd in Mauritius, on the FSC register as an investment dealer, for MT5 services, and GT Tech LLC for Match-Trader services. No page says which company takes a trader’s fee or pays rewards. The chief executive, Somesh Kapuria, is named publicly, and the UK register showed him owning 75% or more of a UK company that was struck off in July 2026.
Fix before issue
Give Hola Prime Limited’s Hong Kong company number and registered address in the terms.
Not settled by public evidence Whether Hola Prime Limited in Hong Kong is registered and active, and who owns 25% or more of it: Hong Kong’s register was not searched, as its online search requires accepting its terms of use, and the firm would have to share its ownership documents. Which company contracts with and pays traders, and whether GT Tech LLC does either; it was not checked on Florida’s register.
Public records show payouts flowing: Payout Junction, a tracker of public blockchain records that the firm links to, counts 6,212 on-chain payouts worth $10.39 million from October 2024 to 12 November 2026, and the firm publishes a year of approval times it says a Big Four firm reviewed under agreed procedures. But its stated times contradict each other: the 1-Hour Payouts page guarantees payment under 60 minutes every single time, while the payout policy puts an account review of up to 24 business hours before a request can be made and processes on business days only, and the report times approval, not money reaching the trader. No accounts of the paying company were found.
Fix before issue
Show the 2.5% payout fee on the forex trading rules page, which lists the payout methods without it, as the futures rules and the payout policy do.
Not settled by public evidence Whether a random sample of payouts requested in the last 90 days matches bank, Rise or blockchain records and reached traders within a stated time counted from the request; whether bank payouts, which no tracker covers, were paid; and whether the paying company can cover what it owes. The firm says it keeps a separate payout account and a 30% to 40% cushion; that is its statement, not a record.
Each plan’s rules are published before purchase on the forex and futures trading rules pages, with worked examples, and the terms restate the figures. The September 2026 copy-trading change applies only to accounts bought from 15 September 2026. But the 2% risk-per-trade rule with a mandatory stop-loss, which ends an account when broken, carries no date on any firm page: the firm dated it to 7 April 2026 only in a reply to a reviewer. The Prime Consistency Program, also undated, moves accounts a trader already holds onto stricter limits with their profits removed, and the terms make rule changes effective as soon as they are posted, for every account.
Fix before issue
Make its pages agree on the Fly rules, news trading on the futures Direct Account and which accounts get the fee refund.
Commit in its terms not to apply rule changes to accounts already bought.
Not settled by public evidence Whether the 2% rule, the Prime Consistency Program or any other change in the last 12 months reached accounts bought before it and cost a trader a payout, which would mean not met: the firm keeps no change log, and the archived copy of January 2026 did not capture the rule tabs.
In its public replies to closures and refused payouts the firm names the rule and often the trade, such as the 2% risk rule on a named EURUSD trade, tick scalping or device access patterns. But no appeal is published: the terms point only to the contact email, and the Prime Consistency Program, which removes profits and can halve the split on the risk team’s holistic judgement, offers only a review after 90 days at the firm’s sole discretion. Reviewers describe both an appeal that restored a breached account and appeals refused with the decision called final. The terms also let the firm suspend or close accounts and withhold benefits for statements that may reasonably be regarded as disparaging, and bar traders from publishing support correspondence, though we found no case of an account closed under them.
Not settled by public evidence Whether every refusal, closure or cut names the rule and what the trader did in writing, whether the evidence, such as the device identifiers traders say they were refused, is kept and summarised on request, and whether any review is decided within 15 business days by someone not involved in the first decision. One reviewer says the firm offered 40% of a held payout if he removed his review; the firm says the case is under review, and only its records could settle it. Two other reviewers say a payout was withheld after they declined to give a positive review; the firm denies any link, and these are reviewers’ accounts, not settled cases.
The terms, footer and help centre say the accounts are simulated and that Hola Prime does not act as a broker, and the FSC register lists a dealer licence for Hola Prime Ltd, though no page says that company is the regulated broker its pages mention. But other pages say otherwise on simulation: the 1-Step Fly page says funded trades can reach the real market with real market exposure, the footer says a Sim. Funded account may be live or copied, and the futures Direct page speaks of trading real-size capital. The site also promises zero payout denials and guaranteed payouts while its terms let the firm forfeit accrued payouts. No review platform has withheld its rating or warned about its reviews.
Fix before issue
Give one set of dated pass rates: the transparency report says 22.53% to 26.66% by forex plan, the footer 25.07% for forex, and the plan cards 31.57% to 32.19%.
Date its headline figures, such as $10M+ paid and 50K+ traders, which appear without a date.
Not settled by public evidence Whether Hola Prime corrects these within 30 days of our raising them; we have not raised them. Whether Hola Prime Markets, which the help centre calls its regulated in-house brokerage, is the company the FSC licensed, since the register shows Hola Prime Ltd.
No alert names Hola Prime or holaprime in IOSCO’s I-SCAN database, and the FSC register shows no annotation on Hola Prime Ltd’s licence. Traders can complain through 24/7 chat, email, phone and a contact form the firm says it answers within 24 hours, and the firm replied publicly to 99% of negative Trustpilot reviews and to all 20 of the latest one-star ones.
Fix before issue
Name a complaints route and a time to resolve a complaint, not only to reply to it.
Not settled by public evidence Regulator lists outside I-SCAN, which we could not search fully, and whether complaints sent privately get an answer, which needs the firm’s records. The Comoros brokerage licence an affiliate was reported to hold in 2024 was not checked.
Hola Prime has not seen this view. It is not a review, a certificate, an approval or an endorsement, and what public evidence could not settle is never counted against the firm.
Checked against version 1.1 on , from public sources only
Nothing is not met, and “Who you are dealing with”, “Payouts are paid”, “Fair enforcement, and a way to appeal” and “Honest claims” are conditional: a certificate shows those conditions, with a dated plan to close them within 90 days.
01Who you are dealing with
Conditional
The terms name the contracting party as FundedHive DAC, a Decentralized Autonomous Corporation they also call a smart-contract-based corporation, represented by TradingHive Technologies Ltd, DIFC Company Licence No. CL9878. No register record of FundedHive DAC was found, so the party a trader contracts with is not shown to be a registered company. Trades from funded accounts reach the market only if TradingHive Global Brokerage Ltd, a St. Lucia company, chooses to execute them with its own funds, and the terms say no TradingHive company pays traders: payouts are claimed from a smart contract. So which registered company contracts with, funds and pays traders is unclear. The footer also names TradingHive Inc. in New York and AcademyHive Ltd in London. Only AcademyHive Ltd could be checked: the UK register shows it active since July 2025, with the chief executive, Thomas Heinfart, as director and owner of 75% or more. He is named publicly as the person in charge.
Fix before issue
Give one address for TradingHive Technologies Ltd: the footer says the Innovation One building and the terms the FintechHive Building, Innovation Hub.
Not settled by public evidence Whether TradingHive Technologies Ltd is registered and active under CL9878, and who its directors and owners of 25% or more are: the DIFC public register loads its results by script, which our tools could not run. Where and whether TradingHive Inc. and TradingHive Global Brokerage Ltd are registered, and who owns them: no New York or St. Lucia record was found. The firm would have to share its ownership documents; we have not asked.
Payouts visibly flow in public records: Payout Junction counts 5,994 USDC payouts worth $2,518,396 from August 2025 to 13 November 2026, at most $1,600 each, from what it calls the firm’s payout contract. The firm states one time: payouts are sent within 60 seconds of a request, with no team approval, by smart contract. The terms set what can be paid: only positive A-Book profit, after fees owed and A-Book losses are deducted, at least $50 and at most $1,000 a day per wallet address on Classic and Pay From Profits accounts or $2,000 on Instant Growth. But no current page gives the payout contract’s address, the terms say USDC on Ethereum while the tracker reads Arbitrum, and TheTrustedProp says it has no blockchain data for the firm, so the tracker’s attribution cannot be checked. Payouts traders say were blocked or cut by these deductions are judged under fair enforcement.
Fix before issue
Say on its payout pages which network payouts are paid on: the terms say Ethereum ERC20, while the tracker reads them on Arbitrum.
Not settled by public evidence Whether a random sample of payouts requested in the last 90 days matches the blockchain records, and how many reached traders’ wallets within 60 seconds of the request; and whether the companies behind the smart contract can cover what it owes: Payout Junction says reserves are only partly on-chain, and no accounts of any company behind the firm could be read.
We read the firm’s documents in Internet Archive copies, its live site refusing our requests. The terms, linked from every page, are public before purchase, carry effective dates (15 September 2025, then 5 January 2026), and set out each program’s limits in figures in Annexes 1 and 2, with the A-Book and B-Book mechanics in Annex 3; the program pages give the same limits. Clause 2.8, in both versions, says a change to fees or parameters does not affect services bought before it is notified. The January 2026 version added the daily payout caps and the cross-account deductions for A-Book losses and unpaid fees, under its effective date. We found no change in the last 12 months that was undated or applied to accounts already bought. None of the 20 latest one-star Trustpilot reviews describes a rule changed after purchase; one says the trader was asked to pay up front after expecting to pay from profits, which the published risk groups allow.
Fix before issue
Make its pages agree on weekend holding, copy trading and the Classic second-phase target: clause 7.2.3 of the terms forbids weekend holding on every account while the annexes and home page allow it in challenges, and the funding models page shows 8% where the terms and home page give 6%.
Commit in its terms not to apply modified terms to accounts already bought: clause 9.2.1 (f) lets it end an account whose holder does not accept modified terms, and Annex 4 can change at any time on publication.
Not settled by public evidence Whether the January 2026 payout caps and cross-account deductions reached accounts bought before 5 January 2026, which only the firm’s records could show, and whether any rule changed between captures without a date: the archive holds copies only every few weeks and the firm keeps no change log. Whether the Classic second-phase target moved from 6% to 8%, as the November 2026 funding models page shows, or that page is in error. Whether onboarding as a funded trader involves a further agreement that is not public.
The terms give a review process: a trader raises a dispute with customer services within 7 calendar days, then may escalate it in writing to the chief executive under a complaints policy we did not find published, then to LCIA arbitration; no stage has a deadline for a decision, and the chief executive’s independence from the first decision is not stated. The program pages call results final and say automation leaves no room for disputes. In public replies to disputed closures the firm usually names the rule and the trade, such as one trade losing 3.14% against a 3.0% cap, and in one case support refunded part of a slippage loss. The terms let the firm end an account, void trades and withhold profit for defamatory statements or harmful content about FundedHive or for disclosing private correspondence, and reserve legal action over any complaint posted publicly; we found no case of either being used. They also let it void every trade in a Black Swan Event it declares, which can be disputed through the same review. Deductions of A-Book losses and fees from payouts follow published rules.
Not settled by public evidence Whether every refusal, closure or cut names the rule and what the trader did in writing, whether the evidence is kept and shared on request, and how escalations to the chief executive are decided and how fast: that needs a sample of notices and outcomes, and the complaints policy the terms refer to. Whether the criticism clauses or the Black Swan power have ever been used.
Trustpilot withholds FundedHive’s rating for a breach of its guidelines and says it has removed a number of fake reviews, as the page showed when read on 13 November 2026; the firm’s text on that profile, now displayed as Under Competitor Attack, blames a coordinated competitor attack. The firm’s pages also disagree on simulated or live: the website disclaimer says all trading is simulated and that it offers no live trading accounts, while the home page promises access to real capital, the AADS page and the terms define the A-Book as real market execution with the firm’s live capital, and the terms themselves leave execution to an affiliate’s discretion. An April 2026 blog post says its licensed brokerage mirrors winning strategies with real capital, naming no regulator, and no regulator record was found for any group company.
