Public Evidence Standard
What the public record can show about a prop firm.
Our own standard for assessing prop firms from public evidence alone. It checks what a firm publishes, what official records say about it, and what the record shows going wrong. It never asks a firm for private records, and it states what public evidence can never establish.
What it is, and what it is not
Every result, issued or not, carries these four sentences.
- It is our assessment of public evidence under our own published standard. It is not a licence, not an accreditation, and not approval by any regulator or public body.
- It does not guarantee that payouts are paid, that the firm can pay what it owes, or how the firm will behave in future.
- It does not verify the firm’s internal records or operations, or anything the firm has not published.
- The firm did not request it, pay for it, or take part in it, unless the record says otherwise.
The six requirements
Each requirement is met only when every check is satisfied and no failure condition applies. A check our research has not settled leaves it open, never failed.
Requirement 1
Who you are dealing with
Can a trader tell, from public records, which company they deal with and who runs it?
Every check must be satisfied
- 1.1The firm names at least one company as the provider of the service or the party traders contract with, in the terms a trader accepts or on its legal pages (legal notice, imprint or site footer). Named only outside the terms, it is disclosed.
- 1.2Each company named under 1.1, for the products in scope, appears in an official public company register as existing and not dissolved, under the name and details the firm gives. A register that charges a fee is still public: until its extract is read, the check is not established.
- 1.3At least one person in control, a director, officer or owner, is named in a public register or on the firm’s own pages.
Any of these fails it
- 1.G1A company the firm names as its provider or contracting party is dissolved, struck off or in liquidation, or the register contradicts the details the firm gives, and the firm still names it.
- 1.G2The only register listing a company the firm names is run by a body an official authority has publicly called unauthorised or fictitious.
Disclosed, not failed, for example
- Several companies are named and the terms do not say which one contracts with or pays traders.
- The company is named on the firm’s legal pages but not in the terms themselves.
- The owners are not on any public register.
- Companies serving some countries could not be verified: their products are left out of scope.
Never established
- Who ultimately owns the firm, unless a public register shows it.
- Who funds the payouts, and the companies’ finances.
Requirement 2
Payout terms and the public payout record
Can a trader see before buying how and when payouts are made, and does any public evidence show approved payouts going unpaid?
Every check must be satisfied
- 2.1Payout eligibility is published before purchase: when a first payout can be requested, the profit split, minimums and caps, and every condition that can stop a payout.
- 2.2The payout methods and any fees are published.
- 2.3The firm states how long it takes to handle a payout request.
- 2.4Evidence from outside the firm shows it paying traders in the last 12 months: a third-party record of payments, such as a tracker reading a public blockchain or payment platform, or payment reports from at least 10 different traders in all, on at least 2 platforms the firm does not control. The firm’s own totals, and posts by its affiliates or ambassadors, never count.
Any of these fails it
- 2.G1The firm has announced a halt or suspension of payouts that is not resolved.
- 2.G2The company that pays traders, or if none is named the contracting company, is in insolvency, liquidation or administration on an official record.
- 2.G3Public evidence shows approved payouts going unpaid: at least 5 different traders reporting, within any 90 days of the last 12 months, an approved payout not received 30 days after the firm’s stated time, and not shown resolved; or a court, a regulator or independent investigative reporting documenting it.
Disclosed, not failed, for example
- No time is stated for some payment methods or products, or the stated times contradict each other.
- Payouts are first held in a wallet the firm runs, paid as credit, or split into instalments.
- Traders report payouts paid late.
Never established
- That every eligible trader was paid.
- How many payout requests are approved or refused.
- That the firm’s published payout totals are complete or accurate.
- That the firm can afford what it owes.
- How long payouts take in practice.
Requirement 3
Rules a trader can rely on
Can a trader read, before buying, every rule that can fail them, close their account or cost them a payout, and see when those rules change?
Every check must be satisfied
- 3.1Every rule that can fail an evaluation, close an account, or reduce or withhold a payout is published on pages a trader can read before buying.
- 3.2The terms that bind a trader when they buy a product can be read before paying: on the firm’s pages, or at checkout before payment. A product whose binding terms cannot be read before paying is left out of scope; if no product is left, the check is not satisfied.