Not settled by public evidence When Trustpilot’s notice was placed, which the profile does not show. Which licence, if any, TradingHive Global Brokerage Ltd holds: St. Lucia’s records were not reached and the DFSA register shows a bot check. What the cTrader listing’s $1,000 payout guarantee covers. We have not raised any of these with FundedHive; if the licence claim stayed up after we did and no regulator confirmed it, this requirement would be not met.
No warning names FundedHive, Funded Hive, TradingHive or AcademyHive in IOSCO’s I-SCAN database, read on 13 November 2026; a search for Trading Hive returns only an FCA warning for HIVE-TRADE GLOBAL TRADING FIRM and a 2024 FINMA warning for a Trading Hive Ltd with no website or address tying it to this firm, which are noted, not counted. Traders have a published way to complain: email, a 24/7 support desk on Discord by ticket, and the terms’ review process escalating to the chief executive. The firm stopped replying publicly to one-star Trustpilot reviews after April 2026, answering 4 of the latest 20 and none of the 16 posted since 19 April; an unanswered public review is not by itself an unanswered complaint, and two of the 20 say support did not answer them.
Fix before issue
Publish a time to answer at each stage of a complaint, and the complaints policy the terms refer to.
Not settled by public evidence Regulator warning lists outside I-SCAN, which we did not search, the DFSA’s own register among them, behind a bot check. Whether most complaints sent by email, Discord or the review process get an answer, which needs the firm’s records.
FundedHive has not seen this view. It is not a review, a certificate, an approval or an endorsement, and what public evidence could not settle is never counted against the firm.
Checked against version 1.1 on , from public sources only
Nothing is not met, and “Who you are dealing with”, “Payouts are paid”, “Rules a trader can rely on”, “Fair enforcement, and a way to appeal” and “Honest claims” are conditional: a certificate shows those conditions, with a dated plan to close them within 90 days.
01Who you are dealing with
Conditional
The terms say the service is offered by WSFmarkets Ltd, which the footer places in Saint Lucia under number 2025-00117. Saint Lucia’s registry lists WSFmarkets Ltd. (IBC) by name, but its free search shows no number, date or status, and an IBC’s shareholders and directors are confidential by law. The footer also says the accounts are offered under WSF Technology FZCO in Dubai, licence 47001, for which no public register was found, and that RENATICA LTD in Cyprus handles payment operations; the Cyprus register shows RENATICA LTD, HE 480440, registered. Which company pays traders, and how the Saint Lucia and Dubai companies relate, is not stated. The firm names its co-founders, Albert Suriol and Iñaki Martínez, and in October 2025 named Martínez chief executive. The operator named on the site has changed from an Andorran company in 2024 to the Dubai company and, by May 2025, the Saint Lucia one.
Fix before issue
Give one company number on every page: the footer says 2025-00117 and the legal notice 2025-001173.
Name its own website and email domain in the terms and legal notice, which refer throughout to wsfmarkets.com.
Not settled by public evidence Whether WSFmarkets Ltd is active and who its directors are, which needs a paid Saint Lucia search or the firm’s documents; whether WSF Technology FZCO is registered and active, since Dubai Silicon Oasis has no free register; RENATICA LTD’s directors and owners, whose details page could not be opened without a browser; which company pays traders; and who owns 25% or more of each company. The firm would have to share its ownership documents.
No public record shows Wall Street Funded’s payments: PropFirmMap’s page for it gives no record of payouts and marks payout proof as not documented, no on-chain count was found, and the firm publishes no total with a period, no count and no accounts. Its stated times point different ways: the home page promises fast and guaranteed payouts, processed within an estimated 48 hours of the request, and shows an average payout time of 2 hours, while the FAQ says payouts are processed only on weekdays from 10:00 to 15:00 CET and that a crypto payout under $500 waits for a form the trader completes; payouts above $500 go through Rise. Nine of the 20 most recent one-star Trustpilot reviews describe payouts refused or cancelled; those disputes concern decisions the firm says rest on its rules, so they are judged under fair enforcement.
Fix before issue
Give one payout time on every page, counted from the request to money the trader controls: the home page says an estimated 48 hours and a 2-hour average, the FAQ only a weekday processing window.
Not settled by public evidence Whether a random sample of payouts requested in the last 90 days matches blockchain or Rise records, and how many reached traders within the stated time counted to money they control; which company pays; and whether it can cover what it owes. That needs the firm’s records.
Each program’s rules are published before purchase, in a public FAQ and on the program pages, and the terms are public. But the contract a trader must sign to activate an Instant or funded account is sent only with the credentials, after purchase. And in the last 12 months a rule that can cost an account changed without a date: in October 2025 the Instant trailing drawdown stopped at the starting balance once the account was up 6% on Standard or 5% on Pro, and the FAQ now says it keeps rising and never locks, without saying which accounts the change covers. Clause 8.4 of the terms, on what the firm tells a trader after a closure, is not in the copy archived on 15 July 2026 and is in the copy archived on 7 October 2026, and the terms carry no version date. The move of the daily reset to 17:00 New York time was dated, from 10 April 2026.
Fix before issue
Make its pages agree on PRIME’s drawdown, static on the home page and trailing in the FAQ, on PRIME’s leverage, on Power’s $5K fee, on copy trading between a trader’s own accounts, and on what a first risk breach costs in a funded account.
Commit in its terms not to apply rule changes to accounts already bought: the terms let changes take effect from the date communicated for users who keep using the service.
Not settled by public evidence Whether the Instant drawdown change reached accounts bought before it and cost a trader a payout, which would mean not met, and what the funded account contract says: the firm keeps no public change log, and only its records or the contract could show it.
The terms let the firm suspend an account at once and without notice for a prohibited practice, with no profit share or refund, and cancel any trader’s participation for any reason at its sole and absolute discretion; clause 8.4 says it may tell the trader only the contractual provision or general reason and need not share the evidence it relied on. The FAQ says a first missed stop-loss or risk breach in a funded account cancels the payout and the account. No appeal or complaints procedure is published; a decision can be looked at again only informally, as the firm’s public replies invite reviewers to send account details and say the risk team emailed details. Of the 20 most recent one-star Trustpilot reviews, 9 describe payouts refused and 13 accounts closed, several saying no specific rule was given; the firm replied to 16, mostly saying its rules are applied consistently, and none of the replies names both the rule and the trades. No term names public criticism as a ground to act against a trader, though clause 8.1 binds traders to keep their communications with the firm confidential.
Not settled by public evidence Whether every refusal, closure or cut names the rule and what the trader did in writing, whether the evidence is kept and summarised on request, and whether any second look is decided within 15 business days by someone not involved in the first decision: that needs a sample of notices and complaint outcomes.
The terms, footer and FAQ say plainly that every account is a demo account with no real capital, that the firm is not a broker and is not a regulated entity, and no page claims a licence. But the home page FAQ says an Instant account trades real money from day one, the terms speak of trading for real profit from accounts connected to capital, and the FAQ names WSF as the broker on MetaTrader 5, cTrader and Match-Trader. The home page promises fast and guaranteed payouts with a 48-hour payment guarantee, defined as processing within an estimated 48 hours, without saying what is guaranteed, while the terms let the firm cancel a trader’s participation at its discretion. And on the PRIME page a script works out the count of accounts left from the clock, in straight lines between fixed points written into the code, from 1,000 on 26 October 2026 to none on 28 October, and a second script sets the number left at none while the buy button is kept active. Trustpilot shows no notice about fake reviews.
Fix before issue
Date its track-record figures and give their basis: over 20 million paid, a 2-hour average payout time, over 100,000 active traders beside a community of 75,000, and an average withdrawal for each size that is the same for every program.
Not settled by public evidence Whether Wall Street Funded corrects these within 30 days of our raising them; we have not raised them. If the real-money and broker statements stay up after that, the method rates this requirement not met.
No alert for WSFunded appears in IOSCO’s I-SCAN database of regulators’ warnings, and no other regulator warning naming the firm was found. Traders can complain through live chat, a phone line and a support email, and the firm replied publicly to 95% of negative Trustpilot reviews, typically within a week, and to 16 of the 20 most recent one-star ones.
Fix before issue
Publish a complaints route with a time to answer: none is stated.
Not settled by public evidence Regulator lists outside I-SCAN, such as those in Andorra, Saint Lucia and Dubai, which we did not search, and whether complaints sent privately get an answer, which needs the firm’s complaint records.
Wall Street Funded has not seen this view. It is not a review, a certificate, an approval or an endorsement, and what public evidence could not settle is never counted against the firm.
Checked against version 1.1 on , from public sources only
Nothing is not met, and “Who you are dealing with”, “Payouts are paid”, “Rules a trader can rely on”, “Fair enforcement, and a way to appeal” and “Honest claims” are conditional: a certificate shows those conditions, with a dated plan to close them within 90 days.
01Who you are dealing with
Conditional
The terms name one contracting company, AtmosFunded Ltd in Cyprus (HE471627), and the Cyprus register shows it registered since February 2025, under the earlier name TRX Capital Solutions Ltd until July 2025, with one director on record. But the footer says the trading is carried out exclusively by Atmos Global Ltd, a Comoros company on Mohéli that owns and operates the website, while the Cyprus company provides the challenges and payment services, and the terms say the account and platform come from an unnamed third-party broker. Atmos Global Ltd is on no register we could open, so which company a trader’s account sits with, and whether every company that sells to or pays traders is registered and active, is unclear. The help centre says Taurex fully owns and operates Atmos; no register we read names an owner.
Not settled by public evidence Whether Atmos Global Ltd is registered and active, which company holds a trader’s account and pays payouts, and who owns 25% or more of each company: the Cyprus register shows shareholders only in filed documents we did not buy, and the Mohéli registrar turned our requests away. The firm would have to share its ownership documents. The licence number in the footer is counted under honest claims, not here.
No public record shows Atmos payments: TheTrustedProp has no blockchain data for the firm, Prop Firm Match, which keeps payout records, turned our requests away, and the firm publishes only undated totals, $2.2 million and more on the home page and $2 million and more on the Nova page. Its stated times contradict each other: rewards processed within hours on the home page, which elsewhere says 2 to 5 business days, payouts in minutes on the promotions page, up to 3 business days in the terms and 2 to 5 business days after approval in the help centre. 13 of the 20 latest one-star Trustpilot reviews say payouts were refused, withheld or late, mostly without detail, and none shows a reply. The Cyprus company was registered in February 2025 and shows no filed accounts.
Fix before issue
Give one payout time on every page, counted from the request to money the trader controls: within hours and 2 to 5 business days on the home page, minutes on the promotions page, up to 3 business days in the terms.
Not settled by public evidence Whether a random sample of payouts requested in the last 90 days matches bank or blockchain records and reached traders within a stated time counted from the request, whether the payouts reviewers say were refused were due under the rules, and whether the paying company can cover what it owes.
Each program’s figures are published before purchase, in the plan selector and a dated help centre, and the terms are public. But rules that can cost a payout or an account changed in 2026 without a date or a word on which accounts they cover: the help centre’s Nova answer gained a cap of 1% risk per symbol per day and a drawdown lock at payout, absent from the copy archived on 9 March 2026 and present by its update of 4 October 2026; and Instant Funding, which paid on demand with no drawdown lock in January 2026, now pays every 14 days with the drawdown locked at the starting balance after a payout request.
Fix before issue
Bring the Customer Agreement up to date, or stop it prevailing over the site: dated 14 August 2025, it lists retired plans and prices, 30:1 forex leverage, a 5-minute news window, 3 profitable days per funded payout period and a 5-day first Instant payout.
Make its pages agree on the Nova drawdown, 8% in the rules table and a 6% floor in the drawdown-lock example, and stop describing 2-Step Plus, which is no longer sold.
Commit in its terms not to apply rule changes to accounts already bought: clauses 5.6 and 10.1 let fees, challenge parameters and terms change at any time.
Not settled by public evidence Whether any of these changes reached accounts already bought and cost a trader a payout, which would mean not met: the firm keeps no change log. Whether the agreement a Nova trader signs before funding is the published Customer Agreement or another document not public before purchase.
The firm says every breach brings an email with a detailed explanation of the reason, and its Complaints Policy promises a written answer within 4 weeks, accepting, offering redress or rejecting with reasons, after review by its Compliance Department. But that is the only way to have a decision looked at again: no appeal is named, the answer can take longer than 15 business days, and no outside body hears disputes. The terms let the firm decide at its sole discretion what is a prohibited practice, and clause 8.1 (xiii) lets it terminate an account and ban a trader permanently for unjustified negative advertising on social media or any public platform, though we found no case of it being used.
Fix before issue
Name the complaints route in the terms, which mention complaints only as grounds to stop serving a trader who disputes a payment.
Not settled by public evidence Whether every refusal, closure or cut names the rule and what the trader did in writing, as the firm says breach emails do, whether the evidence is kept and summarised on request, and whether complaints are decided by someone not involved in the original decision: that needs a sample of notices and complaint outcomes. Some one-star reviewers say support gave them no clear reason for a decision.
The footer and clause 2.6 of the terms say plainly that every account is simulated with virtual funds and that Atmos is neither licensed nor regulated. But other pages say otherwise: the help centre’s welcome answer says traders earn payouts while trading with real capital, the Instant Funding answer promises a live funded account from day one, the site’s FAQ says losses are covered by the firm, and the terms’ own preamble calls Atmos a company that invests its own capital and allocates it to traders. The same footer gives Atmos Global Ltd a licence number, BFX2025060, without naming who issued it, and the FAQ says Taurex’s licences give traders the assurance of regulated standards. Trustpilot withholds the firm’s rating for a breach of its guidelines and says it removed a number of fake reviews.
Fix before issue
Date its headline figures and make them agree: $2.2 million and more rewarded and 60,000 traders on the home page, $2 million and more paid on the Nova page, with no date or period.
Not settled by public evidence Whether Atmos corrects the real-capital and live-account wording within 30 days of our raising it; we have not raised it. Who issued licence BFX2025060: the footer does not say, the Mohéli registrar turned our requests away, and in June 2022 the Central Bank of the Comoros called a Mohéli licensing body fictitious. When Trustpilot first showed its notice.
No alert names Atmos Funded, atmosfunded.com or its companies in IOSCO’s I-SCAN database. Traders can complain through a published Complaints Policy, with an answer within 4 weeks, and through live chat, email, WhatsApp and phone. One alert is noted, not counted, because it does not name Atmos: since October 2025 Malaysia’s Securities Commission has listed Taurex, the broker Atmos says owns it, as carrying on unlicensed dealing in securities, and Atmos sells in Malaysia, with Malaysian payment methods and a Malay site, and offers to move payouts into Taurex accounts.
Not settled by public evidence Whether the Securities Commission’s alert on Taurex covers Atmos’s own offer in Malaysia, including payouts moved into Taurex accounts, and how Atmos explains it; regulator lists outside I-SCAN, which we could not search fully; and whether complaints sent privately get an answer, since none of the 20 latest one-star Trustpilot reviews shows a public reply.
Atmos Funded has not seen this view. It is not a review, a certificate, an approval or an endorsement, and what public evidence could not settle is never counted against the firm.
Checked against version 1.1 on , from public sources only
Nothing is not met, and “Who you are dealing with”, “Payouts are paid”, “Rules a trader can rely on”, “Fair enforcement, and a way to appeal” and “Honest claims” are conditional: a certificate shows those conditions, with a dated plan to close them within 90 days.
01Who you are dealing with
Conditional
The terms name one contracting company, Moneta Funded Ltd, Saint Lucia international business company 2025-00532, and the footer names it as the operator; Saint Lucia’s register lists it by name. Payouts can instead be moved to Moneta Markets Ltd, which the terms name with its number. But no owner or director of Moneta Funded Ltd is public, since Saint Lucia keeps them confidential. The firm names David Bily as its founder and chief executive, and the UK register shows him owning 25% to 50% of Moneta Markets’ UK company, which does not reach the Saint Lucia company.
Not settled by public evidence Whether Moneta Funded Ltd is active, when it was incorporated, who owns 25% or more of it and who its directors are: the register’s free search shows names only and Saint Lucia’s IBC law keeps directors and shareholders confidential, so the firm would have to share these.
No public record shows Moneta Funded’s payments: TheTrustedProp holds no blockchain data for it, and the firm publishes only a live counter of profits paid, a monthly figure and three payout certificates, none dated or audited. Its stated times are close but counted differently: the help centre says requests are usually processed within 24 to 48 business hours, the home page under 48 hours, and the terms process them on weekdays in a GMT+10 window, then allow up to 24 hours for crypto. A payout moved to Moneta Markets under the double-payout option becomes trading credit that cannot be withdrawn; that claim is counted under honest claims.
Fix before issue
Give one list of payout methods and fees: the terms describe bank wires with a fee of at least $20 and payouts by the method used to pay the fee, while the help centre lists only crypto, Rise and Moneta Markets.
Not settled by public evidence Whether a random sample of payouts requested in the last 90 days matches crypto, Rise or bank records and reached traders within the stated time, counted to money they control; whether payouts taken as Moneta Markets credit were ever paid out; and whether Moneta Funded Ltd can cover what it owes: we found no public accounts for it.
Each program’s limits are published before purchase, on the program pages and in a help centre, and the terms set out how each limit is measured. Recent changes are dated and apply by purchase date: Instant Funding’s 5% drawdown from 2 July 2026, the payout lock from 21 September 2026, and the revised 1-Step, whose earlier buyers keep their rules. But the Funded Trader Agreement a trader signs after passing is not public before purchase, rules that can end an account, such as the floating-loss caps, appear only in the help centre and the terms without a start date, and the revised 1-Step’s relaunch carries no date.
Fix before issue
Make its pages agree on news trading, the 1-Step’s maximum loss, the maximum allocation and the Sprint loss limits.
Commit in its terms not to apply rule changes to accounts already bought: clause 17.2 lets the firm change the terms at any time, and clause 17.2A lets changes apply differently to existing accounts.
Not settled by public evidence Whether any rule change in the last 12 months reached accounts already bought: the firm keeps no change log, the help centre shows relative update times, and only the home page of February 2026 could be compared, since the Internet Archive’s index of the help centre was offline.
Decisions are explained by category: in its public replies, and in emails traders quote or describe, the firm cites prohibited strategies or practices, layering, hyperactivity, tick scalping or coordinated activity, and once forged identity documents; no public reply names the trades concerned. No appeal or complaints procedure is published; the terms call the firm’s evaluation decisions final, let it refuse payouts at its sole discretion and end accounts for any reason. A decision can be looked at again informally: traders can write to support by live chat, email or the contact form, and one public reply says the firm is reviewing a disputed drawdown breach. And clause 5.4 lets the firm end an account without refund, and seek damages, over reviews or statements it judges harmful, though we found no case of it being used; two reviewers say the firm tried to have a review removed or offered a refund against its removal, which is not a termination or claim under the clause.
Not settled by public evidence Whether every refusal, closure or cut names the rule and the trades in writing, whether the evidence is kept and summarised on request, and who decides a disputed decision, and how fast: that needs a sample of notices and complaint outcomes. Also whether pending payouts were withheld from traders whose accounts were closed, as four of the 16 one-star reviews say, and whether a pending payout was offered only against a signed waiver, as two say.
The terms and footer say plainly that every account is simulated, that the firm is not a broker and that it provides no financial services, and no page we read claims a licence for Moneta Funded. But the home page offers real funding and says the firm provides the funds traders trade, the 1-Step page says a trader who passes goes live, and the About page says broker backing gives the firm real capital, beside a count of 5 global licences that it sets among Moneta Markets’ results. The home page also promises to double a payout moved to Moneta Markets, which the help centre says becomes trading credit that cannot be withdrawn. Trustpilot shows no withheld rating or fake-review warning.
Fix before issue
Date its figures and make them agree: more than $200K paid out monthly, 100,000+ traders, support 24/7 or 24/5, and a Moneta Markets track record of over a decade on some pages and 7+ years on the February 2026 home page.
Not settled by public evidence Whether the firm corrects these within 30 days of our raising them; we have not raised them. Trustpilot’s notices before 13 November 2026 were not checked in archived copies.
No alert names Moneta Funded, Moneta Funded Ltd or monetafunded.com in IOSCO’s I-SCAN database, and no other regulator warning naming the firm was found. Two alerts name the broker brand Moneta Markets as unlicensed, from the Securities Commission Malaysia in November 2024 and Ukraine’s NSSMC in May 2024; neither country is on Moneta Funded’s restricted lists, but the alerts name the broker, not the prop firm or its company, so they are noted, not counted. Traders can complain by live chat, email or the contact form, and the firm replied publicly to 63% of negative Trustpilot reviews and to 10 of the 16 one-star ones.
Fix before issue
Publish a complaints route with a time to answer: none is stated in the terms or the help centre.
Not settled by public evidence How the alerts naming Moneta Markets bear on Moneta Funded’s traders, whose payouts the firm offers to move into Moneta Markets accounts: a review would ask the firm to explain them. Regulator lists outside I-SCAN were not searched fully, and whether complaints sent privately get an answer needs the firm’s records.
Moneta Funded has not seen this view. It is not a review, a certificate, an approval or an endorsement, and what public evidence could not settle is never counted against the firm.
Checked against version 1.1 on , from public sources only
Nothing is not met, and “Who you are dealing with”, “Payouts are paid”, “Rules a trader can rely on”, “Fair enforcement, and a way to appeal” and “Honest claims” are conditional: a certificate shows those conditions, with a dated plan to close them within 90 days.
01Who you are dealing with
Conditional
The General Terms of October 2026 and the Instant Funding Agreement name Acello Ltd, company 12696083, as the company a trader contracts with, and the UK register shows it active since June 2020 with no accounts or confirmation statement overdue. Its directors are Lewis James Mansbridge and Will Shearer, and the register traces its ownership through Acello Group Limited to their holding companies, each 75% or more theirs. But the footer says the programs are run by IF Pro Ltd, a Saint Lucia international business company, and that Acello Ltd is only its payment agent, so which company contracts with and funds traders is unclear. Saint Lucia’s name search lists IF Pro Ltd, but its number, status and owners are not public.
Not settled by public evidence Which company signs for a program bought today, and who owns 25% or more of IF Pro Ltd and directs it: Saint Lucia keeps an international business company’s directors and owners off the public record, so the firm would have to share them. Whether IF Pro Ltd is active needs a paid registry search.
Crypto payouts can be traced: the firm publishes three payout wallets, and TheTrustedProp, a commercial tracker, counts 10,046 payouts worth $8.79 million verified on-chain, though the last it records is from 19 June 2026, while the firm reports $5.7 million paid in 2026. Bank payouts go through Rise and leave no public record. The firm states one time for every method, 48 business hours plus a business day at weekends, without splitting approval from sending. Acello Ltd, which pays, files unaudited accounts that we did not read. The payouts that recent reviews say were refused are counted under fair enforcement.
Fix before issue
Make the yearly payout figures on the home page add up to the total shown beside them: as shown they sum to $22,408,784, $1,002,678 more than $21,406,106.