Any of these fails it
- 3.G1In the last 12 months, the firm refused a payout or closed an account under a rule not published when the trader bought, or applied a change to deny a payout earned under the earlier rule, shown by the firm’s own statement, an authority, independent reporting, or consistent, documented accounts from at least 3 different traders.
- 3.G2Rules that can fail an evaluation, close an account or cost a payout changed without a dated notice, change log or dated version, and silent changes of the same kind were disclosed at the previous assessment.
Disclosed, not failed, for example
- A rule that can fail an evaluation, close an account or cost a payout changed without a dated notice, change log or dated version.
- An agreement a trader signs later, such as for a funded account, is not public, though its material terms are.
- The terms let the firm change rules for accounts already bought.
- A change that worsened terms reached accounts already bought, without refusing a payout.
Never established
- How rules are enforced inside the firm.
- What documents the firm does not publish say.
- That rules will not change.
Requirement 4
Fair enforcement and a way to contest
Does a trader know what will cost them an account or a payout, and can they contest such a decision with the firm?
Every check must be satisfied
- 4.1The prohibited practices, and what happens to a trader who breaches them, are published.
- 4.2A trader has a published, written way to raise a closure or a refused payout with the firm itself: a complaint, review or appeal by email, form, ticket, or a support channel the firm does not exclude for such decisions. Courts and arbitration do not count.
- 4.3No published term or page declares enforcement decisions final with no review of any kind.
Any of these fails it
- 4.G1The firm closed an account or refused a payout because the trader criticised it publicly, shown by the firm’s own statement, an authority, independent reporting, or consistent, documented accounts from at least 3 different traders.
- 4.G2A court, a regulator or independent investigative reporting finds that the firm refused payouts or closed accounts without a basis in its published rules.
Disclosed, not failed, for example
- No time limit is stated for deciding a contested decision, or no one independent of the first decision is named.
- A term lets the firm act against a trader for criticism or for harming its reputation.
- Accounts from at least 3 different traders describe closures or refusals without a stated reason.
Never established
- Whether a decision was fair in any one case.
- Whether notices give the rule and what the trader did.
- How contested decisions turn out.
Requirement 5
Honest claims
Does the public record contradict what the firm claims about itself?
Every check must be satisfied
- 5.1The firm’s terms say whether the accounts traders buy are simulated or live, and on what basis any live account is offered.
- 5.2Every claim the firm makes to be licensed, registered, regulated or approved by an authority or exchange matches that body’s own public record. Where the record shows the licence for the named company but not a detail such as its number, the claim matches.
- 5.3The firm’s profiles on the main review platforms were read for notices about fake or manipulated reviews.
Any of these fails it
- 5.G1A claim of a licence, registration, regulation or approval is contradicted by the authority’s own record, or rests on a body an official authority calls unauthorised or fictitious, and is still published.
- 5.G2A claim still on the firm’s own channels says payouts are guaranteed, never refused or never denied, or that the firm is a regulated fund, broker or bank, and the firm’s own terms or an official record contradict it, without the claim saying plainly what it covers.
- 5.G3A review platform has said publicly, in the last 12 months, that the firm itself broke its rules by buying, incentivising, faking or manipulating reviews.
- 5.G4A contradiction disclosed under this requirement at the previous assessment is still published at the next scheduled one.
Disclosed, not failed, for example
- The firm’s own pages contradict each other on a point covered by this requirement, such as a claim that traders trade the firm’s real capital where its terms say the accounts are simulated.
- A review platform removed fake reviews without saying who wrote them.
- A claim of approval could not yet be matched to the body’s record.
Never established
- Advertising, social media and affiliate content beyond the firm’s own site, terms and help centre.
- Performance figures the firm publishes, such as trader counts and pass rates.
Requirement 6
Regulatory standing and complaints
Does any authority warn against or act against the firm where it sells, and can a trader complain to it?
Every check must be satisfied
- 6.1Searched: IOSCO’s I-SCAN database, and the warning list or register of the regulator in the home country of each company named under 1.1, where one exists.
- 6.2Traders have a published way to complain to the firm.
Any of these fails it
- 6.G1A regulator or court has an active ban, enforcement action or order against the firm or a company named under 1.1, in a market where the firm sells.
- 6.G2A regulator’s public warning naming the firm alleges fraud or a scam, beyond operating without authorisation, in a market where the firm sells.