Not settled by public evidence Whether a random sample of payouts requested in the last 90 days matches Rise or blockchain records and reached traders within 48 business hours of the request; which wallets have sent payouts since June 2026; and whether the paying company can cover what it owes, which its filed accounts or a statement of reserves would show.
Each program’s targets and limits are published before purchase in the website’s program selector and help centre, and the General Terms and the Instant Funding Agreement that bind traders are public. But no help-centre answer carries a date and no change log was found. A notice that leverage on metals, oil and indices is temporarily set to 1:5 on funded accounts carries no date and applies to accounts already bought; an archived copy shows it in place on 7 March 2026, and it still applies. We found no case of it costing a payout.
Fix before issue
Make the program selector and the help centre agree on the split add-on for IF Micro Lite and Two-Phase ZAR, and on the best-day limit for Two-Phase ZAR.
Commit in the terms not to apply rule changes to accounts already bought: clause 9.6 lets the firm change fees and parameters at any time, and clause 19.1 makes changes effective on notice.
Not settled by public evidence Whether any other change in the last 12 months, such as the move to the Lite programs or the open-loss limit with its cut to a 50% split, reached accounts already bought and cost a trader a payout, which would mean not met: only more archived pages or the firm’s records could show it.
In public replies to disputed closures and refused payouts, the firm usually names the rule, such as reverse trading, group hedging, copy trading or a shared IP address and VPN, and in one case says it emailed the trader the evidence, with screenshots of the trading it flagged. Eight of the 20 latest one-star reviews describe payouts refused, withheld or delayed. A complaint goes to a complaints team that promises a written outcome with its reasons once it decides, and by the end of 8 weeks either that or a letter explaining the delay, and one reply passes a disputed breach to the risk and technical teams; no appeal to someone not involved is described. The terms let the firm decide at its discretion what is forbidden, let either side end the agreement without a reason, and forbid public reviews that are unsubstantiated, not accurate or constructive and unnecessarily harmful to the brand; we found no case of that clause being used.
Not settled by public evidence Whether every refusal, closure or cut names the rule and what the trader did in writing, whether the evidence is kept and summarised on request, and who decides a complaint and how fast: that needs a sample of notices and complaint outcomes.
The terms, the footer and the help centre say plainly that every account is a demo account with fictitious funds and that the services are not FCA-regulated, and no page we read claims a licence; the Instant Funding Agreement discloses that the firm may copy traders’ simulated trades onto its own live account. But Trustpilot withholds the firm’s rating because of a breach of its guidelines and says it has removed a number of fake reviews.
Not settled by public evidence When Trustpilot’s notice was posted, which no archived copy we checked shows. Finance Magnates reported in April 2026 that IF Pro is registered and licensed in Saint Lucia as a CFD brokerage; the firm’s own pages make no licence claim and say IF Pro offers no brokerage on this website, so no claim is counted. We did not review the firm’s advertising.
No alert names Instant Funding, its website or Acello in IOSCO’s I-SCAN database, which carries warnings from regulators including South Africa’s FSCA; the only near match, an Alberta caution of October 2024 about Instant Funded Trader, concerns a different website. Traders can complain by email under a published complaints policy, as well as through live chat and support email. The firm replied publicly to 18 of the 20 latest one-star Trustpilot reviews, all but the two posted in the last day.
Fix before issue
Give one address for complaints: the complaints policy, the terms and the refund policy name three different ones, on three different domains.
Not settled by public evidence Regulator warning lists outside I-SCAN, which we did not search one by one, including South Africa’s, where the firm sells rand accounts; and whether complaints sent privately get an answer, which needs the firm’s complaint records.
Instant Funding has not seen this view. It is not a review, a certificate, an approval or an endorsement, and what public evidence could not settle is never counted against the firm.
Checked against version 1.1 on , from public sources only
Nothing is not met, and “Who you are dealing with”, “Payouts are paid”, “Rules a trader can rely on” and “Fair enforcement, and a way to appeal” are conditional: a certificate shows those conditions, with a dated plan to close them within 90 days.
01Who you are dealing with
Conditional
The terms name Lark Dashboards Inc., which they call a Canadian corporation registered in Quebec, at 3 Place Ville-Marie in Montréal, as the company that runs the services, under a brand licence from Lark Funding Inc., whose jurisdiction, address and number no page gives. Which company pays traders is unclear: the terms say Lark Dashboards Inc. conducts all payments, while the anti-money-laundering policy has Lark Funding Inc. verify traders before paying them. Neither is on Canada’s federal register, and no owner of either is named; the chief executive, Matthew Letourneau, is named in trade press.
Fix before issue
Give Lark Dashboards Inc.’s Quebec enterprise number in its terms and footer, which give none.
Not settled by public evidence Whether Lark Dashboards Inc. is registered and active in Quebec, who its directors are, and who owns 25% or more of each company: the Quebec register showed a browser security check we did not pass, and Lark Funding Inc.’s jurisdiction is unknown. The firm would have to share its ownership documents.
Payouts are requested from the dashboard and sent only through Riseworks, every 14 days on the evaluations and on demand, then every 30 days, on Instant. TheTrustedProp, a commercial site, counts 449 payouts worth $550,604.39 that it says it verified on-chain, the latest on 18 June 2026, without naming the wallet it tracks; the firm shows 17 undated payout certificates and says it has paid over $1 million, with no period. Its stated times disagree: the payouts answer says most are handled in under 6 hours but to allow up to 3 business days, while the Instant card promises payment the same day. No accounts of either company are public.
Fix before issue
Give one payout time on every page, counted from the request to money the trader controls: the Instant card says the same day, the payouts answer up to 3 business days.
Not settled by public evidence Whether a random sample of payouts requested in the last 90 days matches Riseworks or blockchain records, and how many reached traders within the stated time; whether the company that pays can cover what it owes; and whether the tracker’s count follows the firm’s own payment wallet.
Each program’s limits are on the home page and in help answers before purchase, most of them dated. But the trader agreement funded traders sign after passing is not public. The prohibited-strategies page, which sets the all-or-nothing ban and the $10,000 daily gain cap that decide payouts, shows no date and gives its margin thresholds as a general guideline the firm recommends, while saying it strictly prohibits all-or-nothing trading; in a reply of November 2025 the firm cited a 20% recommended margin threshold when refusing a payout, where the page now gives 50% for forex. The refusals the reviews describe cite margin use of 60% to about 95%, above both figures. And in February 2026 the firm told reviewers it had closed funded accounts on its discontinued 2-Step program, saying every requested payout was paid.
Fix before issue
Make its pages agree on drawdowns, restarts and the 1% limit: the home page promises static drawdowns and free restarts without conditions, and calls a per-trade limit a per-symbol one.
Remove the 2-Step from the payouts answer, which still lists it.
Commit in its terms not to apply rule changes to accounts already bought: clauses 1.4 and 8.1 let the firm change the terms and guidelines at its discretion.
Not settled by public evidence Whether the margin thresholds changed in the last 12 months, when, and for which accounts (so whether any payout was refused under a threshold stricter than the one published when the account was bought, which the evidence does not show, since every refusal cited margin use far above even today’s 50%); whether closing the 2-Step accounts cost any trader a payout, which two reviewers suggest and the firm denies, and which would mean not met. The Internet Archive was offline, so no archived copy was compared, and the firm keeps no public change log.
In its public replies to disputed refusals and closures the firm usually names the rule and what the trader did, such as margin use of 60% to about 95% or a 7% swing in 90 minutes, and in several it offered a free retake or a refund; a breach for inactivity can be lifted on request. But no complaints or appeal procedure is published: a breach of the terms or prohibited strategies brings a permanent ban, the terms let the firm block any trader at its sole discretion and end access without notice, one reply calls a closure final and another says the evidence cannot be shared. So a decision can be looked at again only informally. No term we read lets the firm act against a trader for public criticism.
Not settled by public evidence Whether every refusal, closure or cut names the rule and what the trader did in writing, whether the evidence is kept and summarised on request, and who decides when the firm looks at a decision again: that needs a sample of notices and complaint outcomes. One reviewer says payouts were held until reviews were left, which the firm denies.
The footer, the terms and the help centre say plainly that every account is a simulated demo account and that clients never trade live capital, and the firm says it is not regulated and needs no registration in Canada; no page we read claims a licence, a brokerage or real capital, or promises that payouts are never refused. Trustpilot showed no notice about fake reviews or a withheld rating on 13 November 2026. The home page’s claim that traders are 87% more likely to get paid rests on the firm’s own 2026 data, explained only in its terms.
Fix before issue
Show beside the home page’s 87% claim what it rests on: the firm’s own 2026 1-Step data against one industry benchmark, with 73.8% as the overall figure in its terms.
Say what licence the footer means when it says Lark Dashboards Inc. runs all services under license: it names no authority.
Not settled by public evidence Advertising beyond the pages we read, and whether the payout-rate figures in the terms match the firm’s records.
No alert names Lark Funding, its website or Lark Dashboards in IOSCO’s I-SCAN database, and none appears in the Canadian Securities Administrators’ investor alerts, which include Quebec’s AMF. The firm does not sell in Quebec, where its operating company is registered, and stopped new US sales in 2024. Traders can reach it by email, its help centre and Discord, and it replied publicly to 73% of negative Trustpilot reviews and to 18 of the 20 latest one-star ones.
Fix before issue
State a time to answer complaints: the contact page promises only a reply as soon as possible.
Not settled by public evidence National warning lists outside I-SCAN and the CSA, and whether complaints sent privately get an answer, which needs the firm’s complaint records.
Lark Funding has not seen this view. It is not a review, a certificate, an approval or an endorsement, and what public evidence could not settle is never counted against the firm.
Checked against version 1.1 on , from public sources only
Nothing is not met, and “Payouts are paid”, “Rules a trader can rely on”, “Fair enforcement, and a way to appeal” and “Honest claims” are conditional: a certificate shows those conditions, with a dated plan to close them within 90 days.
01Who you are dealing with
Met
The terms name Quantum SRL, Italian VAT number 03095010595, as the company that operates FuturesElite and the party to the whole relationship, and neither the terms nor the payout pages name any other company that sells to, funds or pays traders: approved payouts are credited in the firm’s own dashboard and sent through Rise or crypto. The EU’s VIES system shows the VAT number valid for Quantum Società a Responsabilità Limitata at Via Maira 13, Latina, and Italy’s company register lists a company of that name as registered, with its registered office in Latina (its free page shows no street). The people in charge are named publicly: the About page names Christian Habibi as co-founder and CEO and Artur S. Deshko as co-founder and COO.
Fix before issue
Give one registered address on every page: the numbered terms, VIES and the register say Via Maira 13, while the footer, the terms’ older first section and the site’s structured data say Corso G. Matteotti 61.
Not settled by public evidence Who owns 25% or more of Quantum SRL and who its directors are: Italy’s register shows them only in paid extracts, which were not opened, so the co-founders’ roles rest on the firm’s word. Which broker or clearing firm holds live accounts, and whose capital they trade: the help centre names none. How FuturesElite relates to FundedElite, a CFD firm whose site names a Saint Lucia company and the same co-founders, which the firm calls a separate business.
Public on-chain records show payouts being made: Payout Junction, a tracker that earns commission from some firms it lists, counts $9,993,313 across 5,642 payouts through Rise from November 2024 to 12 November 2026, $1,267,106 of it in the last 30 days. But the firm’s stated times contradict each other: the home page advertises a 24-hour average payout time and a public reply under 20 hours, while the help centre allows 24 to 72 working hours to review a request and then 1 to 3 business days to send it. Approved payouts first land as Elite Credits in the firm’s own dashboard, which is not yet money the trader controls, and part of a payout may be refunded to the trader’s card instead, by a route the trader cannot choose. Of the 20 most recent one-star Trustpilot reviews, 8 describe payouts refused, cut, held or not received; the firm replied to 6 of those 8, giving reasons such as hedging, cards in another person’s name or that the payout had been credited. Refusals on a stated rule are judged under fair enforcement.
Not settled by public evidence Whether a random sample of payouts requested in the last 90 days matches Rise, crypto and card records and reached traders within the stated time, counted to money they control: the tracker shows payments leaving, not when they were requested, and does not count card refunds or direct crypto. Whether Quantum SRL can cover the payouts it owes: its filed accounts are only in paid register extracts, which were not opened, and it publishes none.
Each family’s targets, loss limits, payout caps and splits are published by size in the help centre and at checkout. The terms say changes to program parameters do not affect services already bought and that payout conditions change only prospectively, and the help centre dates its cut-offs: Elite’s payout rule changed only for accounts bought from 25 June 2026, the scalping definition for accounts bought from 24 November 2025, and funded resets for Elite accounts created from 23 July 2026. But two documents that bind funded traders are not public before purchase: the funded trader contract signed after passing, and the supplemental terms that govern a move to live, which the terms let the firm make at any time. The rules for that move, added to the terms with the version dated April 2026 and set out in the help centre, carry funded profit over to live only up to a cap and do not say which accounts they cover. And a payout on any account can be paused for a case-by-case review of how profit is spread across trades, with no fixed cutoff.
Fix before issue
Make its pages agree on Prime’s payout buffer on 100K and 150K accounts, on Nitro’s evaluation days, consistency share and funded-account limit, and on the refund fee.
Remove the superseded first section of the terms, which still sends disputes to arbitration where the numbered terms send them to the court of Latina, and update the Evaluation Account page’s outdated reset prices and minimum days.
Not settled by public evidence What the funded trader contract and the live supplemental terms say. Whether the live conversion cap or the case-by-case payout review has been applied to accounts bought before they appeared: the firm keeps no change log, every help-centre article shows only a last-updated date between 13 October and 12 November 2026, and only the terms were compared with archived copies, which show the short terms of July 2025 replaced between 14 March and 18 July 2026.
A decision can be contested only informally: the help centre tells a trader who believes an account was flagged by mistake to send an appeal to Support, with no deadline and no decider named, and the terms offer only an attempt at amicable resolution before the Italian courts, which do not count. In its public replies to one-star reviews the firm usually names the rule it applied and what it found, such as hedging, IP sharing or cards in another person’s name, and in one reply it called its decision to end a trader’s collaboration final. Its terms make any attempt to threaten it with negative reviews, social media defamation or reputational harm to get round rules, obtain a refund or gain an advantage a material breach, and treat an unjustifiable complaint about fees as a breach that can end every account with a permanent ban: terms that can punish public criticism, though we found no case on record of a closure under them. Trustpilot’s warning about pressure on reviewers is counted under honest claims.
Fix before issue
Name the appeal route to Support in the terms, which mention none.
Not settled by public evidence Whether every refusal or closure notice names the rule and what the trader did, whether the evidence is kept and summarised on request, and whether appeals sent to Support are decided within 15 business days by someone not involved: that needs a sample of notices and appeal outcomes. Whether any trader lost an account or a payout for a review: one recent review says an account was cancelled for leaving one and another that accounts were locked until a review was removed, while the firm’s reply to the same reviewer’s other review gives IP sharing as its reason; if it were shown, this requirement would be not met. What the funded trader contract says about appeals.
The terms, footer and help centre say plainly that evaluation and funded accounts are simulated and that the firm is not a broker or a regulated provider, and it claims no licence; NFA’s records show no registration. But Trustpilot is withholding its rating because of a breach of its guidelines: on 13 November 2026 the profile warned that the company has been pressuring people to change or remove their negative reviews. A review platform withholding a rating over manipulated reviews in the last 12 months makes this requirement conditional under the method. The help centre says selected traders move to live accounts trading real capital; whose capital that is is noted under identity. Home-page figures disagree with each other: a largest single payout of $33,400 beside a payout card showing $24,000, while the tracker records larger payments. Its 24-hour payout claim is counted under payouts.
Fix before issue
Make the home page’s payout figures agree: its largest single payout is $33,400 in the figures and $24,000 on the payout card.
Not settled by public evidence When Trustpilot’s warning was first posted, which its notice does not say, and whether the practice has stopped. Whether the firm’s figure of $9.5 million paid out holds up: the only independent count is a commercial tracker’s. We have not raised any of these with FuturesElite.
No alert names FuturesElite, FundedElite or Quantum SRL in IOSCO’s I-SCAN database, which carries the warnings of Italy’s CONSOB among other regulators, and NFA’s records show no registration or action. Traders have a published way to complain: the support email in the terms, live chat and a contact form, with support advertised around the clock. Where complaints can be seen, they get an answer: the firm replied publicly to 10 of the 20 most recent one-star Trustpilot reviews, usually within a few days, and an unanswered public review is not by itself an unanswered complaint. Trustpilot’s withheld rating is counted under honest claims.
Fix before issue
Publish a complaints procedure and a time to answer.
Not settled by public evidence Whether most complaints sent by email or chat get an answer, which only the firm’s records can show; one recent review says emails went unanswered for nearly two months. Whether the firm’s model needs authorisation from the CFTC or an Italian or EU authority, a legal question public sources do not settle.
FuturesElite has not seen this view. It is not a review, a certificate, an approval or an endorsement, and what public evidence could not settle is never counted against the firm.
Checked against version 1.1 on , from public sources only
Nothing is not met, and “Who you are dealing with”, “Payouts are paid”, “Rules a trader can rely on”, “Fair enforcement, and a way to appeal” and “Honest claims” are conditional: a certificate shows those conditions, with a dated plan to close them within 90 days.
01Who you are dealing with
Conditional
The terms and funded terms name one company, Propr Limited, a British Virgin Islands company, number 2211330, registered at Trinity Chambers, Road Town, Tortola, as the supplier of the challenges and funded accounts; both say the merchant of record that settles payments, Odeonpay ALE S.R.L. (Paysagi), is not the supplier. Payouts come from wallets the firm lists as its own. But the BVI registry gives company records only on request and for a fee, so we could not confirm that the company is registered and active, and no owner or director is named publicly: the firm names its founder and chief executive, Louis Régis, and says it was built by XBorg and is backed by SwissBorg, with no stake given.
Not settled by public evidence Whether Propr Limited is registered and in good standing, and who owns 25% or more of it and sits on its board: the BVI registry sells search reports, whose listed contents name no owners or directors. Which company pays rewards: the funded terms do not name it. Paysagi’s country and registration are not given. The firm would have to share its ownership documents.
Public records show payouts being paid. The firm’s dashboard lists 7,194 payouts to funded traders, $4.00 million in all, each with its Ethereum transaction, and gives a median of 10 minutes from request to paid over all payouts (32 minutes 42 seconds over the last 7 days); the rulebook and help centre state one time, processed within 24 hours. Etherscan shows the payout contract, created on 7 May 2026, called from the wallet the firm names as its hot reserve, and the three payouts we opened there are USDC transfers of the listed amounts to outside wallets. Payouts go to a wallet the trader names, not one the firm runs. But the request times are the firm’s own records, and its ability to pay is shown only by a reserve of $283,000 it says is on-chain, against $1.13 million paid in the last 30 days; no accounts of Propr Limited are public.
Not settled by public evidence Whether the request times the firm publishes are accurate, and so whether at least 90% of a random sample of payouts requested in the last 90 days reached traders within 24 hours of the request; whether every approved request was paid; and whether Propr Limited can cover what it owes funded traders: that needs its records and accounts, or a reserve statement set against what it owes.
Each challenge’s targets, loss limits and payout rules are set out before purchase in a detailed rulebook with worked examples, the terms and funded terms are public, and the rulebook’s change log dates five changes from February to July 2026, three of them to how the daily loss limit is set. But archived copies show rules that can end an account with no payout added with no log entry, though the log says every rule change is documented with the date it took effect: a ban on hedging against outside exchanges between 20 July and 18 September 2026, and, between 6 and 25 October, bans on trading several accounts from one household, device or IP and on strategies hard to replicate in live markets, with both hedging bans widened to correlated assets. None says which accounts it covers; the rulebook keeps active funded accounts on the rules in force at activation unless otherwise stated, and says nothing about challenges already bought.
Fix before issue
Keep past change-log entries as published: the launch entry of 25 February 2026 gave 5x leverage on BTC and ETH in May 2026 and 10x by September.
Make the help centre and home page agree with the rulebook on leverage, the $300,000 funded cap, how the daily limit is measured and copy trading between one’s own accounts.
Make the rulebook agree with itself on what a payout does to the 2-Step high-water mark: section 7 resets it to the starting balance, section 11 lowers it by the amount paid.
Commit in the terms not to apply rule changes to accounts already bought: clause 14.1 lets changes take effect on continued use.
Not settled by public evidence Whether any of these bans, or the dated changes to the daily limit, was applied to accounts already bought in a way that cost a payout or an account, which would mean not met: only the firm’s records could show it.
The rulebook names the grounds for closing an account, and loss-limit breaches are automatic; but it says breaches cannot be appealed and enforcement decisions on prohibited conduct are final and not subject to appeal, and several grounds, such as strategies hard to replicate in live markets, set no measurable threshold. A decision can be looked at again only informally: the terms promise a written answer to an emailed complaint within 30 days, and in public replies the firm has offered refunds or resets for breaches it put down to platform latency and asked for details of a disputed evaluation. The terms let the firm terminate a trader’s agreements for acting in a manner that may damage its reputation, including after termination, and the funded terms add that pending rewards are then lost: wording broad enough to reach public criticism, though we found no case of it being used. The terms also let the firm stop serving a trader whose complaint it deems unjustifiable.
Not settled by public evidence Whether closure and refusal notices name the rule and what the trader did, whether the evidence is kept and shared on request, and who decides when a complaint challenges a decision, and how fast: that needs a sample of notices and complaint outcomes.
The terms, the disclosures on every page and the facts page say plainly that every account, funded ones included, is simulated, that Propr Limited is not a broker and is not licensed or regulated by any financial authority, and that trades copied to Hyperliquid belong to the firm; the facts page says Propr is not fully on-chain. But the product change log, in an entry of 7 April 2026 still published, restricts purchases in jurisdictions where Propr is not yet licensed, implying a licence it says it does not hold, and the transparency dashboard labels the simulated balances of funded accounts as $16.6 million of funded trader AUM, total capital under management. Trustpilot shows no warning about fake or manipulated reviews. The change log’s claim to document every rule change is counted under rules.
Fix before issue
Stop saying the two equity limits are the only guardrails, on the home page and in the rulebook: the rulebook lists twelve prohibited practices that can end an account with no payout.
Not settled by public evidence Whether Propr corrects these within 30 days of our raising them; we have not raised them. Whether Trustpilot showed a review warning at any time since the profile was claimed in April 2026: no archived copy was checked.
No alert names Propr or propr.xyz in IOSCO’s I-SCAN database; a search for Propr returns three alerts about other names, all dated before Propr launched. Traders have a published way to complain: by email under the terms, settled within 30 calendar days with a written confirmation, and through Discord. The firm replies to 100% of negative Trustpilot reviews, typically within 24 hours, and replied to all six of its one-star reviews.
Not settled by public evidence Regulator warning lists outside I-SCAN, which we did not search in full, and whether complaints sent privately get an answer, which needs the firm’s complaint records.