Disclosed, not failed, for example
- A regulator warns that the firm is not authorised, in a market where it sells. In a market its terms exclude, the warning is noted, not disclosed.
- A regulator acted against the firm in the last three years, and the action is resolved.
- No time is stated for answering complaints.
Never established
- How many complaints the firm answers or resolves.
- Regulators’ private inquiries.
- Whether the firm’s business needs a licence anywhere: that is a legal question.
How the outcome is decided
An assessment takes the result of its weakest requirement. No score enters it, and a strong result elsewhere cannot make up for a failure.
- Meets the standard
- Every check of every requirement is satisfied, no failure condition applies, and nothing firm-specific needs disclosing. The standard’s limits still apply.
- Meets the standard, with disclosures
- Every check is satisfied and no failure condition applies, but the record holds concerns, contradictions, unpublished details or terms a trader should know. Each is shown with the result, and the result is never shown without them.
- Assessment incomplete
- No failure condition applies and nothing the public record shows fails a check, but at least one check is not established: our research has not settled it, or the firm’s public record is too short. It says which, and it is never a finding against the firm.
- Requirements not met
- The public record shows a failure condition, or a check not satisfied. It names each one. A firm can fix what is in its control and ask to be assessed again.
Evidence and sources
Every answer in an assessment names the class of its evidence and cites its sources. Absence of evidence is never read as proof either way.
- Verified public record
- Confirmed by a public record kept independently of the firm: a company register, a regulator’s register or publication, a court record, or a platform’s own notice about the firm, such as a review platform’s warning on its profile.
- Published by the firm
- Published by the firm in its terms, website or help centre. It shows what the firm says and commits to, not that it is true in practice.
- Corroborated
- Supported by at least two relevant sources that are independent of each other and of the firm, such as independent reporting, a third-party payment record or consistent accounts from different traders.
- Documented concern
- A material problem supported by reliable evidence: an authority’s publication, the firm’s own statements, or corroborated accounts. A firm disputing it does not remove it; its reply is recorded beside it.
- Unresolved contradiction
- The firm’s own statements, or the firm and an official record, say different things on a point that could change a trader’s decision.
- Not publicly established
- Public sources do not settle it. It is never read as true, and never read as false.
Sources, strongest first
- A. Official records
- Company registers, regulators’ registers, warnings and decisions, court records. Decisive for what they record.
- B. The firm’s own documents
- Terms, product and payout pages, help centre, notices, and archived copies of them. Decisive for what the firm publishes and commits to; never proof that it does it.
- C. Independent reporting and third-party data
- Named outlets and authors, trackers reading public payment records, review platforms’ own notices. Strong, checked for independence from the firm.
- D. Identifiable customer accounts
- Reviews and posts by named or long-standing accounts. Evidence of a pattern only when several independent accounts agree; one account never establishes a fact.
- E. Anonymous allegations
- Leads to investigate. Never decisive on their own.
How an assessment is made
We start every assessment
Firms do not apply and are never asked for private records. An assessment needs nothing from the firm.
Public evidence only
Each check is answered from official records, the firm’s own published documents and archived copies, independent reporting and traders’ public accounts, weighted by source.
Scope stated, never stretched
A result covers the products and companies the assessment lists. A product whose binding terms are not public, or that is sold by a company we could not verify, is left out and named as left out.
Two people
One person assesses and records the evidence for every check. A different named person approves a designation. Neither may have a tie to the firm.
Firms may write to us, never pay us
A firm may send a correction, a public clarification or new public evidence, contest a finding, or ask to be assessed again. What it sends is checked like any other evidence; a private document never replaces public evidence or widens what a result claims.
Money changes nothing
Assessments carry no fee. Affiliate links, commissions, sponsorship and investment interest have no bearing on a result, and any tie is shown on the record.
After a designation
Reassessment
Every designation is reassessed within six months, and lapses after twelve unless reassessed.
Withdrawal
It is withdrawn at once when a failure condition is confirmed, and within 14 days when a new check is shown not satisfied.
Corrections and appeals
We answer a correction or a request to be reassessed within 14 days, and publish what changed. An appeal is heard by a named person who did not approve the decision.
History
Every result, every change of status and the evidence behind it stay on record. Earlier versions of the standard and their results are kept, labelled with their version.