Propr has not seen this view. It is not a review, a certificate, an approval or an endorsement, and what public evidence could not settle is never counted against the firm.
Checked against version 1.1 on , from public sources only
6 requirements are conditional, more than the 5 the method allows.
01Who you are dealing with
Conditional
The terms name SWISS RLCRATES AG of Zug as the company traders deal with and as the party to the Final Stage agreement a trader signs after passing, and the Zug register shows it active since 26 March 2024, with a board member, Donovan Iker Rodriguez Durasno, and a manager, Olivier Cavadini. But the footer says the Swiss company acts as payment and marketing agent for RLCRATES, S.L., which provides the MetaTrader 5 service, so which company sells the evaluations, runs the accounts and pays traders is unclear. RLCRATES SL has been on the Navarra register since 2021; its sole shareholder and administrator on its founding is on record, but not its owner today. The firm names none of its people on its own pages.
Fix before issue
Name RLCRATES, S.L. and its register details in the terms, beside the Swiss company, since the footer already says it provides the MetaTrader 5 service.
Not settled by public evidence Who owns 25% or more of each company: the Swiss register does not list shareholders, and the Spanish gazette shows only the sole shareholder declared in 2021. Which company contracts with and pays traders, and whether RLCRATES SL is still active, which the Spanish register’s own extract would show. The firm would have to share its ownership documents.
No public record shows the firm’s payments: TheTrustedProp has no blockchain payout data for it and PropFirmMap’s trust check no payout data. The firm claims $22,216,359 paid in all and $401,754 last month, undated, and its reserve page links a CoinStats portfolio worth about €1.47 million that does not show whose wallets it tracks. The FAQ gives an average of about 8 hours and up to 48 business hours to review and send, but no time until the money reaches the trader for any method; in November 2025 it also promised arrival within 24 hours of sending. The terms let SWISS RLCRATES AG withhold an earned scholarship under unnamed circumstances; that term is counted under fair enforcement. No public review we read says an approved payout went unpaid; the refusals described are judged under fair enforcement.
Not settled by public evidence Whether a random sample of payouts requested in the last 90 days matches bank or blockchain records and reached traders within a stated time, and whether the company that pays can cover what it owes: the Swiss company opted out of an audit, and no accounts or statement of reserves checked by anyone outside the firm are public.
Each program’s rules are in the FAQ and terms before purchase, and when the 1-Step plans replaced the One Phase evaluation on 12 or 13 November 2026, the terms kept existing One Phase and Instant accounts on their conditions and add-ons. But the Final Stage agreement a trader signs with SWISS RLCRATES AG after passing is not public. And the same update added, undated and without saying which accounts it covers, a clause letting the firm compare funded-account trading with the evaluation and then hold back a payout, adjust the scholarship or apply its sanctions: an archived copy of the terms from the morning of 12 November 2026 does not have it. The terms also let the firm add restrictions to any account and change the terms at any time.
Fix before issue
Make its pages agree on minimum trading days (none in the program table, 5 a phase in the FAQ) and on leverage (1:100 on all instruments on the home page, as low as 1:5 on smaller accounts in the FAQ and terms).
Commit in its terms not to apply rule changes to accounts already bought: section 1.3 makes continued use acceptance of any change.
Not settled by public evidence What the Final Stage agreement says, and whether the new clause or any other change in the last 12 months has been used to refuse a payout on an account bought before it: the terms carry no version date, the firm keeps no change log, and archived copies of the terms from May, August and early October 2026 did not load.
The FAQ offers one route after a suspension: a funded trader whose trades all had stop-losses and risked at most 2%, and who traded 15 days, can ask within 7 days for a review paying up to 50% of the profit. In its public replies to disputed payouts the firm usually names the rule, such as the ban on sharing an IP address, and describes its review. But no complaints or appeal process is published; the terms let the firm withhold an earned scholarship under unnamed circumstances, refunding only the fee; and they forbid public statements disputing or criticising how the firm applies its rules to an account, with termination and the loss of returns as the sanction, though we found no case of it being used.
Not settled by public evidence Whether every refusal, closure or cut names the rule and what the trader did, in writing; whether the evidence is kept and summarised on request; and whether a decision can be appealed to someone not involved, within 15 business days. Three of the seven payout refusals among the 20 latest one-star reviews have no public reply, one saying no reason was given after an interview: only the firm’s notices could show what it said.
The home page, FAQ and terms say plainly that every account is demo, with no real capital, and the footer says SWISS RLCRATES AG is not authorised or licensed in Switzerland and conducts no regulated activities. We found no claim to a licence, to live capital or to guaranteed payouts; the terms say payment is not guaranteed. But Trustpilot withholds the firm’s rating for a breach of its guidelines and says it has removed a number of fake reviews for this company, a warning on the profile today.
Fix before issue
Make its figures agree and date them: the home page claims 99,000 traders educated and 98,000-plus traders, the Break page 56,000-plus; instrument counts differ between pages; and the totals paid carry no date or period.
Not settled by public evidence When Trustpilot acted and what the breach was: its notice gives no date or detail, and PropFirmMap, a commercial site, dates the withheld rating to 23 August 2026. We have raised nothing with the firm.
FINMA, the Swiss regulator, has listed “Cryptofundtrader”, www.cryptofundtrader.com, at Bahnhofstrasse 21, 6300 Zug, on its warning list since 23 August 2024, as a name not entered in the commercial register that may be providing services without authorisation; IOSCO’s I-SCAN carries it as an unregistered or unlicensed entity offering financial products or services. The firm is run from that Zug address and sets no country restriction on Match-Trader, so this is a market where it sells, and none of its pages explains the warning. No other alert names the firm or RLCRATES. Traders can complain by email, live chat or a contact form, and the firm has replied publicly to 69% of its negative Trustpilot reviews and to 11 of the 20 latest one-star ones.
Fix before issue
Publish a complaints procedure with a time to answer.
Not settled by public evidence Why FINMA listed the firm, and whether the firm is challenging the listing or has answered FINMA: we have not asked it to explain. FINMA says a listing does not by itself mean the activities are unlawful. Whether complaints sent privately get an answer, which needs the firm’s records.
Crypto Fund Trader has not seen this view. It is not a review, a certificate, an approval or an endorsement, and what public evidence could not settle is never counted against the firm.
Checked against version 1.1 on , from public sources only
Nothing is not met, and “Who you are dealing with”, “Payouts are paid”, “Rules a trader can rely on” and “Fair enforcement, and a way to appeal” are conditional: a certificate shows those conditions, with a dated plan to close them within 90 days.
01Who you are dealing with
Conditional
The terms name WEN LTD, registration number 2025-00872, at the Sotheby Building in Rodney Bay, Gros-Islet, Saint Lucia, as the company that runs the site and its services, and name no other company that sells to, funds or pays traders. Saint Lucia’s register of international business companies lists Wen LTD. by name in its free search. But the contact page gives a Dubai headquarters with no company named, no page says which company pays rewards, and no owner or director of WEN LTD is named. The firm’s blog names four founders by one name each; the About page shows four people whom Maven Trading’s own site names as its chief executive and senior officers, with no role at WEN LTD stated.
Not settled by public evidence Whether WEN LTD is active and when it was registered, which needs a paid register search, and who owns 25% or more of it and directs it: Saint Lucia keeps an IBC’s shareholders and directors confidential, so the firm would have to share its documents. Whether a Dubai company sells to, funds or pays traders, and which company pays rewards.
No public record shows WenCrypto paying anyone: the firm publishes no total or count, TheTrustedProp has no blockchain data and no payout-denial reports for it, and PropFirmMap shows no payout record. The firm states how often a payout can be requested, every 10 business days, but names no payout method and states no time from a request to money the trader receives. The terms make transfers subject to minimum payout thresholds that no page states; that is counted under rules.
Fix before issue
Give one payout rule on every page: the home and pricing pages say a trader can withdraw at any time, the FAQ every 10 business days.
Not settled by public evidence Whether a random sample of payouts requested in the last 90 days matches bank or blockchain records and was paid within a stated time, and whether WEN LTD can cover the payouts it owes: it files no public accounts. The firm’s Discord, where payouts may be posted, needs a login and was not read.
Each program’s targets, loss limits and split are published before purchase on the pricing page and in the FAQ, and archived copies show the Single and Double Pass rules and the terms unchanged since March 2026. But the Buy Now Pay Later split, 100% on the page archived on 11 July 2026, was 80% by 30 September with no date and nothing saying which accounts it covers. The terms, last amended on 19 February 2026, do not mention Buy Now Pay Later, make transfers subject to minimum payout thresholds no page states, and let the firm limit a trader to 1% risk for excessive trading or require consistency scores on accounts they do not name.
Fix before issue
Make its pages agree on the funded Buy Now Pay Later drawdown (static on the pricing card, trailing in the FAQ), on inactivity (28 days in the FAQ, 30 calendar days in the terms) and on fee refunds (Refundable on the cards and after three withdrawals in the FAQ, non-refundable in the terms).
Commit in its terms that changes never apply to accounts already bought unless they favour the trader: clause 16 lets it change the terms at its sole discretion.
Not settled by public evidence Whether the cut from 100% to 80% reached Buy Now Pay Later accounts already bought, and whether any payout was refused under the unstated minimum threshold; either would make this not met. The firm keeps no change log, so only its own records could show it.
A decision can be looked at again only informally: the terms send any dispute first to an informal solution within 30 days, then to mediation, binding arbitration and the courts of Saint Lucia, and publish no appeal of a closed account or a withheld payout. Prohibited activity ends an account at once and the firm may close one as it deems appropriate, with nothing saying the trader will be told the rule and what they did. And clause 14 says defaming WEN LTD on social media or review sites will lead to account termination, without defining defamation, while support exchanges must be kept confidential; we found no case of it being used.
Not settled by public evidence Whether refusal and closure notices name the rule and what the trader did, whether the evidence is kept and shared on request, and who looks again at a disputed decision and how fast: that needs a sample of notices and complaint outcomes. No public complaint about a refusal or closure was found.
The terms, FAQ, risk disclosure and home page say plainly that every account is a demo account with simulated funds and that payouts are real. The firm claims no licence or regulator, and says it is not an exchange and holds no client deposits; its AML policy names Saint Lucia’s Financial Services Regulatory Authority and Financial Intelligence Authority only as the bodies whose requirements it follows. No review platform has withheld a rating or warned about its reviews: it has no Trustpilot profile, and its Feefo page carries no notice.
Fix before issue
Show only testimonials about WenCrypto: three of the five on its home and About pages praise Maven or Maven Trading.
Publish the data on evaluation success rates, breaches and payouts that its home page promises, or drop the promise.
Make its home page agree with its FAQ and line-up: it offers assets from stable coins to altcoins and Instant Funding, while the FAQ excludes stablecoins and no instant program is sold.
Not settled by public evidence Seven of its eight Feefo reviews are labelled incentivised, which Feefo does not explain; that is not a platform warning. We have not raised any of these points with WenCrypto.
No alert names WenCrypto in IOSCO’s I-SCAN database; a search for Wen LTD returned only four unrelated firms and one for Maven Trading none, and no other regulator warning naming the firm was found. Traders can raise a problem through the support email in the terms, a contact form, a chat button and Discord, and the terms give an informal resolution step of 30 days. No public complaint was found unanswered: the firm has no Trustpilot profile, it replied to 7 of its 8 Feefo reviews, and TheTrustedProp lists no payout-denial reports.
Fix before issue
Publish a complaints procedure with a time to answer: the contact page promises only an answer as soon as possible.
Not settled by public evidence Whether most complaints made by email, chat or the form get an answer, which needs the firm’s records; there is no public sample of complaints to test. Regulator lists outside I-SCAN were not searched in full.
WenCrypto has not seen this view. It is not a review, a certificate, an approval or an endorsement, and what public evidence could not settle is never counted against the firm.
Checked against version 1.1 on , from public sources only
Nothing is not met, and “Who you are dealing with”, “Payouts are paid”, “Rules a trader can rely on” and “Fair enforcement, and a way to appeal” are conditional: a certificate shows those conditions, with a dated plan to close them within 90 days.
01Who you are dealing with
Conditional
The terms name Traders Launch LLC, at 1700 Market Street, Suite 1005, Philadelphia, as owner of the site and the company traders deal with, and say payouts are funded by it; the rules, payout, Facts and partner pages name no other company that sells to, funds or pays traders. But the firm’s pages name no owner, member, manager or executive, and do not say where the company is registered. The only names on record come from a 2023 podcast page calling Max Thomas co-owner and cofounder with Connor Holly, and a comparison site calling him founder and chief executive, so the people in control are not named publicly by the firm or a register.
Fix before issue
Show the state where Traders Launch LLC is registered and its company number on its own pages, beside the name and address its terms already give.
Not settled by public evidence Whether Traders Launch LLC is registered and active, and where: Pennsylvania’s business register returned an access-blocked page to a browser and to an automated request, Florida’s register has no company of that name, Wyoming’s search did not finish and OpenCorporates showed a bot check. Who owns 25% or more and who runs it, which the firm would have to show. Who runs the crypto accounts and the October 2026 Hyperprop drop, which the pages do not say; nothing public says another company pays those traders.
No public record shows Traders Launch’s payments: it publishes no total or count, PropFirmMap shows no payout records and TheTrustedProp no payout totals or records. The current pages state no time from request to money received for any method, crypto, ACH or wire. Until late October 2026 the home page said crypto and ACH payouts were processed every 24 hours and wires weekly, and the rules page promised same-day processing; those statements are gone. On public evidence payouts are paid: 5 of the 12 most recent Trustpilot reviews mention payouts received, and none of the 5 one- and two-star reviews says an approved payout went unpaid. The company publishes no accounts.
Not settled by public evidence Whether a random sample of payouts requested in the last 90 days matches bank, payment-provider or blockchain records and reached traders within a stated time: that needs the firm’s records, and its pages now state no time. Whether Traders Launch LLC can cover the payouts it owes. The terms’ clause on partner-referred traders is counted under fair enforcement.
Each program’s target, drawdown, contract limit and split is on the price cards, and the rules, payout and FAQ pages and the terms are public before purchase. The split chosen at purchase is kept, and the firm says Legacy NYC and Early Access accounts keep their rules. But the contract traders sign after passing is not public. And between 24 October and 13 November 2026 the futures rules page, still shown as last reviewed on 16 July 2026, added a rule that can end an account: holding or opening an index future within 2% of CME’s daily price limit is a breach. Neither it nor the FAQ says from when it applies or to which accounts, and the terms make every change effective at once for existing users. The same edit dropped the 3-day minimum and turned the $100,000 payout pause into a review of up to 5 business days.
Fix before issue
Commit in its terms that rule changes never apply to accounts already bought unless they favour the trader: the terms make every change effective at once for existing users.
Make the FAQ agree with the price cards and payout rules on when the first Premium payout can be requested: after a buffer account and a contract, or once the funded account is above +1%.
Not settled by public evidence What the contract signed after passing says. Whether the price-limit rule, or the end of the scaling to 15 minis offered until mid-2026, has been applied to an account bought before it and cost a payout, which would mean not met: the firm keeps no change log, and only its records could show it. Two other captures of the rules page, of 18 June and 6 November 2026, were not opened.
No public page offers an appeal. The terms and FAQ set out no way to contest a closure or a refused payout; an unhappy buyer can email support, which says it will try to resolve the matter, and the firm answers by email and in Discord. The terms do not declare decisions final, and accounts flagged by the HFT filter or for averaging are paused for a review, so a decision can be looked at again only informally. The rules are numeric, and in one public reply the firm explained the end-of-day drawdown rule it had applied. No term lets the firm refuse a payout or close an account for public criticism. But the terms let it end a membership for any reason, and say users introduced through a partner program may not be eligible for payouts on simulated profits without saying which; we found no case of it being used.
Not settled by public evidence Whether every refusal or closure notice names the rule and what the trader did, whether the evidence is kept, and whether a written appeal is decided within 15 business days by someone not involved: that needs a sample of notices. What the contract signed after passing says about reviews or criticism. Which partner-referred traders may be refused payouts.
The footer, the terms and the Facts page say plainly that evaluation and funded accounts are simulated and that no order reaches a live market, and the firm claims no licence or registration; NFA’s records show none. Payouts are described as real but not guaranteed. Archived home pages of May and June 2026 said the firm had never denied a payout and showed zero denials, which no record we found contradicts; the current home page no longer says so. Trustpilot showed no notice about fake or manipulated reviews on 13 November 2026. The FAQ’s price range of $49 to $599 leaves out Static accounts that cost up to $679.
Fix before issue
Make the FAQ’s price range, $49 to $599, include the Static accounts, which cost up to $679.
Not settled by public evidence Whether the firm has in fact never denied a payout, and whether its archived payout figures, such as a highest payout of $54,500 and a ticker in which every payout read processed in about 6 hours 12 minutes, were accurate: only its records could show it. Whether Trustpilot showed a notice at any time in the last 12 months, which was not checked. We have not raised any of these with Traders Launch.
No alert names Traders Launch or its website in IOSCO’s I-SCAN database, and NFA’s records show no registration or action. Traders can complain by email to support, by a refund request marked Dissatisfied Purchase, or in Discord, where the firm says staff answer every day. Where complaints can be seen, about half get a public answer: Trustpilot shows replies to 50% of negative reviews, typically within 24 hours, and the firm replied to 2 of its 5 one- and two-star reviews. An unanswered public review is not by itself an unanswered complaint.
Fix before issue
Publish a complaints procedure with a time to answer.
Not settled by public evidence Whether most complaints sent by email or in Discord get an answer, which only the firm’s records can show. Whether the firm’s model needs CFTC registration, a legal question public sources do not settle.
Traders Launch has not seen this view. It is not a review, a certificate, an approval or an endorsement, and what public evidence could not settle is never counted against the firm.
Checked against version 1.1 on , from public sources only
Nothing is not met, and “Who you are dealing with”, “Payouts are paid”, “Rules a trader can rely on”, “Fair enforcement, and a way to appeal” and “Honest claims” are conditional: a certificate shows those conditions, with a dated plan to close them within 90 days.
01Who you are dealing with
Conditional
The Terms of Use in the help centre name Day Traders LLC, a Nevada limited liability company at a Las Vegas address, and say funded accounts are traded with the trading capital of Day Traders under separate written agreements. But the user agreement that every page of the site links as Terms names no company and puts claims under Delaware law, and both documents extend to unnamed affiliates. The live page offers a live brokerage account backed by real firm capital without naming the broker or the account holder, so which company funds live traders, and through whom, is not settled by public pages. Card payments are processed by Collecto, Inc. and payouts sent through Plane, both named as service providers. The founder and chief technology officer, Leo Riot, and the co-founder and chief operating officer, Martin Montaño, are named on the About page, and the US trademark register records the Day Traders name as owned by a Texas trust whose trustee is Leo Riot.
Not settled by public evidence Whether Day Traders LLC is registered and active in Nevada, and who its managers and members are: Nevada’s business search showed an hCaptcha check that we did not pass, and OpenCorporates showed a reCAPTCHA. Who owns 25% or more of it. Which broker holds live accounts and in whose name, and what the Pro Account Agreement and the live account agreement, which are not public, name as their counterparty.
The firm states times for parts of the route but not the whole of it in one place: approval is automated in the standard case, with an average of 32 minutes on the payouts page; payouts approved before the daily reports load are reflected the same day; live payouts are processed from 11:00 AM to 4:00 PM ET on business days; and only the payouts page’s answers say most traders receive funds through Plane 1 to 3 business days after approval, a time the help centre does not give. A payout can also be taken as DT Wallet credit the firm runs, which cannot be withdrawn as cash. On public evidence payouts are paid: the firm’s ledger lists 25 approved payouts from 6 to 12 November 2026 totalling $40,950, its press releases give totals of $1 million, $2 million and $3 million in that order, 6 of the 20 most recent Trustpilot reviews mention payouts, and none of the 20 most recent one-star reviews says an approved payout went unpaid. The ledger is the firm’s own record, and no independent payout record was found. Withholding half of a large payout when a trader is moved to live is counted under rules.
Fix before issue
Give the time from approval to the trader’s bank in the help centre as well as on the payouts page.
Not settled by public evidence Whether a random sample of payouts requested in the last 90 days matches bank or Plane records and reached traders within the stated time, which needs the firm’s records. Whether Day Traders LLC can cover the payouts it owes: it publishes no accounts, and its register could not be read.
Each plan’s rules are published by size before purchase, in help articles updated from 22 October to 5 November 2026 whose figures match the home page. But the Pro Account Agreement signed at activation and the live account agreement signed after S2L are not public. And in the last 12 months rules that can cost an account or part of a payout appeared without a date or a statement of which accounts they cover: the inactivity rule shown in August 2025, one trade in any 30 days, had by 14 February 2026 become four days in every rolling 30 days each making a minimum profit for one-time accounts, with idle accounts closed for good, and four one-star reviews from February 2026 say rule changes closed accounts already bought; and by June 2026 the payout FAQ said that a trader moved to live at the firm’s discretion receives half of a payout of $10,000 or more, the rest becoming the live account’s maximum loss, where in February traders went live after six payout milestones. Other changes favoured traders: up to 15 funded accounts in place of 5, and no $150,000 cap on lifetime withdrawals on current pages.
Fix before issue
Make the Terms of Use agree with the help centre on holding positions past 5:00 PM and on what a daily loss breach does.
Commit in its terms not to apply rule changes to accounts already bought: today the Terms of Use let trading rules change with or without notice.
Not settled by public evidence Whether any of these changes was used to refuse a payout on an account bought before it appeared, which would mean not met: the firm keeps no change log, it told the reviewers it had no record of them, and the help centre was republished under new addresses in October 2026. What the Pro and live agreements say.
Reasons are set out only by category: the help centre says a confirmed prohibited strategy closes every account involved and forfeits its unpaid profit, and the Terms of Use let the firm remove profits, delete trading days, reset accounts or ban users at its sole discretion, with no stated duty to say what the trader did. No appeal is published, but no term or help page declares decisions final, and a decision can be looked at again informally by asking support: in public replies the firm has invited traders to open a new ticket about a disputed liquidation, and offered to review a household flag with verification. The Terms of Use also let the firm restrict an account without notice or refund for conduct that may cause it risk of reputational damage, with no threshold, a term that could reach public criticism, though we found no case of it being used; separately they let it bar anyone who disparages it from its prize promotions.
Not settled by public evidence Whether refusal and closure notices name the rule and what the trader did, whether the evidence is kept and shared on request, and who decides a second look and how fast: that needs a sample of notices and complaint outcomes. Whether the Pro and live agreements, which are not public, provide an appeal or a term on public criticism.
The help centre says plainly that evaluations, Pro Accounts, S2F accounts and S2L evaluations are simulated and that only live accounts trade in live markets, and the Terms of Use say the firm is not a broker-dealer; it claims no licence, and NFA’s records show none. But other pages say otherwise: the home page tells traders “We fully fund your account” under the heading “Your Journey. Our Capital.”, and the Customer Compensation Disclosure on every page says Pro Level Accounts may consist of simulated, live or mirrored trading accounts, claims of real capital that the firm’s own rules contradict; while the Risk Disclosure says the firm offers no real-money trading accounts though it sells live S2L accounts. The payouts page calls every payout verified without saying by whom. No review platform was found withholding a rating or warning about fake reviews: Trustpilot showed no notice on 13 November 2026, nor on an archived copy of 2 January 2026.
Fix before issue
Give one Trustpilot rating and one country count: the home page shows 4.7 against 4.6 on Trustpilot, and both 40+ and 100+ countries.
Give one founding year: the About page says 2023 and the founder’s page 2025.
Not settled by public evidence Whether DayTraders.com corrects these claims within 30 days of our raising them; we have not raised them with the firm. Whether Trustpilot showed a fake-review notice between January and November 2026: the later archived copies did not load. Who, if anyone, verifies the payout ledger and the totals.
No alert names DayTraders.com, Day Traders or Leo Riot in IOSCO’s I-SCAN database, and NFA’s BASIC database holds no record of the firm. Traders have a published way to complain: live chat and Discord on the contact page, advertised as available 24/7, and the help desk. Where complaints can be seen, they get an answer: Trustpilot shows replies to 90% of negative reviews, typically within a week, and the firm replied publicly to 19 of the 20 most recent one-star reviews, though 11 of those replies say only that it could not find a record of the reviewer as a customer.
Fix before issue
Publish a complaints procedure with a time to answer.
Not settled by public evidence Whether most complaints made through chat and the help desk get an answer, which only the firm’s records can show. Whether the firm’s model needs CFTC registration, a legal question public sources do not settle.
DayTraders.com has not seen this view. It is not a review, a certificate, an approval or an endorsement, and what public evidence could not settle is never counted against the firm.
Checked against version 1.1 on , from public sources only
Nothing is not met, and “Who you are dealing with”, “Payouts are paid”, “Rules a trader can rely on”, “Fair enforcement, and a way to appeal” and “Honest claims” are conditional: a certificate shows those conditions, with a dated plan to close them within 90 days.
01Who you are dealing with
Conditional
The prop trading terms name one company as the program’s provider and the payer of compensation from its own funds: Vest Exchange Inc., a Panama corporation, under Panama law, and the platform’s general terms name the same company. But the terms give no company number or address, and Panama’s Public Registry opens only with a login, so we could not confirm that it is registered and active. The footer of every page names Vest Labs Inc., which the New York register shows as a Delaware corporation formed on 31 March 2022 and active in New York since November 2024; its LEI record says it has no parent and is owned by natural persons, whom it does not name. The press names Justin Ma as chief executive and co-founder, with two other co-founders. How the two companies are related is not public.
Not settled by public evidence Whether Vest Exchange Inc. is registered and active, with which number and directors; how it relates to Vest Labs Inc. and whether either sells to or pays traders through another company; and who owns 25% or more of each. The firm would have to share its ownership documents. The statements that traders trade real capital are counted under honest claims, not here.
On public evidence payouts are paid. DamnPropFirms, an affiliate site, counts $39.2 million in 42,368 withdrawals to 12,366 wallets from Vest’s bridge contracts since 1 July 2026, though it can tell funded-account payouts from ordinary exchange withdrawals only by its own rules; the firm told Fortune that about 26% of its 27,000 traders had received a cash payout by late September; 11 of the 12 five-star Trustpilot reviews praise its payouts, and none of the 24 reviews describes a payout refused. But the stated times contradict each other: the home page says payouts hit the wallet immediately, while the docs give 24 hours for a claim to reach the Primary Account, a balance held on Vest’s own platform, and a further 24-hour processing period for every withdrawal to an outside wallet. The terms let the firm hold payouts during an investigation with no time limit, and say compensation is paid from general corporate funds that fees help supply.
Fix before issue
Give one payout time on every page, counted from the claim to money in the trader’s own wallet: the home page says payouts arrive immediately, the docs 24 hours to the Primary Account and a further 24-hour processing period to withdraw.
Not settled by public evidence Whether a random sample of claims made in the last 90 days matches blockchain records and reached wallets the traders control within the stated time, which needs the firm’s records; and whether Vest Exchange Inc. can cover what it owes, as it publishes no accounts or statement of reserves.
Each program’s loss limits are published before purchase with their formulas, and the prop terms dated 9 November 2026 promise reasonable advance notice of material changes, apply them only to future activity, and rule out using them on completed activity or to cut compensation already earned. The exchange notices date leverage and market changes. But a program rule that can cost an account changed without a date: in September 2026 the docs set the daily limit at 4% of the balance plus half of any open profit at the evening snapshot, and they now measure it from the reset balance with open profit left out, with no notice saying when this changed or which accounts it covers. The terms also let Vest model slippage and the price impact of a trader’s own orders, which can decide a breach, without saying how these are set.
Fix before issue
Make the docs’ Account Tiers page match the configurator: it lists targets of 10% or 20%, a 3% or 4% daily limit, a fixed 6% drawdown, 80% or 90% splits and accounts up to $25,000, where the configurator offers 5% to 20%, up to 5%, 6% to 8%, 70% to 95% and $50,000.
Commit in its terms that rule changes apply only to accounts bought after them unless they favour the trader: section 6(r) lets material changes reach future activity on accounts already bought, after notice.
Not settled by public evidence Whether any change in the last 12 months reached accounts already bought and cost a trader a payout, which would mean not met: the firm keeps no change log for program rules, the Internet Archive holds no earlier copy of the prop terms, and only the firm’s records could show it.
The prop terms promise that when compensation is withheld, cut or denied after a review, the firm keeps the records, gives a reasonably specific explanation and lets the trader ask for a review by email, and that suspension or closure alone does not forfeit compensation already earned; they also commit the firm not to invent a violation or worsen a profitable trader’s fills. But the review has no deadline and no stated decider independent of the first decision, and payouts can be held during an investigation with no time limit. Loss-limit breaches close accounts automatically: in September 2026 the docs said there was no recovery or appeal process, and they still say a breached account cannot be recovered. No term lets the firm act against a trader for criticising it; one bans conduct detrimental to the firm without saying what counts.
Fix before issue
Name the review in the docs, which still say a breached account cannot be recovered; only the terms offer one, by email to team@vest.exchange.
Not settled by public evidence Whether refusal and closure notices name the rule and what the trader did, whether reviews are decided within 15 business days by someone not involved, and whether a breach caused by the firm’s own pricing faults or modelled price impact can be looked at again: that needs a sample of notices and review outcomes. None of the 12 negative Trustpilot reviews carries a public reply, so they show nothing either way.
The prop terms and the disclosure on every page say plainly that every account, Instant and live funded ones included, is simulated, that no real capital is credited and that payouts are program compensation from the firm’s general funds. But the docs say a live funded account trades real Vest capital, not simulated, the funding page’s FAQ says an Instant account trades real capital funded by Vest Capital, and Fortune’s October 2026 report on the firm describes traders using company money in real markets. The home page also lists Coinbase among its backers, which no press report we read names, and in May 2026 it listed Citadel, HRT and BlackRock, where the docs now say executives of those firms invested. No licence or regulation is claimed, and Trustpilot shows no warning about the firm’s reviews.
Fix before issue
Make its figures agree: the home page’s FAQ gives 28 days for a refund where the terms and docs give 3, and the funding page gives splits from 70% where the docs give 80% or 90%.
Not settled by public evidence Whether Vest corrects the real-capital statements within 30 days of our raising them; we have not raised them. If they stay up after that, the method rates this requirement not met. Whether Trustpilot warned about the firm’s reviews at any time in the last 12 months: the Internet Archive holds no copy of the profile.
No alert names Vest Markets, Vest Exchange, Vest Labs or vestmarkets.com in IOSCO’s I-SCAN database; a Malta warning from December 2024 about Vestmarket Trade concerns a different website. No other regulator warning naming the firm was found. Traders can complain through the platform’s chat and the support email, and the terms send disputes to a published address for up to 90 days of informal talks before arbitration. Publicly, the firm has answered none of its 12 negative Trustpilot reviews, and two say support took days to reply; an unanswered public review is not by itself an unanswered complaint.
Fix before issue
Publish a complaints procedure and a time to answer.
Not settled by public evidence Whether most complaints made through chat and email get an answer, which needs the firm’s records, and regulator lists outside I-SCAN, which we could not search fully. The general terms bar US and UK residents from the platform while the prop terms do not; whether the program needs a licence where it sells is a legal question public sources do not settle.
Vest Markets has not seen this view. It is not a review, a certificate, an approval or an endorsement, and what public evidence could not settle is never counted against the firm.
07
What each version changed
Each draft was tested on real firms before the next, and what the test showed is published here. Version 1.0 named the people and put the method in force.
Version 1.1
1.1 raises the limit on conditions from 3 to 5 and gives every certificate a grade out of six. The six requirements, the process and the people are unchanged.
A firm can be certified with conditions with up to 5 of the 6 requirements conditional, where 1.0 allowed 3; at least one must be met. Every condition still needs a dated plan to close it within 90 days, or the certificate is suspended.
Every certificate shows a grade: each requirement met counts 1 and each conditional counts ½, out of six. It is worked out from the levels and is never a score.
Checked again against 1.1 from public sources, nine of the ten research passports are certifiable with conditions in our view, from 3.5 to 4.5 of 6; Apex Trader Funding is not, because fair enforcement is not met. Our view is not a review, and nothing has been issued.
Version 1.0
1.0 puts the method in force and names who reviews, decides and hears appeals. The six requirements, the counting rules and the three outcomes are unchanged from draft 0.4.
Reigo Tooming reviews and Reiko Tooming decides; neither decides a firm they reviewed. Both declared no stake in, job at or account with any firm we cover.
One person decides, where draft 0.4 had two deciders and a third to break a tie: no second person checks a decision before it is made.
Appeals are heard by Reigo Tooming, who reviewed the firm but did not decide. Draft 0.4 asked for an outside appeal reviewer; we have none yet.
Certification is open: we start reviews ourselves, one firm at a time, and a passport says when its firm is under review.
Reviews carry no fee. Draft 0.4 allowed one if it was the same whatever the outcome.
Draft 0.4
Drafts 0.1 to 0.3 were set by ten of the largest firms. For 0.4 we checked ten mid-size and small firms against draft 0.3 from public sources, forex and futures, from one whose contracting company reports a single employee to one reported to have about 150 staff. None was certifiable outright, four were certifiable with conditions and six were not; nothing was not met. Fair enforcement was conditional at all ten, and payouts came out met at all ten although no public evidence can show the matched sample the method asks for. These are the changes they led to.
Firms no longer apply. We start each review, ask the firm only for what public evidence cannot settle, and judge a firm that does not answer on public evidence alone.
One reviewer checks a firm and two people who did not review it decide; a third breaks a tie. An outside reviewer hears an appeal. The firm has a right of reply before any decision.
Payouts can only be met on records: a sample that grows with the firm, timed from the trader’s request to money the trader controls, from a company shown able to pay what it owes.
One fact counts as one condition. Two firms crossed the limit because one fact about who funds their accounts was counted under two requirements.
Requirements look back 12 months, so terms rewritten weeks before a check do not erase what came before, and a new rule that can cost a payout is never housekeeping.
A claim to a licence is checked against the regulator’s own record wherever it is made, including in the terms; a review platform’s fake-review warning counts under honest claims.
Fair enforcement covers cut profit shares as well as refusals, needs the rule and what the trader did rather than a category, counts terms that punish public criticism, and is not met only where a firm offers no way at all to have a decision looked at again; going to court or arbitration is not a way to contest one.
Standing now has a level for a regulator’s warning the firm has not explained, and for a firm that answers only some complaints.